Should we sign Carney or not? Yes or No?

[Weaponhead82]

I have a feeling that a mortimer/pearce combo is going to be a lot better than people expect.

I am suprised parramatta have not played for carney.

Why would they make a play for Carney? They have Sandow and Roberts. Plus they can play Hayne, Matuia and young Marmin Barba at 5/8 too

 

[sharks2010]

Marmin is more off a fullback isn't he

 

[Murphy]

and 5-8

 

[sharks2010]

Yeah but has been playing fullback mostly for the 20's

 

[hitman124]

Why would they make a play for Carney? They have Sandow and Roberts. Plus they can play Hayne, Matuia and young Marmin Barba at 5/8 too

Um, I dunno. Maybe because Carney would **** all over any of those players that you have just named at the 6 position? Roberts is of NSW cup quality, Reni isnt a 5/8's ******** and Kearney needs to realise that Hayne needs to go back to fullback quicksmart.

7 Sandow
6 Carney
1 Hayne

That is 3 qtrs of a darn good spine!

In my opinion it makes more sense for parra to want carney, than us.

 

[sharks2010]

They don't have the money

 

[hitman124]

they have 330 k of justin poore they can unload.

 

[stormshark]

**** sake mate. What am I in this alone now?

No definately not!

All aboard the carney train whooot whooot

Or Train Wreck?

 

[tips]

i believe the torment will be over tomorrow...

 

[Born&bred]

i believe the torment will be over tomorrow...

Why?

 

[Murphy]

because tommorrow never comes

 

[tips]

i heard the 2 yrs has been done, hopefully we read about it in the telegraph tomorrow.

 

[sharks2010]

So he met with gallop and he approved it?

 

[POTTY MULLET]

he was about to sign but he used up all the ink drawing more tuff stickers on himself

 

[tips]

gallop is on holidays.. i heard they met 3 weeks ago

 

[Ibanez]

^ Haha

 

[Born&bred]

i heard the 2 yrs has been done, hopefully we read about it in the telegraph tomorrow.

Heard where exactly?

 

[ben]

i heard the 2 yrs has been done, hopefully we read about it in the telegraph tomorrow.

gallop is on holidays.. i heard they met 3 weeks ago

I hope so, this has been so drawn out.

6. Kelly
7. Carney

 

[sharks2010]

Carney will be 6

 

[hitman124]

a part of me would be just as happy if we pulled the offer off the table, it shows we have some backbone atleast.