Proud Shark
Jaws
- Joined
- Feb 3, 2015
- Messages
- 8,360
- Reaction score
- 2,662
Thought he was great tonight. Left it all out there. Would have been nice to have had the challenge for his knock on. Looked like it could have been stripped.
Official Toby Rudolf
- Thread starter snowman
- Start date
Blue_Eyes84
Bull Shark
Great game on Saturday night. Too bad it wasn't enough for a win. He did what he could, though.
Probably too tired. Plus with the ball still in play he had to get back and defend.
Gards
Jaws
'loose carry'
Toby gets some serious leg drive going in tackles , made some strong runs again and gets the crowd into it a bit when he does it
BurgoShark
Super Moderator
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2008
- Messages
- 12,868
- Reaction score
- 4,097
Toby Rudolf - 2023
Consistent season from Toby. I'd say there was two games where his involvement was down (Rd20 and Rd24). Otherwise he was outstanding. An amazing performance considering the injury he was dealing with.
He definitely played too many minutes in the finals game, but I can't really hold that against Fitz. There was no BHU, no Finucane, an injury to Hazelton early in his stint, and two of the guys on the bench were Coquhoun and an underdone Kaufusi.
The comparison charts are where Toby really stands out...
(* apologies to the colourblind. Had to use orange. Starting to run out of colours. If you want to see a specific comparison once I'm finnished I can re-format Toby v another player in different colours).
I'll drop the full running comparison charts in the Fancy Stats thread, but these are the most relevant for Toby.
#1 - Involvement
On average, Toby does as much work as any other middle (so far) but does it for longer. Only Colquhoun (in very limited minutes) was more heavily involved in the play.
#2 - Attacking Trend
* excludes finals game
Up to ~35 minutes of ball in play (about 50 minutes of game time) Toby doesn't slow down. He'll take as many runs as anyone who is playing more than 15 minutes.
#3 - Defensive Trend
* excludes finals game
Toby makes as many tackles as any other player (so far), and does it for longer.
#4 Runs inside own 40 Trend
* excludes finals game
Toby takes more runs inside his own 40 than Kaufusi and Hunt, more than Hazelton if he plays longer than 15 minutes, and is on par with Williams.
Consistent season from Toby. I'd say there was two games where his involvement was down (Rd20 and Rd24). Otherwise he was outstanding. An amazing performance considering the injury he was dealing with.
He definitely played too many minutes in the finals game, but I can't really hold that against Fitz. There was no BHU, no Finucane, an injury to Hazelton early in his stint, and two of the guys on the bench were Coquhoun and an underdone Kaufusi.
The comparison charts are where Toby really stands out...
(* apologies to the colourblind. Had to use orange. Starting to run out of colours. If you want to see a specific comparison once I'm finnished I can re-format Toby v another player in different colours).
I'll drop the full running comparison charts in the Fancy Stats thread, but these are the most relevant for Toby.
#1 - Involvement
On average, Toby does as much work as any other middle (so far) but does it for longer. Only Colquhoun (in very limited minutes) was more heavily involved in the play.
#2 - Attacking Trend
* excludes finals game
Up to ~35 minutes of ball in play (about 50 minutes of game time) Toby doesn't slow down. He'll take as many runs as anyone who is playing more than 15 minutes.
#3 - Defensive Trend
* excludes finals game
Toby makes as many tackles as any other player (so far), and does it for longer.
#4 Runs inside own 40 Trend
* excludes finals game
Toby takes more runs inside his own 40 than Kaufusi and Hunt, more than Hazelton if he plays longer than 15 minutes, and is on par with Williams.
Last edited:
Good news. How much $$?
Super Impose
Great White
Wow - that’s a massive vote of confidence from the coach ..
Tiger Shark
Jaws
Good news, now for mine the trick is we need to recruit so that he's no longer our best prop, he's our second best.
Sparkles
Jaws
- Joined
- May 21, 2008
- Messages
- 12,125
- Reaction score
- 2,855
Think I said earlier that Toby should aim to become our new Fifita. If not, I'm saying it now
He's getting the body shape, has decent footwork and speed and used to have an offload (?)
I'm sure he'll enjoy stacking on the extra 10kgThink I said earlier that Toby should aim to become our new Fifita. If not, I'm saying it now
He's getting the body shape, has decent footwork and speed and used to have an offload (?)
I don't see it myself
BurgoShark
Super Moderator
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2008
- Messages
- 12,868
- Reaction score
- 4,097
Definitely used the offload to good effect in the Souths game (Rd23).Think I said earlier that Toby should aim to become our new Fifita. If not, I'm saying it now
He's getting the body shape, has decent footwork and speed and used to have an offload (?)
I think to some degree it is coaching/role that determines whether they play that way. Royce seems to be under instructions to offload as much as possible, but even though Toby has that in his game he plays a bit more conservatively.
Sparkles
Jaws
- Joined
- May 21, 2008
- Messages
- 12,125
- Reaction score
- 2,855
More of a find your front and get a quick ptb role you think? Maybe that will change with Williams getting back into action?
Yeah Rudolf lacks in explosive power but has a good work rate.
Williams is Rudolf's sub I would think. May not always work out exactly like that but I think that is the gist of the prop roles - I don't really see him impacting how Toby plays too much - Burgo got any observations on either playing different if on with the other?
Rudolf to Williams
BHU to Hazelton/Hunt
Finucane to McInnes
The other bench spot goes to utility, the other one of the big boys mentioned, Talakai or Kaufusi
Williams has a bit more of that explosiveness than Toby but in a smaller body. This makes up for being a smaller middle but explosive power always helps middles if they are a chance to burst through a line. Was a big factor for Fifita that he could crab and palm and then just turn it on and burst through as soon as he saw half a gap. Before his resurgence but after his knee gave out he would still crab and palm but couldn't generate the power when he tried to straighten.
For middles our best line breakers were
Hazelton 5
Williams 5
McInnes 4
Hamlin-uele 3
Hunt 3
Finucane 1
Rudolf 1
Colquhoun / Kaufusi (0 each)
BurgoShark
Super Moderator
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2008
- Messages
- 12,868
- Reaction score
- 4,097
I think it changes depending on who else is available, and possibly based on the opposition. That game was the first game since round 5 that BHU and Toby both started.
BurgoShark
Super Moderator
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2008
- Messages
- 12,868
- Reaction score
- 4,097
They are rarely on the field together other than for 5 minutes here and there, or the games where WIlliams covered second row.
They are probably the two players who spent the least amount of time on the field together playing in the middle.
The others I'd say are pretty close, but Finucane and McInnes will often be on together for 20-25 minutes, so it's more like...
80 mins Toby + Jack
100 mins Cam + Dale
60 mins BHU + 2 of Tom/Royce/Oregon/Jesse
Those minutes go up a bit when they run with a 3 forward bench or if someone gets hurt early in the game.
Yeah that's what I would have expected - I'd have been surprised to hear there were a bunch of stints 15+ minutes they were our two props without things being pretty messed around by injury.
When you do watch through 5 see if many/any of those offloads come off a BHU PTB or with BHU as a decoy/option runner.
Be interesting to be able to say there is a clear correlation between BHUs work and Toby offloading (if that is the case).
Also how many come off a straight hit-up or if they are from tip ons.
Increased number in offloads could be a gameplan decision to push them more, or it could just come naturally if he's getting less numbers into the tackle quickly to lock him up.