The Jiggy and Tef, rating game!
- Thread starter Jigsaw
- Start date
snowman
Total gronk
Because they arent first grade standard wingers.
Stapo and Isaac would not make the run on team for another team.
Stapo and Isaac would not make the run on team for another team.
Yeah there is proof now with everyone so far agreeing with you.
Yeah it was a convincing win to tef.
Alcohol is a handicap?
blacky
Hammerhead
Agree with tef more then jig no offence top stuff boys ...enjoyed the read.
Lol I don't think Tef even watched the game. Tackle counts? Seriously did you just look up Supercoach or stat sites to make judgements about the game? Unless you sit there with a pad and pen and count everything like the old days. Then credit to you sir.
This is meant to be how YOU saw the game not what a stat site can tell you.
Plus at least I left emotion and favoritism out of it, and just commented on what I saw.
Give credit where credit is due to Robson, that solo try won us the game and was all him, your blind as a bat if you can't see that. The first try he did nothing for, but the second was all class.
And did you watch the first half of Careny? He gave us 3 repeat set and tackled really strong. I can understand someone not knowing anything about league to only expect him to be "playing" for 10 minutes because that was the only time he is doing something amazing. There is ALOT more to a good game then just moments of brilliance. It's like saying a movie was **** because there was to much character development and not enough explosions and blood and guts....
This is meant to be how YOU saw the game not what a stat site can tell you.
Plus at least I left emotion and favoritism out of it, and just commented on what I saw.
Give credit where credit is due to Robson, that solo try won us the game and was all him, your blind as a bat if you can't see that. The first try he did nothing for, but the second was all class.
And did you watch the first half of Careny? He gave us 3 repeat set and tackled really strong. I can understand someone not knowing anything about league to only expect him to be "playing" for 10 minutes because that was the only time he is doing something amazing. There is ALOT more to a good game then just moments of brilliance. It's like saying a movie was **** because there was to much character development and not enough explosions and blood and guts....
Yeah, you got me. I based all of my review purely on what I read from NRL.COM. Idiot. Did you not read my Robson review because I'm pretty sure I said the things you just pointed out to me. The problem is he did nothing up until then. Same as Carney. He barely ran the ball until he came alive late in the game. And yes, I expect more out of him than that. If he wants to be elite he has to take control of the game more. Not drift in and out of games. And no, you didn't leave your emotionand favouritism out of it because you gave Gordon far more credit than he deserved. The crowd has spoken Jigsaw, suck it up.
I don't quite agree with you jig, but that is a ****ing awesome analogy haha
I said Gordon set up a good try and didnt do much after that. Not really praising the guy now am i. Plus you wanted to use numbers to show how much better Friz was then Gordon, tackles... meters... please comparing a wingers numbers to a Locks numbers is just stupid. Plus in the meters gained it wasnt even that much to brag about what 43 meters or something? lol WOW WATCH OUT!
With Carney your wrong. He wasnt in and out of the game... Yeah ok he doesnt run the ball every play and doesnt take the ball to the line every play. He DOESNT have to, The guy is one of the smartest players when it comes to picking and choosing when and where to strike and when to really inject himself. Carney was in control of that game from kick off when we had the ball in hand, the game never got away from him at all except for when he tried to push it and kicked the ball out.
I dont know what your expecting from the guy? What more do you want from him? He was the reason we won this game....
lol i dont mind what people think, TBH i didnt expect anyone to really vote for me anyway as i am the troll you know =p. Plus i needed to come back at something you said, i aint just gonna read your stuff and not comment back lol
You up for this on a weekly thing?
stevekneen10
Tiger Shark
Haha, might not have noticed it?...that's like saying i might not have noticed the mermaids last night!
Haha, just playing mate. Yeah, those mermaids were wearing next to nothing in the rain. I suppose they are aquatic creatures.
Gards
Jaws
Jiggy - Carney too high and Friz & Tafua too low.
Other than that not too far off the mark.
I think this is the closest thing to a structured post I have seen from the Jig but what is the point f this thread again????
Btw anyone who watches some footy can resasonably rate players, what does it proove other than being observant. Bit harsh on Wright btw, other than the 50/50 leave in the ingoal he was solid. He is just a temp.
Other than that not too far off the mark.
I think this is the closest thing to a structured post I have seen from the Jig but what is the point f this thread again????
Btw anyone who watches some footy can resasonably rate players, what does it proove other than being observant. Bit harsh on Wright btw, other than the 50/50 leave in the ingoal he was solid. He is just a temp.
lol it was just something Tef and i decided to do after me having a go at him in another thread. It really has no meaning to anyone other then Sharkyboy Tef and myself i dont think. If anyone else likes reading it then so be. Plus i really enjoy rating players(not just on looks) and since we have no 3 2 1 thread anymore this is some fun.
I hope Tef keeps it up. I have a fun thing for next week =D
I hope Tef keeps it up. I have a fun thing for next week =D
Gards
Jaws
I like player ratings especially in depth ones like this. Tef gets the bacon in this one (harsh on Robbo though) but good effort Jig.
Should be some interesting battles the next time the team has a real shocker and everyone is called reserve grade ect ha ha
Should be some interesting battles the next time the team has a real shocker and everyone is called reserve grade ect ha ha