Greatest Sharks Team

[Super Impose]

Another player who was not a great but a very very good footballer for several seasons - Mark Wakefield.

Waka was improving so fast before being on the end of a savage act of foul play and was never the same again ...

 

[HaroldBishop]

Another player who was not a great but a very very good footballer for several seasons - Mark Wakefield.

Waka was improving so fast before being on the end of a savage act of foul play and was never the same again ...

Yep agree on that.

Pretty sure that happened at Belmore?

 

[Super Impose]

Yep agree on that.

Pretty sure that happened at Belmore?

Correct - similar to Sludge....

 

[HaroldBishop]

Correct - similar to Sludge....

Yep, was Turvey on Wakefield from memory, I was there with my old man.

 

[Super Impose]

Yep, was Turvey on Wakefield from memory, I was there with my old man.

Mortimer got 9 weeks - an indication of the serious nature of the incident - sickening...

 

[snowman]

i'll give it a crack, based on the eye test from players i have seen in their prime

1 - Ben Barba
2 - Mat Rogers
3 - ET
4 - Jack Bird
5 - Val Holmes
6 - James Maloney
7 - Preston Campbell
8 - Jason Stevens
9 - Michael Ennis
10- Andrew Fifita
11 - Luke Lewis
12 - Wade Graham
13 - Paul Gallen

14 - Chris McKenna
15 - Greg Bird
16 - Kade Snowden
17 - Brett Kimmorley

 

[snowman]

can we all do a failed potential 17 now?

 

[Sir Chadley]

can we all do a failed potential 17 now?

1. Dustin Cooper
2. Stewart Mills
3. Karl Filiga
4. Josh Hannay
5. Jarrod Anderson
6. Scott Gustard
7. Tim Smith/Scott Porter
8. Kade Snowden
9. Paul Aiton
10. Josh Cordoba
11. Broderick Wright
12. Talimai Tautai
13. Ken Ebb

14. Lancen Joudo
15. Dayne Weston
16. Luke Harlen
17. Darren Mapp

There’s easily another two teams you could pick.

 

[snowman]

1 - Nathan Gardner
2 - Nathan Stapleton
3 - Karl Filiga
4 - Matt Parata
5 - Stewart Mills
6 - Albert Kelly
7 - Chad Townsend
8 - Jacob Selmes
9 - Lancen Joudo
10 - Siosaia Vave
11 - Brod Wright
12 - Taulima Tautai
13 - Kyle O'Donnell

14 - Don Tweedle
15 - Sam Wessel
16 - Luke Harlen
17 - Brett Kearney

 

[Sir Chadley]

1 - Nathan Gardner
2 - Nathan Stapleton
3 - Karl Filiga
4 - Matt Parata
5 - Stewart Mills
6 - Albert Kelly
7 - Chad Townsend
8 - Jacob Selmes
9 - Lancen Joudo
10 - Siosaia Vave
11 - Brod Wright
12 - Taulima Tautai
13 - Kyle O'Donnell

14 - Don Tweedle
15 - Sam Wessel
16 - Luke Harlen
17 - Brett Kearney

Some good names there mate but you can’t have a premiership winning halfback in your failed potential team. It just isn’t on ok.

I predict that one day you and CT are going to be room mates in the same nursing home.

 

[stormshark]

Bit hard on Scotty Porter and Dane Westen. That Tautai however would be the Worst Bumbler in the BWB of ALL time. He should be an emergency like when they name 21- he should be 21!

 

[Gards]

Yea I dunno if I can think of a worse Sharks player who played more than just a game or 2 than TT - he was so ****ing bad, like all time bad. scored a try once though

what about KFCuthbo - was meant to be amazing, his career Sharks highlight was an offload

 

[Sir Chadley]

Here’s our all time list of players to choose from:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Cronulla-Sutherland_Sharks_players

 

[PMQ_Tony]

1. Dustin Cooper
2. Stewart Mills
3. Karl Filiga
4. Josh Hannay
5. Jarrod Anderson
6. Scott Gustard
7. Tim Smith/Scott Porter
8. Kade Snowden
9. Paul Aiton
10. Josh Cordoba
11. Broderick Wright
12. Talimai Tautai
13. Ken Ebb

14. Lancen Joudo
15. Dayne Weston
16. Luke Harlen
17. Darren Mapp

There’s easily another two teams you could pick.

A bit harsh on Ken Ebb haha

 

[snowman]

Some good names there mate but you can’t have a premiership winning halfback in your failed potential team. It just isn’t on ok.

I predict that one day you and CT are going to be room mates in the same nursing home.

why not? shane perry was in brisbanes

chad was a junior roo, junior nsw half and has played no rep games and is the second least deserving half to win a premiership behind perry

he hasnt evolved since he was 22

 

[snowman]

Some good names there mate but you can’t have a premiership winning halfback in your failed potential team. It just isn’t on ok.

I predict that one day you and CT are going to be room mates in the same nursing home.

also the knights ran a poll on who was the one player that never kicked on for them - sean rudder

look him up

 

[Sir Chadley]

A bit harsh on Ken Ebb haha

Maybe. But he was talked about highly when he came into grade but didn’t aim up.

 

[stormshark]

Yea I dunno if I can think of a worse Sharks player who played more than just a game or 2 than TT - he was so ****ing bad, like all time bad. scored a try once though

what about KFCuthbo - was meant to be amazing, his career Sharks highlight was an offload

100% ALL time bad, very apt. That try- I nearly fainted in disbelief. As for Cuthbo- Avalon Bull dogs jnr, not bad for Manly, thought he would be good for us. Lazy, soft etc etc .Terrible as well, and was in an ordinary side from memory.

 

[Sir Chadley]

why not? shane perry was in brisbanes

chad was a junior roo, junior nsw half and has played no rep games and is the second least deserving half to win a premiership behind perry

he hasnt evolved since he was 22

I’m taking the mickey mate, settle Gretel.

 

[HaroldBishop]

A bit harsh on Ken Ebb haha

Went with the flow a bit too much for my liking.