Now I feel bad
OK , Aiden was the ROCK of our defence
I think he plays his role. Just gets hurt so much that he can’t build momentum through a season.I can’t see BHU making our best 17 this year, his lateral defence was horrendous in parts last year and coming back from injury I can’t see him being any better this year.
He pulls of a few highlight hit ups and crunching tackles but that’s it.
Has the ability just can’t see his body ever getting him and keeping him there long enough, shame is a great bloke
Are you right if he is a healthy scratch once? Or does making the 17 when there are other healthy props just once sink your theory?You have all season to keep bringing it up if u want.
Is there such a thing as an unhealthy scratch?Are you right if he is a healthy scratch once? Or does making the 17 when there are other healthy props just once sink your theory?
I appreciate (what I perceive to be) how bold it is!
And actually putting some explanation to why you believe it
Happy to see other bold predictions (with an explanation) and big credit if it comes off
Yeah but I think there is a cream for itIs there such a thing as an unhealthy scratch?
I'd agree. It seems the role is going out of fashion though so maybe Fitz doesn't mind mixing the role up. I do see why we would want to keep BHU even with AFB coming, but I can also see us being happy enough to lose him and adjust as needed.I think he plays his role. Just gets hurt so much that he can’t build momentum through a season.
Got any examples of his poor lateral defence? Im
keen to re-watch.
FWIW I think BHU and Kaufusi are the only genuine “props” in this team. I reckon they anre under different instructions. Even Tom and Royce (similar size/weight) will chase hard from A like jackrabbits or cover an edge for a set if needed. Those two don’t. They are “stay in the middle channel and conserve energy” props.
No, more like one giant step forward with AFB and one teeny tiny step back with BHU goingmmm this is NOT good news, one step forward with AFB, half step back here.
I'd say the Sharks in particular value more mobile guys at different stages of the game. That's probably in-part why Fitz likes playing McInnes and Williams from the bench even though many would say that they are "better" players than guys who have started plenty of games (it's hard to catch out a tired player with footspeed and a quick ptb in the 5th minute). Cowboys have been bringing Cotter off the bench for a similar reason imho.I'd agree. It seems the role is going out of fashion though so maybe Fitz doesn't mind mixing the role up. I do see why we would want to keep BHU even with AFB coming, but I can also see us being happy enough to lose him and adjust as needed.
The prop is a funny role these days... I mean, we rarely even use all of our subs, so carrying a big guy that's blowing after 10 minutes and needing to conserve energy must not look too attractive anymore. Is there a benefit you can see from a big body impact player who probably bends the line more but has a slower PTB and low optimal minutes, or a smaller body with a faster PTB and able to keep the intensity longer (generalising of course)? The right answers probably whatever suits the particular team the best.
Yeah - always fun to look in to the middles from different angles.Some of that is directly relevant to your comment Thought it was an interesting line of conversation to throw out there.
That's definitely something the forum battles with - are your 'best' players better coming off the bench or starting?I'd say the Sharks in particular value more mobile guys at different stages of the game. That's probably in-part why Fitz likes playing McInnes and Williams from the bench even though many would say that they are "better" players than guys who have started plenty of games (it's hard to catch out a tired player with footspeed and a quick ptb in the 5th minute). Cowboys have been bringing Cotter off the bench for a similar reason imho.
I don't think the Sharks have any big lumbering players who get slow ptbs, but that's more down to either good work by Brailey or good interchange of passing and push support among the forwards. It's the way the Sharks play that creates the quick ptb's back-to-back-to-back. I think some of the bigger guys like Tom and Oregon might not be as effective in a different style or with different hooker/lock feeding them the ball.
Big middle of the field anchorsImo the biggest differentiators stylistically between BHU/Kaufusi and the rest of the forwards are defensive work-rate and how often they run inside their own 20. That's what I mean when I say that those guys will conserve energy.
E.g. Kaufusi actually takes almost as many runs as Williams overall, but takes less than half as many runs inside his own 20.
I'd guess that they do less East-West running in attack during a game too, but I haven't measured that.
Perve.Yeah - always fun to look in to the middles from different angles.
I understand there's a salary cap but man it'd be great to have Uele here next year backing up AFB.Sworn off the booze along with Toby
He’s sworn off Toby?Sworn off the booze along with Toby
He’s sworn off Toby?
Would love Trindall to get the chance to earn a flat track bully tag. He, Hynes and Kennedy have a lot of attacking flair given the opportunityNo coincidence I reckon that these boys are abstaining from the beers. Everyone is on their toes now they know AFB is coming.
I'm looking forward to seeing some major improvements in our pack in 2024 with our without AFB. The pressure and competition of performing week in week out can only be good for us.
If our pack does fire, it will make it so much easier for Nicho and BT to do their stuff.
Good competition, hopefully a very hot burning fire after fumbling out of two finals series consecutively and few guys really settling in as long term NRL players now tooNo coincidence I reckon that these boys are abstaining from the beers. Everyone is on their toes now they know AFB is coming.
I'm looking forward to seeing some major improvements in our pack in 2024 with our without AFB. The pressure and competition of performing week in week out can only be good for us.
If our pack does fire, it will make it so much easier for Nicho and BT to do their stuff.