I have no real preference on Carney either coming or not. I don't think it's stupid to sign Todd and I don't think it's stupid not to sign Todd.
What WOULD be stupid to me would be to sign Todd...and then give him an entrapping range of restrictions, particularly a drinking ban. That's like waiting for the Sun to rise in the East or for the zebra to pop out without stripes. It isn't going to happen and expecting it to is moronic. This isn't a rehab center (an argument that works both in his favor and against). You have to accept that IF you sign Todd you do so warts and all. Again, I don't have a real preference on it and haven't voted in the poll, but IF the Club were to sign Todd I hope there would be a realization that you're getting sixty cents on the dollar for him. I'm interested to see how it plays out.