Round 19, 2010: Sharks v Sea Eagles July 17 Toyota Stadium 7:30pm

[ben]

If Gordan was fit would covell be on his wing or the other? Hopefully the other so ferg can be dropped our wings are cov, gordan.

 

[Born&bred]

That's one crazy team you've picked there =P I wouldn't want to take gardner out, but I think Gordon could be good at fullback. We need to get Cov to teach him how to contest a high ball. Wouldn't have Tautai at center, would rather it be M Wright, and wouldn't move Gal out of lock - we need him everywhere and Toops had a shocker IMO

Unfair - I wouldn't rubbish Gards under the high ball - he's better than anyone else we've had at fullback in years. I don't know who else in our side could've caught what he had to with all the traffic.

 

[peachey]

1.Gardner
2.Gordon
3.Collis
4.Pomeroy
5.Covell
6.Kelly
7.Smith
8.Snowden
9.Aiton
10.Douglas
11.Millington
12.Tupou
13.Gallen (c)

14.Cordoba
15.B.Wright
16.Vave
17.Morris

if Barrett is out then that should be the team next week, if Barrett is still there it should be
6.Barrett
7.Kelly

Kelly played alright at halfback today when Townsend got injured, and if Gordon still injured then you put Leutele in (if hes recovered, if not we stick with Fergo)

Kelly and Smith in the same team, dear god no!

 

[Deleted member 3365]

oops didnt mean to put him there
probably porter or morris instead of smith

 

[El Coconuto]

Interesting to see some people pleading for another year from Baz in other threads, but leaving him out of their teams for next weekl. All things not considered...

1. Gardner
2. Gordon
3. Collis
4. Pomeroy
5. Covell
6. Barrett
7. Smith
8. Snowden
9. Morris
10. Douglas
11. Millington
12. Tupou
13. Gallen

14. Vave
15. Aiton
16. Cordoba
17. Tautai

Translation: Gordon in for Ferguson would be just about the only change I'd make. Porter and Barrett have a record of NOT being able to play together and Porter and Smith showed they were just as crummy together last week as well. Why go down that same path? If anything...

6. Barrett
7. Morris
9. Aiton
15. Kelly

 

[SF]

I think we are assuming he will be suspended.

 

[El Coconuto]

Be that the case, I'm still not sure I'd play Smith/Porter together again. It's got to either be...

6. Kelly
7. Porter

or...

6. Morris
7. Smith

or...

6. Morris
7. Porter

...and against a rather aggressive offensive side like Manly, I'd be more likely to go the latter.

 

[SF]

I wonder what the forfeit fee is.

 

[Blix]

Is Josh Lewis definately out???

 

[Mr Wright]

I hope Barrett calls it quits this year. At least if we put Kelly/Townsend into the team full time next year we can go the youth option.

 

[Ibanez]

Ugh, can't we just keep Covell on the bench and put him on just for the conversions?

 

[Mark^Bastard]

I wonder what the forfeit fee is.

:ridiculed

 

[Jaz]

Unfair - I wouldn't rubbish Gards under the high ball - he's better than anyone else we've had at fullback in years. I don't know who else in our side could've caught what he had to with all the traffic.

Wasn't saying Gards was bad under the high ball (always room for improvement though), i was talking about Gordon and difusing attacking kicks

 

[Deleted member 3365]

6.Morris
7.Smith

9.Aiton
17.Kelly

morris/kelly interchange then aiton/morris interchange

 

[Jaz]

Unfair - I wouldn't rubbish Gards under the high ball - he's better than anyone else we've had at fullback in years. I don't know who else in our side could've caught what he had to with all the traffic.

wasn't talking about Gards, (though always room for improvement), i was talking about Gordon contesting the oppositions attacking kicks

 

[teflon77]

I've seen enough of Kelly to know he couldnt possibly do any worse than Tim Smith. Its time to look ahead. Kelly's kicking game was excellent in NYC and he has a good pass on him as well as the ability to take the line on. Halfback for mine and pray to god we sign Wade Graham for next year.

 

[Illawarra Shark]

If Sticky hasn't shown any integrity and left by next week, I couldn't give a monkey's who is in the side after today's terrible "effort" as it is obvious our boys have had just about enough of Sticky and his constant absolution of responsibility

 

[Riverside MF]

I have an idea!

Lets put Fergo in the front row and watch him get his head taken off

 

[Mark^Bastard]

I've seen enough of Kelly to know he couldnt possibly do any worse than Tim Smith. Its time to look ahead. Kelly's kicking game was excellent in NYC and he has a good pass on him as well as the ability to take the line on. Halfback for mine and pray to god we sign Wade Graham for next year.

Did you see Kelly's try assist to Kyle O'Donnell today? That was very impressive. I'm very impressed with his short passing game.

EDIT: KOD :drunk

 

[Blix]

At least if we use Morris in the halfs Flanagan can get a run.

Also we dont need to watch Smith let tries in against us every week.

Either that or send in Lewis or Kelly