Educated comments....Please

[Capmar]

Great idea

 

[Great White]

Suggestion if they have time and don't mind have the moderators cut duplicate threads for starters.

 

[peachey]

Finally
go the great white.
Are we the most hated Give me a farking break

dont bloody read it then jeeze, give me a break

its a serious bloody question cause of the way so called "experts" jibber on about us

 

[sharks195]

shut up for once peachey!

 

[peachey]

no u shut up, im jus expressing an issue i have with the bloody NRL

 

[sharks195]

some of your threads have been pointless and duplicates cut it out, and stop posting like your life depends on it

 

[peachey]

stop posting pointless posts

dont like them IGNORE THEM...jeeze...

 

[sharks195]

i can't if i'm trying to be informed and that crap is in the way. all i'm saying is think first.

 

[KELPIE]

How about both of you cut it out.

Sharks195, you've come a long way and are getting better all the time. Same with you Peach however as '95er said, you do tend to copy the same comments into multiple threads. No need to attack each other, just keep up with the good posts.

How about we start with a dedicated thread for each game?

Working on it. Trying to get the game threads of old up and running again. Untill then how about we just sticky a post match thread?

 

[Bronze Whaler]

Wow this is my first group intervention and it's making me feel all warm and fuzzy!!

 

[chunk67]

stop posting pointless posts

thats nice coming from u peach....hahahaha

 

[peachey]

i know aye, i was slow with a good comeback so all i had was that

idea

dedicate a thread to each player, the club in general, each round we play

like sub forums

 

[Jenni]

Educated comments? That leaves me out.....

Seriously though, any comment I make about the footy is my opinion. If I make a comment and some one doesn't agree with me, then does that make me wrong or the other person wrong? I understand the point of what you are saying though.

I wasn't born and bred with League, so my understanding of the game is what I have learnt by watching the game and our beloved Sharkies for about 17 years. Maybe as a female, never playing the game or growing up in a Aussie Rules house, my vision on certain things maybe different.

I think how we respond to each others opinions, can turn it into a sh*t fight sometimes.

 

[Tunguska]

i know aye, i was slow with a good comeback so all i had was that

idea

dedicate a thread to each player, the club in general, each round we play

like sub forums

I'd find it hard to go into each player's thread, especially when 4 or 5 have great games or shocking games and 2 or 3 are praisable/bashable in the same way.

I agree with Kelpie. One thread titled: ROUND 00: Sharks vs. __________ is started just before kickoff so we skip the pre-match hype and all posts end up in that thread. Much easier to take care of things that way.

Posts on individual players should also be more descriptive I reckon... I've noticed there are lots of threads with the subject: "player" ie: "Kevin Kingston" and "De Gois"... how about we all try to make it more descriptive.

ie: "Kinga on the bench?"
or: "De Gois' Tackling Technique"

Just my two sense.

 

[FoRzA aZzUrRi]

the one thing that would put a stop to this for good would be to duplicate the post count..thats the only way

 

[peachey]

get rid of the post count, why do we have to count how many posts we make, ill happily get rid of my post count (not my posts tho)

and if there is a duplicate thread, jus merge them

 

[scott17]

i like the post count, all though i dont care how mnay posts i do, its just interesting to see how many times we have posted

 

[Shark Crazy]

Can we have a post count that elimainates pointless, duplicated, nonsence and in any other way stupid posts, and only has the ones worth reading!!

 

[brently]

1. Beautifully put, Great White. It needed to be said.
2. Commiserations, Teflon. It seems Sharky fever isn't always contagious.
3. Great idea Tung. How many threads were there pre and post dogs game? Too bloody many!!!

 

[scott17]

yeah but they are sometimes good to have more than 1 thread for a particuler topic