Should we sign Carney or not? Yes or No?
- Thread starter Sir Chadley
- Start date
- Status
snowman
Total gronk
dunno, but his girlfriend is moving from bondi to nz at the end of the year, so i would say he is there for the long haul
bjrshark
Tiger Shark
what's you problem today?
would take him in a heartbeat. defence would be concern in the line. I know the guy can hit like a freight train but NRL defence very different.
he would end up in Brisbane, Melbourne or Warriors IMO.
better access to 3rd party deals.
Last edited:
stormshark
Jaws
Have we actually got Carney to the table yet, and/or has he drunk us under it!?
I thought he controlled the game well
Gow's Scissors
Great White
he controlled the last 10 well... the rest was a pass mark... we won didnt we.
SF
Mako Shark
Shane Flanagan was talking on 2GB then. He said along the lines of "He's the sort of player I'd want in my team, but it's not wholly my decision." He said nothing's really happened with Carney at a "club level", just going to let the dust settle on 2011, and concentrate on the 20s and NSW Cup.
Joel Caine who was interviewing him was very positive about the Sharks squad next year, said we would have pretty much a world-class pack, and was talking up our halves. :good:
Flanagan also predicted Melbourne will win the comp (Melbourne, Manly or Brisbane).
Joel Caine who was interviewing him was very positive about the Sharks squad next year, said we would have pretty much a world-class pack, and was talking up our halves. :good:
Flanagan also predicted Melbourne will win the comp (Melbourne, Manly or Brisbane).
Fitzy2513
Oceanic Whitetip Shark
It was typical finals footy. Our ball movement was always going to come overt the top of their defense. Well done 9,7 and 6.
Shocking first half. 5th tackle Kicks were terrible
He did play better in the 2nd half tho
Maybe he needs a year in nsw cup to gain a bit of experience
In the meantime we should sign that Todd carney bloke for our halves lol
Fitzy2513
Oceanic Whitetip Shark
I thought the ball movement to the edges and wing was outstanding.
Fitzy2513
Oceanic Whitetip Shark
Didn't have the pace to push for the corner needed a step off the left
Townsend didn't play terribly but I've seen worse. And why bring Townsend's performance into question in this thread...this is the Carney thread. Carney is a 6 not a 7.
Just comparing the Tigers against what I've seen from the Sharks. They spread it early and make good meters from it. I don't think they've put up a bomb yet. They've earned more repeat sets in one half than the Sharks have all year. Why do the Sharks persist with the bomb? The bomb doesn't challenge anyone except Albert Kelly.
Just comparing the Tigers against what I've seen from the Sharks. They spread it early and make good meters from it. I don't think they've put up a bomb yet. They've earned more repeat sets in one half than the Sharks have all year. Why do the Sharks persist with the bomb? The bomb doesn't challenge anyone except Albert Kelly.
Coach.
- Status