Ryan Cross. Yay or nay?

[SJH]

Should we sign Cross?

 

[Thresher]

All depends on price, $150k I say yes, anything upwards of $200k a definite no

 

[Tank]

I just voted yes but depends on cost! I am a very pissed though ! Anyone know what we want to pay for him???

 

[Matty C of the Shire]

Yes but at a cost. $75000 with incentives and options for 2nd year. How ever if he can help mentor, maybe a little more for incentive too

 

[WillyInBris]

I just voted yes but depends on cost! I am a very pissed though ! Anyone know what we want to pay for him???

Pissed or pissed off????

Didnt he go to dat other code if deed did how de dat guy go in dat other code?
How old is he?
Can he help?


Would we rather the $$$ be used as incentives?

So many questions and I cant be ****ed looking them up lol

 

[sharks2010]

Yes for me. At the lowest price

 

[stormshark]

Given our stocks, i'm a yes, two year deal low base...but then again i was all for tahu as well....shesh, i'l stick to the forwards i think.

 

[greg_bird]

hell no

 

[sharks2010]

One year deal then go hard for a centre for next year. If cross impresses then sign him up for another

 

[Bundy Shark]

I say no

 

[Mr Ryan]

Depends what we are paying him, and for what reason.

If he's getting 300 000 and he's signed to be our no 1 centre, then no thanks.

If he's getting 75 000, plus incentives, and he's just in the mix with the rest of our outside backs. Then ok, I can see some benefits.

 

[Bizzy029]

Depends what we are paying him, and for what reason.

If he's getting 300 000 and he's signed to be our no 1 centre, then no thanks.

If he's getting 75 000, plus incentives, and he's just in the mix with the rest of our outside backs. Then ok, I can see some benefits.

my thoughts exactly!

 

[greenie1957]

yes i agree on signing cross,$150,000 max he has been out of nrl for a while and is got a bit of age on him. You never know he might be awesome clicking with carney.Lets hope he can catch, could bring a lot of experience to the club

 

[snowman]

100k... he wants anymore he can go to the titans and be left in the wilderness

 

[Matty C of the Shire]

Depends what we are paying him, and for what reason.

If he's getting 300 000 and he's signed to be our no 1 centre, then no thanks.

If he's getting 75 000, plus incentives, and he's just in the mix with the rest of our outside backs. Then ok, I can see some benefits.

Some people think alike lol, I said something on your lines before mr. Ryan lol

 

[Special K]

One year deal I could stand but not a 2 year deal. We should learn from signing Colin Best at a similar age to a 2 year deal

 

[baanya]

Tough one ... He definitely will bring some class to our back line but his signing isn't a development move ... He probably won't get any better than he currently is and isn't a long term prospect due to age ... Appears to be a stop gap solution... Perhaps so far flanno hasn't seen anything he likes from our young centers so is looking to plug the hole for a year ...

Can't hurt for 12 months

 

[FLEETY]

Depends what we are paying him, and for what reason.

If he's getting 300 000 and he's signed to be our no 1 centre, then no thanks.

If he's getting 75 000, plus incentives, and he's just in the mix with the rest of our outside backs. Then ok, I can see some benefits.

I'd go along with that, as a 1 year deal.

Any second year deal, to replace Best as 'senior man' would need to be in the club's favour, dependent on how our young centre prospects are developing &/or which other quality centres we could attract at the time.

 

[Card Shark]

Yes, if he was cheap (we need centre options) & it was promised that he & Best wouldn't ever be partnered in the centres.

 

[Sharkeye]

Yeah A 1 year deal with a second in the clubs favour, he can cover 2013 if he is in form and some of our young guys are still not really for Full time First grade.