Official Braydon Trindall

Capital_Shark

Capital_Shark

Kitty Master
Joined
May 7, 2006
Messages
18,589
Reaction score
3,707
apezza said:
Yeh the hip drop penalty has become a farce and it stated with the McInnes one early in the year. The classic hip drop is so obvious because the players use their own weight the drop down when tackling.

I can't remember the last time a player from any club actually got suspended for this type tackle. What makes it worse is that the bunker is making these calls after watching a few times.
Click to expand...
We've got to a place where if someone gets hurt someone must be at fault and pay for it. Nothing can just be an accident now.
 
HaroldBishop

HaroldBishop

Megalodon
Joined
Mar 8, 2012
Messages
62,354
Reaction score
17,374
Location
Sydney
Capital_Shark said:
We've got to a place where if someone gets hurt someone must be at fault and pay for it. Nothing can just be an accident now.
Click to expand...
They're slowly getting closer to what they want the game to look like. At least the people that watch SOO and the GF will be happy, that's the main thing.
 
Shortfin Mako

Shortfin Mako

Bull Shark
Joined
Aug 16, 2020
Messages
2,205
Reaction score
1,197
burgess1978 said:
It’s footy fans in general mate. The player who has 3 big runs and one big hit every game will always be seen by the masses as being “better” than the player who has 10 solid runs and 40 tackles.

Imo you need both players in the team - but if I can only have one of them I would take the latter.
Click to expand...
Well, how did that saying go? Attack wins games, defence wins championships.
 
MrDravid

MrDravid

Great White
Joined
Apr 11, 2022
Messages
4,223
Reaction score
3,267
Capital_Shark said:
We've got to a place where if someone gets hurt someone must be at fault and pay for it. Nothing can just be an accident now.
Click to expand...
I don't mind them saying if you're a defender, you have a duty of care to protect that other players head... but we're way beyond that now. A guy can trip over and gets hit in the head, even through his head is knee high and it's a penalty.

Not to mention if you have the ball, you can pretty much do what you want. Imagine what charge Kaufisi would cop if he was the defender and Walker had the ball.
 
Last edited:
bort

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
37,287
Reaction score
13,017
Location
IN A BAR
The players know most high contact is incidental, accidental & unavoidable.

The dumb thing is some of the worst knockouts you see are guys going low as tacklers and collecting a knee or hip so policing mediocre high contacts out of the game doesn't even fix the issue.

I do think what Kaufusi did was 100% intentional and he has a track record of forearms but will be interesting to see if he can beat it at judiciary.
It's basically just his word that it was an accident vs them deciding either it was intentional, or at least an avoidable accident.
 
Wiz

Wiz

Jaws
Joined
Mar 23, 2016
Messages
5,884
Reaction score
1,522
bort said:
The players know most high contact is incidental, accidental & unavoidable.

The dumb thing is some of the worst knockouts you see are guys going low as tacklers and collecting a knee or hip so policing mediocre high contacts out of the game doesn't even fix the issue.

I do think what Kaufusi did was 100% intentional and he has a track record of forearms but will be interesting to see if he can beat it at judiciary.
It's basically just his word that it was an accident vs them deciding either it was intentional, or at least an avoidable accident.
Click to expand...
Kaufusi is a F*** dirty grub. The mf is a gun player but
 
Born&bred

Born&bred

Jaws
Joined
Apr 1, 2010
Messages
13,933
Reaction score
2,118
Location
The Bar
MrDravid said:
I don't mind them saying if you're a defender, you have a duty of care to protect that other players head... but we're way beyond that now. A guy can trip over and gets hit in the head, even through his head is knee high and it's a penalty.

Not to mention if you have the ball, you can pretty much do what you want. Imagine what charge Kaufisi would cop if he was the defender and Walker had the ball.
Click to expand...
To a point, in my day it was up to you when running the ball to protect yourself (as best you could).
 
Born&bred

Born&bred

Jaws
Joined
Apr 1, 2010
Messages
13,933
Reaction score
2,118
Location
The Bar
burgess1978 said:
So true. I got spear tackled once. David Manson was the ref. I got picked up by 3 players. turned upside down so I was perfectly vertical, and dropped on my head. He said it was no penalty because I had time to get my hands out to stop my fall 😂

I was 14 iirc.
Click to expand...
Yes, but that is something you couldn't possibly protect yourself from haha.

Side note - Dave's brother Doug refereed Masters up here when I was still running around late 90s.
 
A

apezza

Jaws
Joined
Apr 1, 2010
Messages
10,219
Reaction score
9,510
Not having a go at Trindall at all (I hope he turns into our greatest ever half) but surely the experiment of him playing 20 mins in the middle needs to stop.

Not that he done anything wrong last week but surely we are better off have another forward on the bench.

Between Brailey Mcinnes and Graham, we can manage if one of our halves go off.

I think we are more at risk week to week not having 4 forwards on the bench than if a half goes off and we need to 'make do' for half a game or so.
 
A

andrew's_sharks

Great White
Joined
Sep 10, 2010
Messages
4,640
Reaction score
1,074
Location
Melbourne
apezza said:
Not having a go at Trindall at all (I hope he turns into our greatest ever half) but surely the experiment of him playing 20 mins in the middle needs to stop.

Not that he done anything wrong last week but surely we are better off have another forward on the bench.

Between Brailey Mcinnes and Graham, we can manage if one of our halves go off.

I think we are more at risk week to week not having 4 forwards on the bench than if a half goes off and we need to 'make do' for half a game or so.
Click to expand...
I agree with this, but I think this will happen if we are full strength.

8.BHU
9. Brailey
10. Toby;
11. Nikora
12. Graham
13. Finucane

14 McInness
15. Williams
16. Wilton/Tolman
17. Tolman/Hunt/FIfita

It becomes hard to fit Trindall in when we are full strength.
 
bort

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
37,287
Reaction score
13,017
Location
IN A BAR
apezza said:
Not having a go at Trindall at all (I hope he turns into our greatest ever half) but surely the experiment of him playing 20 mins in the middle needs to stop.

Not that he done anything wrong last week but surely we are better off have another forward on the bench.

Between Brailey Mcinnes and Graham, we can manage if one of our halves go off.

I think we are more at risk week to week not having 4 forwards on the bench than if a half goes off and we need to 'make do' for half a game or so.
Click to expand...
Whereas Fitz cleary thinks an injury to 1,6,7 in opening half is the worst case scenario and wants spine cover.
Knows McInnes, Finucane, Tolman, Rudolf and Graham can all do big minutes if needed.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top