Official Cameron McInnes

stormshark

Jaws
Joined
Jan 8, 2009
Messages
6,328
Reaction score
957
Location
Phillip Island
I can't open or "widen" the photo. Looks like a well grazed Dave Taylor from afar. The dumbest( Think Fergo Category) laziest ( i'm trying to think of an equal/-someone will) , wasted potential ( Think Grezmuuhl) to ever reach FG. HOWEVER-I would take a Dave Taylor in his prime in a GF contesting Side ( Think short side play Rabbitohs V Rorters Length of field try). "1 game 1 match winning game- that's all we need from you"
 

Capital_Shark

Kitty Master
Joined
May 7, 2006
Messages
18,180
Reaction score
3,041
Dave was playing the biggest kid in u12s role right into first grade. Then people wanted him to stop & play structures & corridors like everyone else. Was no longer the game he enjoyed I think but money was great & he didn't have the skills to navigate that well.
 
D

Deleted member 2543

Guest
Serious question... why do you want a really big body at lock? You want a low minute impact guy with a bit of intimidation factor to get you through the softening up period? Props hold their channel but big guy can pop up anywhere? Something like that?
 
D

Deleted member 2543

Guest
Dave was playing the biggest kid in u12s role right into first grade. Then people wanted him to stop & play structures & corridors like everyone else. Was no longer the game he enjoyed I think but money was great & he didn't have the skills to navigate that well.
I've gone through this with a couple of kids this year. Standout players on their teams the last few years, everyone pumping up their tyres etc. but playing low divs with no structure. They haven't learned yet that when you play good teams, you can't expect chip and chase from your own end on tackle 2 and score every time. From their PoV the team is there to serve them, rather than them being a cog in the machine. They are teenagers, so they are bound to think that... but they need to grow out of that attitude eventually.

Obviously Dave Taylor never got called on his bullshit, or when he did his parents just moved him somewhere else to be pandered to.
 

Capital_Shark

Kitty Master
Joined
May 7, 2006
Messages
18,180
Reaction score
3,041
I've gone through this with a couple of kids this year. Standout players on their teams the last few years, everyone pumping up their tyres etc. but playing low divs with no structure. They haven't learned yet that when you play good teams, you can't expect chip and chase from your own end on tackle 2 and score every time. From their PoV the team is there to serve them, rather than them being a cog in the machine. They are teenagers, so they are bound to think that... but they need to grow out of that attitude eventually.

Obviously Dave Taylor never got called on his bullshit, or when he did his parents just moved him somewhere else to be pandered to.
I got told once I had to work for my team. I didn't get it for a while cause as a teenager I was like "I'm scoring every ****ing point we get, only **** making rep sides & cleaning up the awards, WTF?"
 
D

Deleted member 2543

Guest
I got told once I had to work for my team. I didn't get it for a while cause as a teenager I was like "I'm scoring every ****ing point we get, only **** making rep sides & cleaning up the awards, WTF?"
The opposite is just as apt. For the kid who is a team player, follows instructions and does all the talking... the parents sit there and say "I don't why the coach loves that kid. He does nothing.".
 

stormshark

Jaws
Joined
Jan 8, 2009
Messages
6,328
Reaction score
957
Location
Phillip Island
Serious question... why do you want a really big body at lock? You want a low minute impact guy with a bit of intimidation factor to get you through the softening up period? Props hold their channel but big guy can pop up anywhere? Something like that?
Pretty much. I think we are going to go away from the small ballplayer again, cause now we will see more big strong FR sized locks, than can ALSO ballplay, tackle all day, and run hard and strong. What was it Jack Gibson said about big players as the game goes on? Teams/positions are nrly becoming uniform in size as it is.
 

BrisbaneShark68

Basking Shark
Joined
Mar 30, 2023
Messages
5
Reaction score
3
Yup.

Even for young players it is something they learn. Rather than just "scoot and make 10m", it is better to scoot and run directly at the A defender. He is going to either commit or hold. If he commits, you draw and pass to try put your runner in a hole. If he holds, you either take the space behind the ruck, or find a runner running directly at A, and he looks for a quick play the ball.

If you watched footy in the 90's and saw Steve Walters the play was "no markers / one marker = scoot and take the metres". It's different now. A quick ptb is more important that 10m. Teams will give up 8-10m scoots from hookers all day if it means they can get 3 players in and win the tackle.

I'll find a good example of my hooker doing it and I'll DM it to you.
It's a touch football tactic basically the attacker runs touches defender plays the ball, try to catch defence offside
 

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
35,157
Reaction score
10,902
Location
IN A BAR
Pretty much. I think we are going to go away from the small ballplayer again, cause now we will see more big strong FR sized locks, than can ALSO ballplay, tackle all day, and run hard and strong. What was it Jack Gibson said about big players as the game goes on? Teams/positions are nrly becoming uniform in size as it is.
Play to your strengths.

If you have a good player who is smaller but quicker, more agile, you play him. If your best player for jersey is a bigger bloke, play him.
If you need a lock - see who the best player available is and sign them.
If every team has a big lock every team is used to playing against all big middles. The smaller quicker bloke can be a point of difference.

Is Cameron Murray (95kg) a significantly worse lock than Isaah Yeo (106kg)?

There is definitely some uniforming though in general.
 

Sharkfox

Great White
Joined
Aug 8, 2021
Messages
2,717
Reaction score
1,651
None of our locks ball play, turn wade into one, Mcinnes share dummy half duties with Brailey, you can always move Mcinnes back to lock if needed and have them both on during game
 

stormshark

Jaws
Joined
Jan 8, 2009
Messages
6,328
Reaction score
957
Location
Phillip Island
None of our locks ball play, turn wade into one, Mcinnes share dummy half duties with Brailey, you can always move Mcinnes back to lock if needed and have them both on during game
Yep,100% agree. Even the great small lock of his era, Graeme O'Gradey cld Ball Play. If we are staying small, that's the sort of guy. Wade or the Tooth cld maybe, but they now playing against bigger bodies than "The Snake". Again personally, there's a prototype bigger, but just as athletic as Murray, just waiting for a chance, around the cnr. (Even The NUt can ballplay;))
 

jocktheshark

Oceanic Whitetip Shark
Joined
Apr 24, 2021
Messages
854
Reaction score
824
Location
New Zealand
Plenty of players that can do what he's doing , i thought he was a ball playing forward yet all i see is a guy throwing himself at the line without doing a lot of damage .
 

Milkshark

Jaws
Joined
Jul 16, 2012
Messages
5,627
Reaction score
1,320
Coach needs to trade him. I can i on my see him playing hooker with Brailey but that ain’t gonna happen.
 
Top