Sir Chadley
Jaws
Maybe. But he was talked about highly when he came into grade but didn’t aim up.
Greatest Sharks Team
- Thread starter deano the p
- Start date
Maybe. But he was talked about highly when he came into grade but didn’t aim up.
stormshark
Jaws
100% ALL time bad, very apt. That try- I nearly fainted in disbelief. As for Cuthbo- Avalon Bull dogs jnr, not bad for Manly, thought he would be good for us. Lazy, soft etc etc .Terrible as well, and was in an ordinary side from memory.
Sir Chadley
Jaws
HaroldBishop
Megalodon
Went with the flow a bit too much for my liking.
snowman
Total gronk
reminds me of peewee moke
snowman
Total gronk
tautai had moments where you just thought, if he could get his **** together he would be decent
unfotunately, never happened for him here, but he has had quite the career in england
cuthbo is another, he was about 5 years too early for himself. the original ball play prop of the modern era but again just never got himself together
another who has had a fantastic career in england
Super Impose
Great White
If he had played his whole career outside of Joey , he might have kicked on ...
PMQ_Tony
Tiger Shark
Actually you are probably correct Chad, I didnt read the criteria correctly. Sorry mate.
I know you hate Chad Snowy but hard to go past Tim Smith for 7?
40 try assists in his debut season! If he could have got close to that number consistently he'd have been an absolutely elite half
Most TAs in last few years is 25, have to go back to JT in 2015 to get above 30 (33) and JT also had 28 in 2014, and he is generally considered a pretty good half.
40 try assists in his debut season! If he could have got close to that number consistently he'd have been an absolutely elite half
Most TAs in last few years is 25, have to go back to JT in 2015 to get above 30 (33) and JT also had 28 in 2014, and he is generally considered a pretty good half.
sharks86
Grey Nurse
Wow some names on that list are best forgotten they ever pulled on the jersey for us!
snowman
Total gronk
I change my lock to Trent Grubb
Tatus
Not-So-Great White
I’ve gone wasted potential/complete fails
1 Ben Barba
2 Leon Bott
3 Stewart Mills
4 Karl Filinga
5 Jacob Gagan
6 Tim Smith
7 Brett Seymour
8 Jesse Sene-Lefao
9 Anthony Watts (didn’t want to put Tony Caine here)
10 Luke Douglas
11 TT
12 T-Rex
13 Cuthbo
Hm* Dean Collis, Corey Hughes, Jono Wright, Blake Ayshford, Albert Kelly (at FB)
LD a fail. You serious?
Tatus
Not-So-Great White
Wasted potential. Was on the cusp of a blues jersey then went to the titans. Nuff said
snowman
Total gronk
yeh he was a fail
sure he played a lot of games consecutively but he achieved nothing in his career
BurgoShark
Super Moderator
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2008
- Messages
- 12,868
- Reaction score
- 4,097
How did Brett Kearney make your team snowman? Wasted potential? He was killing it until injury wiped him out.
HaroldBishop
Megalodon
Sure was, big fan of his.
snowman
Total gronk
thats why his potential was wasted
snowman
Total gronk
yeh i was a huge fan of his, but after 2008 his potential left
sharks86
Grey Nurse
Agree, loved watching him play but was prone to an injury