Official Nene Macdonald

[Thresher]

Love the Goodwin signing, but if we have him in our top 2 wingers we're in trouble.

Great depth for wing and centre though.

my thoughts too

 

[Sparkles]

Love the Goodwin signing, but if we have him in our top 2 wingers we're in trouble.

Great depth for wing and centre though.

What's not to love. Good win... Good wing...

 

[Tiger Shark]

We have some depth now which is good, also puts pressure on others to perform.

If Nene comes back and is a but underdone and needs to take a spell we have some decent depth to fill in.

 

[bort]

Love the Goodwin signing, but if we have him in our top 2 wingers we're in trouble.

Great depth for wing and centre though.

If he holds off at least two of Katoa, Ronnie & Nene and we aren't going well it's probably not his fault.

 

[snowman]

Love the Goodwin signing, but if we have him in our top 2 wingers we're in trouble.

Great depth for wing and centre though.

depends, his performance on the weekend was nothing short of solid considering it was his first game for the year

 

[Wiz]

depends, his performance on the weekend was nothing short of solid considering it was his first game for the year

Same.. thought his game was good.

 

[Jaz]

depends, his performance on the weekend was nothing short of solid considering it was his first game for the year

And given our injuries/youth solid was just what we needed. Still, you'd think we could get more out of Ronnie/Katoa/Macdonald than a 34yo Goodwin.

No disrespect to him, but could he be the slowest winger in the comp?

 

[Gumby]

And given our injuries/youth solid was just what we needed. Still, you'd think we could get more out of Ronnie/Katoa/Macdonald than a 34yo Goodwin.

No disrespect to him, but could he be the slowest winger in the comp?

Think Anthony Don has that in the bag

 

[MMsharks]

bryson just a stop gap for the moment surely
these young guys will develop and soon enough they will be running over tedesco!!!

 

[Gumby]

Would it be idea to have this guy on the bench in say 3-4 weeks? Similar to what Souths have been doing.

 

[Sparkles]

I don't think Goodwin is playing to lock down a four year deal, so I'm sure he's here with the remit to try and play as much first grade as he can and help bring the young guys through.

 

[CrazyMatt]

I don't think Goodwin is playing to lock down a four year deal, so I'm sure he's here with the remit to try and play as much first grade as he can and help bring the young guys through.

When he signed, the report said he was trying to earn a second year. No plans for a one and done from his point of view.

 

[bort]

And given our injuries/youth solid was just what we needed. Still, you'd think we could get more out of Ronnie/Katoa/Macdonald than a 34yo Goodwin.

No disrespect to him, but could he be the slowest winger in the comp?

Imagine how the poor Roosters must feel with two old blokes in their backline, no way anyone over 30 can perform in the NRL

I guess he could be the slowest winger in the comp, probably haven't seen enough either way to be making that call though?

 

[Tiger Shark]

When he signed, the report said he was trying to earn a second year. No plans for a one and done from his point of view.

He's probably not on much and offers good coverage in the backs. Wouldn't be the end of the world to keep him for next year also.

 

[Sparkles]

When he signed, the report said he was trying to earn a second year. No plans for a one and done from his point of view.

If he's got it in him, great. But if we're starting him for more than a year I think we're in trouble, not just on the field but in trying to hold on to the up and comers.

 

[sharkgaz]

When he signed, the report said he was trying to earn a second year. No plans for a one and done from his point of view.

Like most others, I am very happy to have him as a cover in the backline. Not too sure I want him ahead of Ronaldo, Nene or Katoa though. His experience around the club will be good for the younger guys for the rest of this year, but I would baulking in signing him up for 2021

 

[egg]

Was solid enough week one .
Happy for him to be in our squad , we'll see what happens over the season.

 

[Jaz]

Imagine how the poor Roosters must feel with two old blokes in their backline, no way anyone over 30 can perform in the NRL

I guess he could be the slowest winger in the comp, probably haven't seen enough either way to be making that call though?

Josh and Brett are freaks. I swear Josh's game last week was as good as he's ever played.

I did say a 34yo Goodwin, though. He was never quick, not even in his prime.

Anyway like I said, I'm v happy with the signing. He shouldn't lose us a game.

 

[snowman]

Think Anthony Don has that in the bag

are you kidding or what?

 

[Thresher]

Beast