Predictions, Ratings And Teams 2007

timmo

Bronze Whaler
Joined
Jul 2, 2006
Messages
177
Reaction score
0
Here's how the sharks rate on rleague.com:

Cronulla Sharks 39.5
2006: 13th
2007: 9th
Quality 6.5/10 Their forward pack matches any in the league, but lacks depth. Their outside backs are more quantity rather than quality.
Depth 7.5/10 As mentioned they have recruited heavily in bits and parts players to fill in the three quarter line. Seymour provides options at half and De Gois at hooker. However losing Villasanti, Stosic and Maiava makes their front row stocks look decisively thin.
Juniors 3.5/10 Mitch Brown may play a part on the wing, however other than that the local junior ranks look extensively skinny for the sharks. Important year for last years standout Luke Douglas.
Form 2/10 Two trial losses against under strength opponents and an unimpressive win over the Rabbitohs is not the best preparation, especially considering their abysmal form at the back end of last year.
History 4/10 Only four times has a side come from 13th or lower the previous season to make the top 8 since the NRL began in 1998.
Motivation 9/10 A definite advantage for the Sharks will be their motivation to claim their first title. Ricky Stuart always has his sides ready to play and the Sharks will be no different.
Other Factors 7/10 The contract of Brett Kimmorly, Adam Dykes and others may be their biggest threats during the year. Speculation over Kimmorly/Dykes/Stuart may hurt if early losses occur. For the Sharks to win the comp, they need Brett Kimmorly to be their halfback and in form.
Look For A reasonably slow start from the Sharks. A big turn over of players and a coach who sees the bigger picture means the Sharks will pace themselves in 2007. Stuart will ensure the Sharks are at least competitive week in week out, and with match practice may just turn them into a real threat. Lance Thompson to gain an early exit from his contract if the Sharks fail to deliver in 2007.
1. D.Simmons
2. M.Brown
3. J.Hannay
4. B.Pomeroy
5. L.Covell
6. A.Dykes
7. B.Kimmorly
8. B.Ross
9. K.Kingston
10. L.Douglas
11. L.Thompson
12. G.Bird
13. P.Gallen
14. B.Kearney
15. C.Stapelton
16. R.Williams
17. C.Cirialdo
18. B.Seymour
19. D.Cooper
20. P.Stephenson
21. L.Hookey
22. M.Taulapapa
23. M.Greenfield
24. F.Anderson
25. I.De Gois
26. J.Selmes
27. P.Leuluai

if you read the rest of the teams ratings.. this guys has really cracked it i think
here's the site

http://www.rleague.com/db/article.php?id=27545

and for a good laugh read the comments people have written below haha
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Inferno

Bronze Whaler
Joined
Sep 7, 2005
Messages
240
Reaction score
0
Our depth is fine, I rate Stapler, Star and Selmes ahead of Mavaia who was only a benchie, Villa who was injured anyway and Stosic who was solid at best.

Also nowhere on the Sharks site does it mention we signed Lee Hookey.
 

san29

Hammerhead
Joined
Sep 7, 2005
Messages
351
Reaction score
5
Lee Hookey

Our depth is fine, I rate Stapler, Star and Selmes ahead of Mavaia who was only a benchie, Villa who was injured anyway and Stosic who was solid at best.

Also nowhere on the Sharks site does it mention we signed Lee Hookey.


YES I ALSO GOT A SHOCK WHEN I READ ABOUT LEE HOOKEY I AGREE WITH YOU I THOUGHT IT MIGHT HAVE BEEN A MISPRINT:eek:
 

Dr Prawn

Grey Nurse
Joined
Apr 6, 2006
Messages
553
Reaction score
3
Location
Kogarah
Some pretty brave predictions there. Just for the record, here's his competition ladder in full.

1 Sydney Roosters :rolleyes:
2 Wests Tigers
3 New Zealand Warriors
4 Canberra Raiders
5 Melbourne Storm
6 South Sydney Rabbitohs :eek:
7 Brisbane Broncos
8 Gold Coast Titans
9 Cronulla Sharks :mad:
10 Newcastle Knights
11 Parramatta Eels
12 St George-Illawarra Dragons :p
13 Manly Sea Eagles
14 Nth Qld Cowboys
15 Canterbury Bulldogs
16 Penrith Panthers
 

Woody

Bronze Whaler
Joined
Aug 12, 2006
Messages
128
Reaction score
0
lol, had a good read, what a freak! how did that peice of dribble even get published?
 

mjef3966

Hammerhead
Joined
Sep 4, 2006
Messages
311
Reaction score
4
Location
Bagdad
Well what’s everyone else’s prediction?

1. Storms
2. Sharks <<<< Over Due
3. Canterbury Bulldogs << Always a Class A team
4. Brisbane Broncos << Always a Class A team
5. Parramatta Eels << Got great young stars
6. Wests Tigers <<<< Depending what round Benji Ends his season ..lol
7. New Zealand Warriors <<< Dark Horses
8. South Sydney Rabbitohs << Due for Better season
9. Sydney Roosters
10. Gold Coast Titans << Do well in first season. will kill myself if they win comp b4 the sharks!

11. Newcastle Knights <<< Depends on Coach Player relation. And what johns injuries this year??

12. St George-Illawarra Dragons << Loose one key player and season is gone
13. Manly Sea Eagles
14. Nth Qld Cowboys << mmm Dont Know
15. Penrith Panthers << What the hell LANG DO?!!
16. Canberra Raiders <<< Too much losses



I know some Predictions are way out of left field but hey stranger things have happened except sharks winning the comp.
 

