Your right SS, it does come down to winning more often than not but if your theory of playing attractive footy is correct the Sharks in 2008 back that up, we were equal first that yr so we had success but we were widely condemned about our lack of vision in attack (played ugly).
All bar about 15-20% of sharks fans are so damn quite, hence what you said about the troubles our ground announcer has in reving up our home crowds . Thats why I suggested microphones in certain parts of the crowd/ground but apparently we are doing that already.
Even in 2008 when we were winning the crowd was still pretty quiet. I remember Ricky Stuart commenting about how quiet a ground Shark Park was.
Compare in recent years going to a Tigers game for example to a Sharks game. A good chance of winning, a team throwing the ball around, Benji, Farrah, Lawrence and co doing their thing. Its exciting. We got to get a bit of that in our team and then people will come back.