Official Nicho Hynes

MrDravid

Great White
Joined
Apr 11, 2022
Messages
2,509
Reaction score
1,315
I'm looking at the one on the NRL website which I would hope be updated.

Would love to know who some of these judges are:

Dally M Results: Round 7​

  • Dolphins v Rabbitohs: 6 - Cody Walker, 2 - Jai Arrow, 2 - Damien Cook, 1 - Kodi Nikorima, 1 - Latrell Mitchell
  • Sharks v Roosters: 6 - Nicho Hynes, 2 - Blayke Brailey, 2 - Siosifa Talakai, 1 - Briton Nikora, 1 - Lindsay Collins
  • Sea Eagles v Storm: 5 - Daly Cherry-Evans, 3 - Tom Trbojevic, 3 - Jake Trbojevic, 1 - Cameron Munster
  • Warriors v Cowboys: 6 - Dylan Walker, 3 - Charnze Nicoll-Klokstad, 2 - Shaun Johnson, 1 - Josh Curran
  • Knights v Panthers: 4 - Nathan Cleary, 3 - Lachlan Miller, 3 - Dylan Edwards, 1 - Greg Marzhew
  • Titans v Broncos: 4 - Reece Walsh, 4 - Adam Reynolds, 2 - Payne Haas, 2 - Moeaki Fotuaika
  • Raiders v Dragons: 6 - Hudson Young, 2 - Tyrell Sloan, 2 - Tautau Moga, 1 - Sebastian Kris, 1 - Matthew Timoko
  • Eels v Bulldogs: 6 - Reagan Campbell-Gillard, 4 - Clinton Gutherson, 1 - Will Penisini, 1 - Mitchell Moses

 
Joined
Aug 11, 2011
Messages
15,300
Reaction score
3,759
Location
Perth WA
Would love to know who some of these judges are:

Dally M Results: Round 7​

  • Dolphins v Rabbitohs: 6 - Cody Walker, 2 - Jai Arrow, 2 - Damien Cook, 1 - Kodi Nikorima, 1 - Latrell Mitchell
  • Sharks v Roosters: 6 - Nicho Hynes, 2 - Blayke Brailey, 2 - Siosifa Talakai, 1 - Briton Nikora, 1 - Lindsay Collins
  • Sea Eagles v Storm: 5 - Daly Cherry-Evans, 3 - Tom Trbojevic, 3 - Jake Trbojevic, 1 - Cameron Munster
  • Warriors v Cowboys: 6 - Dylan Walker, 3 - Charnze Nicoll-Klokstad, 2 - Shaun Johnson, 1 - Josh Curran
  • Knights v Panthers: 4 - Nathan Cleary, 3 - Lachlan Miller, 3 - Dylan Edwards, 1 - Greg Marzhew
  • Titans v Broncos: 4 - Reece Walsh, 4 - Adam Reynolds, 2 - Payne Haas, 2 - Moeaki Fotuaika
  • Raiders v Dragons: 6 - Hudson Young, 2 - Tyrell Sloan, 2 - Tautau Moga, 1 - Sebastian Kris, 1 - Matthew Timoko
  • Eels v Bulldogs: 6 - Reagan Campbell-Gillard, 4 - Clinton Gutherson, 1 - Will Penisini, 1 - Mitchell Moses

Ruan Sims!
 
Joined
Feb 3, 2015
Messages
8,446
Reaction score
2,740
Would love to know who some of these judges are:

Dally M Results: Round 7​

  • Dolphins v Rabbitohs: 6 - Cody Walker, 2 - Jai Arrow, 2 - Damien Cook, 1 - Kodi Nikorima, 1 - Latrell Mitchell
  • Sharks v Roosters: 6 - Nicho Hynes, 2 - Blayke Brailey, 2 - Siosifa Talakai, 1 - Briton Nikora, 1 - Lindsay Collins
  • Sea Eagles v Storm: 5 - Daly Cherry-Evans, 3 - Tom Trbojevic, 3 - Jake Trbojevic, 1 - Cameron Munster
  • Warriors v Cowboys: 6 - Dylan Walker, 3 - Charnze Nicoll-Klokstad, 2 - Shaun Johnson, 1 - Josh Curran
  • Knights v Panthers: 4 - Nathan Cleary, 3 - Lachlan Miller, 3 - Dylan Edwards, 1 - Greg Marzhew
  • Titans v Broncos: 4 - Reece Walsh, 4 - Adam Reynolds, 2 - Payne Haas, 2 - Moeaki Fotuaika
  • Raiders v Dragons: 6 - Hudson Young, 2 - Tyrell Sloan, 2 - Tautau Moga, 1 - Sebastian Kris, 1 - Matthew Timoko
  • Eels v Bulldogs: 6 - Reagan Campbell-Gillard, 4 - Clinton Gutherson, 1 - Will Penisini, 1 - Mitchell Moses

Which particular ones stand out? I can't say I watched every game closely, but the ones I did those points don't seem too far off the mark.
 

BurgoShark

Super Moderator
Joined
Apr 8, 2008
Messages
12,868
Reaction score
4,097
Which particular ones stand out? I can't say I watched every game closely, but the ones I did those points don't seem too far off the mark.
It's all a circle-jerk around the media darlings for the most part anyway. Reece Walsh had a really poor game overall but scored a try after being setup for a 5 on 3, and then had one amazing piece of play in the 66th minute when his team was up by 16, the opposition had a guy in the bin, and the Broncos had the ball for 8 minutes straight. Gets 4 points.
 
