What Comes 1st Club Or State

[deano the p]

So if Fergo signs with us thats alright?

Yes he had a get out clause and used it.

Lyon had no clause to get out he just walked. He left his club high and dry with no chance of replacing him.

Lets look at events:

1) June 2002 re-signs with Parramatta till the end of 2006.
2) 15th of March (two days after round one loss) 2004 announces his retirement from Parramatta and the NRL.
3) 14th of April 2004 signs with the Wee Waa Panthers until the end of 2006.
4) 17th of August 2004 signs with St Helens until the end of 2006.

I don't care what he does for Manly he will always be a dog in my eyes.

 

[Shark Magnet]

Yes he had a get out clause and used it.

Lyon had no clause to get out he just walked. He left his club high and dry with no chance of replacing him.

Lets look at events:

1) June 2002 re-signs with Parramatta till the end of 2006.
2) 15th of March (two days after round one loss) 2004 announces his retirement from Parramatta and the NRL.
3) 14th of April 2004 signs with the Wee Waa Panthers until the end of 2006.
4) 17th of August 2004 signs with St Helens until the end of 2006.

I don't care what he does for Manly he will always be a dog in my eyes.

Yeah at the Parra Vs Manly games he cops it.

 

[HaroldBishop]

Yes he had a get out clause and used it.

Lyon had no clause to get out he just walked. He left his club high and dry with no chance of replacing him.

Lets look at events:

1) June 2002 re-signs with Parramatta till the end of 2006.
2) 15th of March (two days after round one loss) 2004 announces his retirement from Parramatta and the NRL.
3) 14th of April 2004 signs with the Wee Waa Panthers until the end of 2006.
4) 17th of August 2004 signs with St Helens until the end of 2006.

I don't care what he does for Manly he will always be a dog in my eyes.

He's a dog I'd love at Cronulla. Everyone makes mistakes and that was almost 10 years ago. Who cares.

 

[snowman]

smfh, really, complaining about Lyon... ffs

 

[deano the p]

smfh, really, complaining about Lyon... ffs

Not really complaining about him, just having a conversation. It's off season gotta find something to talk about.

He's a dog I'd love at Cronulla. Everyone makes mistakes and that was almost 10 years ago. Who cares.

Hey never said I wouldn't want him at Cronulla. I just think it was a dog act. Same as Fraser Anderson, if he's as good as when he left us I'd take him back but that was a dog act too.

 

[Spanner shark]

Not really complaining about him, just having a conversation. It's off season gotta find something to talk about.
l didn't see any complaining in your comments Deano . Correct me if l am wrong isn't this site for two way conversations.Without it we are going to have a long off season.

 

[Spanner shark]

I agree with all that you said about Lyon but the way Fergo left the Raiders wasn't pretty either. Didn't get to use his get out clause down there. If we get him l hope we don't include one.Still as l said great talent and hope we snare him.

 

[deano the p]

I agree with all that you said about Lyon but the way Fergo left the Raiders wasn't pretty either. Didn't get to use his get out clause down there. If we get him l hope we don't include one.Still as l said great talent and hope we snare him.

Wasn't the best way of going about it that's for sure. I just don't think he dogged it on his mates in quite the same way.

 

[Frenzy]

What Comes 1st Club Or State?

Queensland - State
NSW - Individuals.

Clubs never come first and this is another reason Qld dominate.

 

[CrazyMatt]

Not our place to decide for them, its up to them, their careers, their lives, we get no say as well we shouldn't.