Should we sign Carney or not? Yes or No?

[A.Snowden]

so you dont rate his ability

yes. When he is in the right frame of mind.

 

[goodbyepenrithhellosharks]

If he can revive half of the form that got him his dally M he will be a huge weapon for us.
and just my opinion here but I think the odds that he will have a go are stacked in our favor, he has made a form comeback before and I think he will have a point to prove again

 

[DeathMoth]

I know you are concerned, and deathmoth is another, but are you barring up over what he is capable of doing on the field.
Forget about off field for 1 moment and give it some thought

I've posted at least 7 million replies in this thread and not one of them has expressed the notion that he is a chump on the field. I've probably expressed concern that he isn't going to single handedly bring the sharks a trophy so therefore, every **** needs to stop carrying on like he's the ****ing savior.

I've expressed ongoing support for our young halves and hope at the very least one of them still makes the cut.

Most of all I've expressed concern over the media **** storm that will ensue when he ****s up. Hopefully that doesn't happen, and I'll be quite happy to support him as long as he doesn't **** up.

And hey, let's just hope he's as dangerous as you all say. And let's hope his injuries aren't ongoing and debilitating.

 

[Riverside MF]

Top news!
Honestly who cares if he goes out drinking?
Who doesnt?
As long as he doesnt glass or bash his girlfriend, or get done drink driving again let him drink!
I'd be disappointed if we drop him over something as trivial as the Rooster dropped him for.
They let go a superstar.
Stupid IMO.
But hey we get him now!!!

 

[Sharkie73]

What is exciting for me about having him in the side next year, is the prospect that our centres and wingers will get early quality ball, look what he did at the Roosters with SKD and Linnet two nuffys who he made look like world beaters.

 

[goodbyepenrithhellosharks]

I've posted at least 7 million replies in this thread and not one of them has expressed the notion that he is a chump on the field. I've probably expressed concern that he isn't going to single handedly bring the sharks a trophy so therefore, every **** needs to stop carrying on like he's the ****ing savior.

I've expressed ongoing support for our young halves and hope at the very least one of them still makes the cut.

Most of all I've expressed concern over the media **** storm that will ensue when he ****s up. Hopefully that doesn't happen, and I'll be quite happy to support him as long as he doesn't **** up.

And hey, let's just hope he's as dangerous as you all say. And let's hope his injuries aren't ongoing and debilitating.

settle pettle I was just acknowledging the fact that you were concerned, nothing more nothing less.
get away from those pensioners, get down the beach and chill

 

[WillyInBris]

700k is fair bit, would be incentives top 8 etc you would think.

 

[sharkyboy]

Foxsports news stated we won't be releasing/doing anything today.

 

[ben]

700k is fair bit, would be incentives top 8 etc you would think.

Someone mentioned its if he doesnt get in the **** as well.

 

[tips]

thanks Ben.. i think i even tipped you the paper you will read it in..

 

[DeathMoth]

settle pettle I was just acknowledging the fact that you were concerned, nothing more nothing less.
get away from those pensioners, get down the beach and chill

You'd know as well as I that there's nothing doing at the beach today mate. Not much swell on the horizon either

 

[WillyInBris]

Someone mentioned its if he doesnt get in the **** as well.

Probably a number of incentives you would guess and that's good no different than a lot of people who work with targets to achieve bonuses etc.

 

[ben]

thanks Ben.. i think i even tipped you the paper you will read it in..

That you did. Do you know when the inu deal will be in the tele?

 

[snowman]

never, we wont sign him

 

[Gards]

Can't wait for him to highlight how bad our Centres really are. lol

Best and Poms don't seem like the type of players to run onto bullet passes into gaps (consistantly) but all the best to them and hope it lifts their games whatever style it is.

 

[Shark]

He will only see the full $700k across 2 years if he plays SOO and Aust rep footy next year.

He plays rep footy then we are winning games. If we are winning games the $700k will look cheap.

 

[squeak]

best played his best footy at canberra running off campese's bullet passes. was a few years back

 

[Ibanez]

I still don't know where I sit with this, and I probably won't until our season begins next year. My biggest fear is that AK, Graham or Townsend will be looking for other clubs.

 

[sharkyboy]

I still don't know where I sit with this, and I probably won't until our season begins next year. My biggest fear is that AK, Graham or Townsend will be looking for other clubs.

this. i want carney, but i dont wanna loose these guys!

 

[snowman]

lose*

c'mon now, your doing your hsc!

on a side note, i wouldnt lose sleep if townsend was the one to go.... would lose an hour if kelly left... would have a fit if graham left