Joined
Feb 3, 2015
Messages
8,446
Reaction score
2,740
It's all a circle-jerk around the media darlings for the most part anyway. Reece Walsh had a really poor game overall but scored a try after being setup for a 5 on 3, and then had one amazing piece of play in the 66th minute. Gets 4 points.
Oh yeah definitely not defending the system. Yeah Broncos is one of the ones I didn't really watch. I was a bit surprised Munster and Moga scored, also Hudson Young didn't strike me as the clear best player on the park to score 6.
 

BurgoShark

Super Moderator
Joined
Apr 8, 2008
Messages
12,868
Reaction score
4,097
Oh yeah definitely not defending the system. Yeah Broncos is one of the ones I didn't really watch. I was a bit surprised Munster and Moga scored, also Hudson Young didn't strike me as the clear best player on the park to score 6.
It's "who did stuff that was memorable at the end of the game?" for most people. Moga and Young both scored in the final minutes.

If a guy has an otherwise decent game and ends up doing something to "win the match" late, I can see how people look at that player and give him points.
 

Mr Ryan

Bull Shark
Joined
Nov 6, 2010
Messages
2,174
Reaction score
304
Look at Thurston for the Clive Churchill in 2015.

Michael Morgan created the try for the equaliser.

Thurston then misses the goal.

Ben Hunt drops the ball and gives Thurston a 2nd chance to be the man.
 

MrDravid

Great White
Joined
Apr 11, 2022
Messages
2,509
Reaction score
1,315
Which particular ones stand out? I can't say I watched every game closely, but the ones I did those points don't seem too far off the mark.
Lachie Miller for one... plenty of errors and missed goals yet still managed 3 points (not to mention 1 for Marzhew who while solid, also didn't do a lot).
 

Milkshark

Great White
Joined
Jul 16, 2012
Messages
4,851
Reaction score
640
It's "who did stuff that was memorable at the end of the game?" for most people. Moga and Young both scored in the final minutes.

If a guy has an otherwise decent game and ends up doing something to "win the match" late, I can see how people look at that player and give him points.
Is this why you said:

3. Brailey
2. Moylan
1. Wilton
 
Joined
Sep 7, 2005
Messages
18,518
Reaction score
2,157
Location
The Ridge!
It’s just interesting the way some people see a game.
It certainly is mate. I have to admit I look more at those who attack rather than those who defend. If a guy makes 50 tackles a game, I'm probably not going to notice it. But if a guy scores a double or more and constantly breaks the line, that I am going to notice!
 

Milkshark

Great White
Joined
Jul 16, 2012
Messages
4,851
Reaction score
640
It certainly is mate. I have to admit I look more at those who attack rather than those who defend. If a guy makes 50 tackles a game, I'm probably not going to notice it. But if a guy scores a double or more and constantly breaks the line, that I am going to notice!
I actually agree with Burgess comment that a lot of the time, points are given to players who come up winning plays a lot of the time.

And I’m curious if that’s why he didn’t give points to Hynes.
 

Gumby

Jaws
Joined
Jun 27, 2011
Messages
15,328
Reaction score
2,326
Location
Melbourne
Look at Thurston for the Clive Churchill in 2015.

Michael Morgan created the try for the equaliser.

Thurston then misses the goal.

Ben Hunt drops the ball and gives Thurston a 2nd chance to be the man.
Jake Granville was the best player on ground that day by a country mile. Thurston did absolutely **** all. Was actually a laughing stock he got the Clive Churchill
 

BurgoShark

Super Moderator
Joined
Apr 8, 2008
Messages
12,868
Reaction score
4,097
Is this why you said:

3. Brailey
2. Moylan
1. Wilton
Nope.

I actually agree with Burgess comment that a lot of the time, points are given to players who come up winning plays a lot of the time.

And I’m curious if that’s why he didn’t give points to Hynes.
I certainly don't hold it against him that he had a couple of late plays to contribute to the win. I just thought the other three were better across the 80. I also don't think there is any problem with giving points to a guy who made the match winning play, as long as he was otherwise in the mix. I am just opposed to giving points to some guy who had a bludger of a game and then had some nice touches late (like Reece Walsh).

Brailey's involvement late probably factored in to me giving him the nod over the other two guys for the 3, and defence was a big factor in picking those other two guys.

Ultimately it is pretty easy to pick a 3-2-1 from that game though. Lots of good players and a lot of "set for set" footy where the whole squad needs to do their jobs. I think in that game as long as you didn't pick Hunt, Nikora or Williams nobody can really argue that the guy didn't earn a point.
 
Last edited:

Wiz

Jaws
Joined
Mar 23, 2016
Messages
5,906
Reaction score
1,514
No one actually doubts that Nicho could play 6. The guy could play anywhere and succeed. He's a star.

The reality is that our halves combination will continue to be made up of who the coach thinks work best together. Clearly right now that's Moylan and Nicho.

An article that says he plays like a 6, or that he wants to be the halfback and general, mean jack ****. There have been people banging on about him being all sorts of different positions in the last two year. Given the chance, I'm sure he could prove them all correct.

To say he's not a halfback is bullshit. He tore up and won the dally m playing as a halfback. To say he's not a 6 or a 1 is equally as ridiculous. He's the best player in the comp amd he's ours, who gives a **** what number he wears.

If he wants to play lock I'm here for that too.
I agree

if he’s saying what his strengths and what he likes best then you do whatever to accommodate to get the best out of him
 
Top