Capital_Shark

Kitty Master
Joined
May 7, 2006
Messages
17,766
Reaction score
2,433
Some pretty brave predictions there. Just for the record, here's his competition ladder in full.

1 Sydney Roosters :rolleyes:
2 Wests Tigers
3 New Zealand Warriors
4 Canberra Raiders
5 Melbourne Storm
6 South Sydney Rabbitohs :eek:
7 Brisbane Broncos
8 Gold Coast Titans
9 Cronulla Sharks :mad:
10 Newcastle Knights
11 Parramatta Eels
12 St George-Illawarra Dragons :p
13 Manly Sea Eagles
14 Nth Qld Cowboys
15 Canterbury Bulldogs
16 Penrith Panthers

lmao thats just upside down and inside out. Manly, Cowboys and Bulldogs bottom dwellers? Storm not in the 4? Roosters minor premiers? Tigers 2nd? Has this bloke stopped drinking since the grand final party?

And why would Thommo piss off if we have little success? Its not like he's used to back-to-back grand finals with the Dragons ffs. If anything he should be used to disappointments and choking.
 

NikkiShark

Hammerhead
Joined
Sep 7, 2005
Messages
476
Reaction score
24
Location
NSW, Australia
Here's how the sharks rate on rleague.com:
Quality 6.5/10 Their forward pack matches any in the league, but lacks depth. Their outside backs are more quantity rather than quality.
forward pack lacks depth...
hmm.. don't think so


Depth 7.5/10 As mentioned they have recruited heavily in bits and parts players to fill in the three quarter line. Seymour provides options at half and De Gois at hooker. However losing Villasanti, Stosic and Maiava makes their front row stocks look decisively thin.
not thin, just lacking first grade experience.
Selmes and Star aren't that bad..

Juniors 3.5/10 Mitch Brown may play a part on the wing, however other than that the local junior ranks look extensively skinny for the sharks. Important year for last years standout Luke Douglas.
local junior ranks.. or just junior ranks?

Form 2/10 Two trial losses against under strength opponents and an unimpressive win over the Rabbitohs is not the best preparation, especially considering their abysmal form at the back end of last year.
unimpressive win against the Bunnies?
please.
we were shocking in the first half.
we won the second half 22-0 - in the pouring rain.
how is that unimpressive? who wrote this?

History 4/10 Only four times has a side come from 13th or lower the previous season to make the top 8 since the NRL began in 1998.
that has absolutely nothing to do with anything.. useless fact.

Motivation 9/10 A definite advantage for the Sharks will be their motivation to claim their first title. Ricky Stuart always has his sides ready to play and the Sharks will be no different.
about the only thing I agree with.......

Other Factors 7/10 The contract of Brett Kimmorly, Adam Dykes and others may be their biggest threats during the year. Speculation over Kimmorly/Dykes/Stuart may hurt if early losses occur. For the Sharks to win the comp, they need Brett Kimmorly to be their halfback and in form.
Look For A reasonably slow start from the Sharks. A big turn over of players and a coach who sees the bigger picture means the Sharks will pace themselves in 2007. Stuart will ensure the Sharks are at least competitive week in week out, and with match practice may just turn them into a real threat. Lance Thompson to gain an early exit from his contract if the Sharks fail to deliver in 2007.
I highly doubt Thommo will leave..
still has two years left on his contract.
as for Kimmorley 'needing to be the halfback, and in form'
any halfback that's in form will do the same.

haha. sorry if that was rude or anything.......
 

paulmilo666

Mako Shark
Joined
Mar 14, 2007
Messages
26
Reaction score
2
Hi all,
Just signed up to this site, just found it. Long time shark supporter (36 years). Just wanted to know how the article in rl week got these teams as the top 4 as i havent seen the article. What planet is he from?

1 Sydney Roosters
2 Wests Tigers
3 New Zealand Warriors
4 Canberra Raiders
 

Capital_Shark

Kitty Master
Joined
May 7, 2006
Messages
17,766
Reaction score
2,433
Hi all,
Just signed up to this site, just found it. Long time shark supporter (36 years). Just wanted to know how the article in rl week got these teams as the top 4 as i havent seen the article. What planet is he from?

1 Sydney Roosters
2 Wests Tigers
3 New Zealand Warriors
4 Canberra Raiders

Its not Rugby League Week that put this garbage out mate, its RLeague.com that come up with it. How, I've got no idea. I'd assume a cocktail of massive head trauma, narcotics and a lot of booze.
 

Hammerhead

Grey Nurse
Joined
Sep 7, 2005
Messages
732
Reaction score
6
Location
Bondi Junction
Its not Rugby League Week that put this garbage out mate, its RLeague.com that come up with it. How, I've got no idea.

The defensive journo in me hopes you all realise that the people who write for these web sites rarely have any formal training - often it's their first gig as a reporter. These sites pay peanuts - and they attract monkeys.:eek: Take what they write with a grain of salt.
 

Megashark

Jaws
Joined
Aug 23, 2006
Messages
5,826
Reaction score
63
Location
Auckland NZ
Well that was good for a laugh at least. The writers name is Damien Herb, and it sure does sound like he's been smoking a bit too much of the green stuff. Gotta love the part where he lists The Super Knock On Kid as an example of the drag queens good recruitment! :D
 

timmo

Bronze Whaler
Joined
Jul 2, 2006
Messages
177
Reaction score
0
yea his last name is herb... ofcourse he is on the good sh*t. i left a comment at the bottom for him.. i'm under the name "sharky"
 
Top