2023 NRL General Discussion

[sharks2010]

Who's your most overrated player in the game? No Sharks' players.

Burton

 

[Jaz]

Tedesco

 

[HaroldBishop]

I've got a few. Luai, Smith, Klemmer, Ponga and Kikau all immediately jump to mind.

Ponga does my head in. Too early?

 

[Sevshark]

Who's your most overrated player in the game? No Sharks' players.

I don't know if anyone rates him, but how Gehamat Shibasaki keeps getting a run in 1st grade is beyond me.

 

[Proud Shark]

Tedesco

He's definitely looking like he's on the slide hey.

 

[andrew's_sharks]

Sam Walker for mine

He is still so young.

 

[BurgoShark]

For me cobbo sure will be elite but has some flaws in his game at present but is young so won’t be too nasty. As in a established player easy answer is brooks, I’ll settle on SJ

It’s Cobbo. He made 6 errors in round 1, and the whole presser was journos asking Kevvie to comment on what a wonderful player Cobbo is and how great he was at fullback.

 

[djhabib]

Luai for me. I do not get the fuss for someone who does a little skip and gets tackled with the ball all the time. He's trash.

 

[Milkshark]

Who's your most overrated player in the game? No Sharks' players.

Does overpaid count?

Ponga
Brooks
Moses

 

[Flanno]

Who's your most overrated player in the game? No Sharks' players.

Phoenix Crossland. And he’s not even rated!

 

[snowman]

no one rates luke brooks

i'd say burton, luai, cody walker would be the first 3 for me

 

[Flanno]

He’s a gun but I do think Latrell at fullback is a bit overrated for all the hype, doesn’t seem to get himself involved enough when I watch.

 

[Milkshark]

no one rates luke brooks

i'd say burton, luai, cody walker would be the first 3 for me

Burton: 750k
Walker: 700k
Luai: 700k
Brooks: 1.1M

I'm only going off what they are paid

Burton, Walker and Luai are probably good value compared to Brooks.

Sidenote, I was going to add Walker to my list also

 

[Milkshark]

 

[snowman]

Burton: 750k
Walker: 700k
Luai: 700k
Brooks: 1.1M

I'm only going off what they are paid

Burton, Walker and Luai are probably good value compared to Brooks.

Sidenote, I was going to add Walker to my list also

on a paid basis, brooks is the worst contract in league history, but he isnt over rated as no one rates him

 

[Milkshark]

on a paid basis, brooks is the worst contract in league history, but he isnt over rated as no one rates him

agree, i'm not discussing overrated

 

[Milkshark]

If you believe Zero Tackle, Burton is on 500k this year.

 

[snowman]

If you believe Zero Tackle, Burton is on 500k this year.

this is the last year of his contract away from penrith, it would be something like that

 

[Sir Chadley]

Does anyone know what our PTB speeds have been like this year?

I have seen no stats but it seems to be we are getting held down a lot this year in the tackle and it seems like an age before we are able to get up and play the ball. Might just be me though - anyone else have that feeling?

 

[MrDravid]

Does anyone know what our PTB speeds have been like this year?

I have seen no stats but it seems to be we are getting held down a lot this year in the tackle and it seems like an age before we are able to get up and play the ball. Might just be me though - anyone else have that feeling?