Should we sign Carney or not? Yes or No?

[Sir Chadley]

There has been some discussion now in the rumour mill on Todd Carney, so I thought I would put it out there in a poll.

So, yes or no. Straight answer. Should we sign Todd Carney? Feel free to explain your thoughts.

In a post on the rumour mill I stated I have no problem signing him as long as we don't lose homegrown talent.

 

[snowman]

yes, sign him... would become the best half at the club straight away, and the 2nd or 3rd best player at the club straight away

 

[Fitzy2513]

No.
The risk of him dragging the club down, far outweigh any positives he brings to the team on the paddock.

 

[bluey]

I have done a back flip here and say give it a go with a tight hold.

 

[Killer5]

This could be a very very stupid move.. Sign a centre!!!! I will stop supporting if this happens...

 

[snowman]

soft

 

[Blix]

definately sign him!!!!

 

[sharkyboy]

yes please.

 

[Mark^Bastard]

I say no.

 

[Ibanez]

I'm still sitting on the fence with this one.

 

[sharkboy18]

No way, as wat Fitzy said, it could bring our club into turmoil if he drinks again, he is a talent yes but we dont want to risk our club going into disrepute because of this guy, he has far too many chances and he does it again and again so i say no

 

[Christo]

I sign him. Take the risk we need attacking players like him.

 

[sharks4ever]

yes

 

[Deleted member 3365]

Yes, Kelly and Carney in the halves is stupid to ignore. The attacking potential is just immense. TWO x-factors in the halves, Carney has a long kicking range to.

I think Townsend will need a year in NSW cup like Daly Cherry-Evans.

 

[sharkyboy]

he is so dangerous in attack when hes on, when he runs the ball, if he has gards feeding off him, carney will draw in defenders, he can go wide, run himself or pass it on the insdie. he is also very ****ing fast. ran down stuart mills

 

[andrew's_sharks]

Incentive based deal. 2 years. One year with the 2nd year option in the clubs favour. If for a reasonable price then yes, otherwise stay away from him.

 

[Fitzy2513]

I am extremely interested in what Fitz and Iron have to say.

 

[SF]

I would sign him if David Gallop agreed to it, as he would only agree to it under the right conditions. I'm not worried if we don't.

Having said that I thought we should sign Tahu :ridiculed

 

[andyshark]

This could be a very very stupid move.. Sign a centre!!!! I will stop supporting if this happens...

The thing is this is called "sharks forever". I say no to carney & spend the money elsewhere, but I'll support the club 100% no matter who plays for us.

 

[greenie1957]

There has been some discussion now in the rumour mill on Todd Carney, so I thought I would put it out there in a poll.

So, yes or no. Straight answer. Should we sign Todd Carney? Feel free to explain your thoughts.

In a post on the rumour mill I stated I have no problem signing him as long as we don't lose homegrown talent.

i will say yes to this one, kelly at 5/8 carney at half graham at lock ( townsend, another year in the lower grade) this half combo is too good to ignorelets hope he doesn't stuff up on the drink,gal to keep him in line