(Archived) THE RUMOUR MILL - Player Movement

[HaroldBishop]

Pass

I don’t rate him.

Can I change my mind

Nah I'm with you.

 

[Sir Chadley]

4 clubs including us interested in Kurt Mann. Thoughts?

Big pass.

 

[Gumby]

Good versatility but I’m not overly keen either. Unless it’s a cheap contract and a depth only signing.

 

[Flanno]

No way to Mann, don’t rate him

 

[Tiger Shark]

Whilst I don't really rate him either I do think his versatility has really hurt him. He's been moved around in so many positions he doesn't know what he's doing. I wouldn't mind seeing him just play one position and see how he goes.

 

[snowman]

bulldogs asking for ramien if they are to release klemmer

im ****in fuming if it happens

 

[HaroldBishop]

bulldogs asking for ramien if they are to release klemmer

im ****in fuming if it happens

Can't see it. Reckon if he was to stay in Sydney he'd come back to us, unless something happened that we don't know about it.

 

[stormshark]

We'll agree to disagree mate. I had seen plenty of others in 20s over the years like Ado Carr who had talent but were never heard of again.
Again, I don't remember him carving up.

I'd like to see his stats during his time at the 20s and see how many tries he did score compared to others. I don't remember him killing it like Val did or Katoa in 2017.

Agree with this, I seem to remember he played a fair bit at FB in 20s, was very quick but lots of issues? Anyway what do I know, I thought that Orchar was going to be the next Peachy for us from the 20s.

 

[HaroldBishop]

bulldogs asking for ramien if they are to release klemmer

im ****in fuming if it happens

Would love us to help Newcastle and the Dogs here.

Klemmer to Newcastle
Ramien to us
Duges to Canterbury

Would love that!!

 

[CrazyMatt]

bulldogs asking for ramien if they are to release klemmer

im ****in fuming if it happens

Well considering what the reasons he gave to go to Newcastle were, it would be a massive kick in our nuts if he went to the Dogs instead.

 

[bort]

Can't see it. Reckon if he was to stay in Sydney he'd come back to us, unless something happened that we don't know about it.

While I don't actually expect him to come back to us, even though he has said he would want to, 100% would also be p*$$ed if he went to dogs now

 

[HaroldBishop]

While I don't actually expect him to come back to us, even though he has said he would want to, 100% would also be p*$$ed if he went to dogs now

Yeah we all would. Won't happen though.

 

[BlackWhiteBlue]

bulldogs asking for ramien if they are to release klemmer

im ****in fuming if it happens

I wouldnt be. Cos in a year Ramien will ask for a release to come back to us if he ends up at the Dawgs

 

[puma1355]

ramien goes to dogs then there is an issue at the club

 

[fishermanaxe]

Won’t happen. If newcastle even suggest to Ramien to go to the Dogs he’ll tell them to bash it and tell them he’ll stick with Sharks if they want to offload him. Of course that doesn’t help the Dogs, so he’s unlikely to come back to us. He’ll stay with Newcastle.

 

[Thresher]

Well considering what the reasons he gave to go to Newcastle were, it would be a massive kick in our nuts if he went to the Dogs instead.

unless his ex missus is already driving him nuts in Newcastle

 

[slide rule]

ramien goes to dogs then there is an issue at the club

Which Club?

 

[Milkshark]

Which Club?

Ours, otherwise why wouldn't he just stay here?

 

[slide rule]

Ours, otherwise why wouldn't he just stay here?

He might have a preference to be near his daughter, but if his new club has a change of heart and thinks he's expendable in order to get someone else to the club then that's really got nothing to do with us.

 

[Tiger Shark]

Ours, otherwise why wouldn't he just stay here?

If he's part of the Dogs/Knight Klemmer deal then he can't just stay here. Obviously if he doesn't want to go to the Dogs or wants to stay at the Knights that's in his control.