(Archived) THE RUMOUR MILL - Player Movement

[HaroldBishop]

This is all hyperthetical but if reports are true that we have offered Bird approx 800k & Chad to sign on for..... Let's say 600k, that's a total of 1.4 mill. (Option A)

Would you prefer or think we could get Foran for 900k & someone like Whare for 500k the total for these two also would be 1.4 mill. (Option B)

Would you prefer option A or B?

B but Foran will cost more than 900.

 

[Paul C]

B but Foran will cost more than 900.

Love Foran but if Simona got life, Foran should have got multiple life terms.

 

[snowman]

B but Foran will cost more than 900.

No chance

 

[deano the p]

Bird isn't even close to being our best player & he shouldn't be paid like he is. If he wants big money he can walk.

 

[BlackWhiteBlue]

Love Foran but if Simona got life, Foran should have got multiple life terms.

For what mate?

 

[endevour shark]

Woods really isn't very intimidating I have to say.

i agree he is certainly not a hard headed prop that would intermediate other packs, can't see why he is being touted as next NSW Skipper maybe Blocker is his PR man

 

[endevour shark]

There is definitely NRL interference / bias though - Nobody has ever explained how an over the cap drag queens were allowed to sign Benchy for example...

And they are stiil very deeply badly in debt the owe money all over town and spending up very big?

 

[snowman]

For what mate?

not bending the line when he runs

 

[Gumby]

not bending the line when he runs

lol

 

[HaroldBishop]

No chance

I reckon he will if he plays to his potential this year.

 

[CHOGM]

This is all hyperthetical but if reports are true that we have offered Bird approx 800k & Chad to sign on for..... Let's say 600k, that's a total of 1.4 mill. (Option A)

Would you prefer or think we could get Foran for 900k & someone like Whare for 500k the total for these two also would be 1.4 mill. (Option B)

Would you prefer option A or B?

I think this forum is broadly being short sighted regarding Chad. The age he is now is still short of the age Thurston was when he hit his peak. For a halfback, Chad has a long way to go before he is expected to be the full package, and as he is now he is very good on a good day. Consistency and maturity will come.

 

[CHOGM]

I have believed for some time that the future halves pairing for the Sharks is Chad/Holmes. 2019. Holmes is a better halves prospect than Bird IMO.

 

[snowman]

I have believed for some time that the future halves pairing for the Sharks is Chad/Holmes. 2019. Holmes is a better halves prospect than Bird IMO.

Kyle Flanagan will be int he halves by then

 

[Bundy Shark]

I think this forum is broadly being short sighted regarding Chad. The age he is now is still short of the age Thurston was when he hit his peak. For a halfback, Chad has a long way to go before he is expected to be the full package, and as he is now he is very good on a good day. Consistency and maturity will come.

I agree to a point, i guess every fan wants their 7 to be a gun or the gun

 

[Tiger Shark]

Kyle Flanagan will be int he halves by then

club rates him do they? can't say I've seen much of him outside of last week's game, good goal kicker, decent size for a half too. Good general kicking game though Williams I think did a bit more kicking.

 

[BlackWhiteBlue]

club rates him do they? can't say I've seen much of him outside of last week's game, good goal kicker, decent size for a half too. Good general kicking game though Williams I think did a bit more kicking.

Knows the coach though

 

[Tiger Shark]

Yeah that always helps

 

[Gards]

Knows the coach though

only through his uncle though

 

[D.D]

How do people rate our youth backrowers in Jayden Walker, Jack Williams and Billy Magoulias?
Can any step up in the next year?

 

[CHOGM]

Kyle Flanagan will be int he halves by then

So at 22 Kyle Flanagan will be good to go as a starting 7? Shane might want it but I can't see it.