Should we sign Carney or not? Yes or No?

[sharkyboy]

jigsaw might actually have a heart attack if that was the case

 

[WillyInBris]

jigsaw might actually have a heart attack if that was the case

He wouldn't let it happen I am sure.

 

[CROWIE]

Carney has signed for a case of VB, that's what they are saying on the grap vine

 

[WillyInBris]

Carney has signed for a case of VB, that's what they are saying on the grap vine

Stub's or Longs

 

[CROWIE]

Longs I believe

 

[WillyInBris]

Longs I believe

Bugger thought we could have got him cheaper!

 

[sharkyboy]

He wouldn't let it happen I am sure.

hed blow up the leagues club and force the club to shut down before letting that happen

 

[Thresher]

I'd rather have AK than Carney, both would be awesome

 

[hitman124]

I have a feeling if AK goes to souths next yr, we will witness souths win the comp in 2012.

 

[sharkyboy]

big call hitman

 

[jabbawokkee]

I may go on a shooting spree if this is correct. Todd Carney is a good player, there is no doubting that. But what kind of message does that send the likes of Chad Townsend, Tyrone Peachey etc... when one of our most promising talents is let go to make way for a bloke with the worst attitude in rugby league? I wanted Todd Carney at the club because i thought he was worth the gamble. But not if it is at the cost of AK. Why can't we have both its not like we need room to fit under the cap? My head hurts...

 

[Thresher]

if mundeine's in AK's ear we're in trouble

 

[Jaz]

Where did the AK leaving rumours originate? I haven't seen anything pointing towards him leaving - I would think he'd be excited to play alongside Carney.

 

[Tiger Shark]

I have a feeling if AK goes to souths next yr, we will witness souths win the comp in 2012.

you're funny man

 

[hitman124]

big call hitman

It just reminds me of presto in 03 mate thats all.

 

[Dunny old James]

I have a feeling if AK goes to souths next yr, we will witness souths win the comp in 2012.

I think if Carney goes to Souths they will be winning the comp in 2012

 

[Born&bred]

I think if I have another bourbon I'll be happier - but I'm often wrong...

 

[Dan-ce]

I think if Carney goes to Souths they will be winning the comp in 2012

I don't rate Sandow, but TBH if they couldn't win it with their squad this year, let alone finish above 8th, they won't be winning it within the next 5 years anyway.

 

[fitz]

I think the approval of the Sharks Development is more important at this point in time than the signing of any player or even a Premiership.

 

[Dunny old James]

I think the approval of the Sharks Development is more important at this point in time than the signing of any player or even a Premiership.

NO NO NO NO NO !!!!