Most Overrated Players/Coaches in the NRL?

[sharkarm]

I posted this thread just to see what you guys think.

In my opinion i think that it's Chris Lawrence-Wests Tigpies

 

[sandman77]

I think Willy Mason

 

[ChristyLovesSharkies]

Anasta hands down

 

[peachey]

anyone in a roosters jersey

I posted this thread just to see what you guys think.

In my opinion i think that it's Chris Lawrence-Wests Tigpies

your kidding right?

the kid is all talent and would walk straight into our team, i want him in a sharks jersey so williams can go back to the backrow

 

[hitman124]

Dave Taylor.
Karmichael Hunt.

cant forget good ol whitey.

 

[sharks_rule69]

Karmichael hunt is easily one of the best in the nrl, Mason most useless and overrated by far

 

[Mr Wright]

The Roosters and Matt Orford.

 

[scoopweidler]

Mason..daylight second. For a $400k a season player, he hasn't provided any value on the paddock this year and has no doubt been one of the architects of the senior player discontent with Fittler. An expensive mistake for the rorters in so many ways.

 

[sharkarm]

anyone in a roosters jersey



your kidding right?

the kid is all talent and would walk straight into our team, i want him in a sharks jersey so williams can go back to the backrow

Not kidding, his defence is woeful and without Marshall handing him 4 pointers he would be in NSW cup

 

[SharkBoy]

Braith Anasta

 

[Jigsaw]

Ben Ross

 

[hitman124]

Karmichael hunt is easily one of the best in the nrl, Mason most useless and overrated by far

hunt was offered 430 a season by broncos and turned it down, his manager is talking 600 k a season.

You cant tell me he is worth anywhere near that, therefore he is the most overated player in the nrl.

 

[peachey]

Not kidding, his defence is woeful and without Marshall handing him 4 pointers he would be in NSW cup

have you not seen matt wright defend or last year, david simmons?, the whole tigers team has nfi how to defend for 9 games out of 10, if they dont win by 30 they usually lose by 30

who cares if he cant defend (judging by todays game, he can), the bloke scores tries and can do it from anywhere on the field (note back to game 1 v storm at leichardt, he ran 100 mtrs to secure the win for the tigers, 16 other blokes in the team that can defend for him

i want him in my team if he was on offer

 

[hitman124]

have you not seen matt wright defend or last year, david simmons?, the whole tigers team has nfi how to defend for 9 games out of 10, if they dont win by 30 they usually lose by 30

who cares if he cant defend (judging by todays game, he can), the bloke scores tries and can do it from anywhere on the field (note back to game 1 v storm at leichardt, he ran 100 mtrs to secure the win for the tigers, 16 other blokes in the team that can defend for him

i want him in my team if he was on offer

Your right peachey, his the only bloke ive ever seen slater try and run down and not gain a meter on.

 

[Ramzyv1]

Anasta is close but has good moments. Just a really inconsistent player. I would say he is the player most overrated by Gould!!

Umm i would say it is Mason. Closely followed by O'Meley and Orford.

 

[moruya shark]

toss up between Annasta and Mason

 

[Sharkyle]

Braith Anasta OR Willy mason.....

 

[sharks_rule69]

hunt was offered 430 a season by broncos and turned it down, his manager is talking 600 k a season.

You cant tell me he is worth anywhere near that, therefore he is the most overated player in the nrl.

i wouldnt say hes worth 600 k, i dont think any player really is, hes overrating himself asking for that much but no way most overrated in the comp

 

[ROB SHARK]

willie mason.

 

[gosharks]

willie mason, but most guys would love his nickname big willie