Official Matt Moylan

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
24,589
Reaction score
2,710
Location
IN A BAR
News flash

Moylan is not in the team for his defensive plays
Agree but his D (or to an extent that edge) has been quite ordinary to start year.

While they work on that I’d love everyone to stop giving away great field position to the opponents to let them take advantage
 

Gumby

Jaws
Joined
Jun 27, 2011
Messages
12,592
Reaction score
795
Location
Melbourne
Can’t kick for **** and can’t run. But yeah let’s keep playing him every week.
 

Sparkles

Jaws
Joined
May 21, 2008
Messages
9,558
Reaction score
1,344
We're not the first team to have a 'weak' defensive half... Not even the first Sharks team. I'm more concerned that teams aren't having much trouble finding and isolating Moylan. That's not solely his fault.
 

Riverside MF

Tiger Shark
Joined
Jul 5, 2010
Messages
1,071
Reaction score
33
We're not the first team to have a 'weak' defensive half... Not even the first Sharks team. I'm more concerned that teams aren't having much trouble finding and isolating Moylan. That's not solely his fault.
If he’s the right make up for a premiership winning squad.
I’m for it.

I agree. Not his fault.

He’s picked on what he can deliver.
If his team mates (who are better defenders) aren’t delivering, then it is a team problem.

Again, wouldn’t have him in my best sharks 17.
But I’m not the coach. And I’m not paid to be.
 
Joined
Feb 3, 2015
Messages
6,256
Reaction score
947
FiTz WiLl NoT dRoP mOyLaN…………………
I don't think he will next week. But Tricky has outplayed him significantly in 2/3. I don't necessarily think Hynes or Tricky defend much better than Moylan in that spot though, that whole edge is a disaster.

At some stage there's surely a tipping point if Moylan is going to show up in 1/3.
 

Matty C of the Shire

Great White
Joined
Nov 22, 2011
Messages
3,447
Reaction score
95
Location
NSW
We're not the first team to have a 'weak' defensive half... Not even the first Sharks team. I'm more concerned that teams aren't having much trouble finding and isolating Moylan. That's not solely his fault.
True Maloney was a defensive weak half; though he had good cover defence.
however Trindall is playing well and his defence is solid.
moylan has been outplayed by tricky. tricky is hungry and I think this yr would be a breakout year for him
 
Last edited:

Wizard

Great White
Joined
Mar 23, 2016
Messages
4,529
Reaction score
554
I don't think he will next week. But Tricky has outplayed him significantly in 2/3. I don't necessarily think Hynes or Tricky defend much better than Moylan in that spot though, that whole edge is a disaster.

At some stage there's surely a tipping point if Moylan is going to show up in 1/3.
Considering he’s the one that re signed Moylan for 2 years I hope Fitz is not one of those coaches that is stubborn and refuses to drop or change players
 
Joined
Feb 3, 2015
Messages
6,256
Reaction score
947
Considering he’s the one that re signed Moylan for 2 years I hope Fitz is not one of those coaches that is stubborn and refuses to drop or change players
There's still something to be said for giving combinations time to develop. That is something Fitz clearly is big on, as he stated how he loved how much of our squad had been playing together for a while. I don't think he needs to make wholesale changes after 3 rounds, but I don't think he'd ignore Moylan playing like rds 1 and 3 for too long. If Hynes comes back, and we get more of Moylan rd 2, Tricky will be waiting a bit longer I think.
 

Sparkles

Jaws
Joined
May 21, 2008
Messages
9,558
Reaction score
1,344
True Maloney was a defensive weak half; though he had good cover defence.
however Trindall is playing well and his defence is solid.
moylan has been outplayed by tricky. tricky is hungry and I think this yr would be a breakout year for him
Moylan's defence outside of the goal line is generally pretty good.

I thought Fitz had a good point about how long a young half could sustain a run of form at first grade level.
You could be right though, but I think this experience sets him up beautifully for when we move Moylan on.
 

Sparkles

Jaws
Joined
May 21, 2008
Messages
9,558
Reaction score
1,344
If he’s the right make up for a premiership winning squad.
I’m for it.

I agree. Not his fault.

He’s picked on what he can deliver.
If his team mates (who are better defenders) aren’t delivering, then it is a team problem.

Again, wouldn’t have him in my best sharks 17.
But I’m not the coach. And I’m not paid to be.
It's all conjecture... but at this point I'd say Moylan's experience in big games puts him ahead insofar as helping get us closest to a premiership.
 

mr.sharkiee

Great White
Joined
Oct 9, 2009
Messages
4,042
Reaction score
222
Bit of a passenger tonight, besides his tip off for the try.

Looked worse when Hynes went off, but expected when you're now the main playmaker and you're pretty average.

Hope Trindall gets a chance with Hynes some point this year.
 

The Punisher

Tiger Shark
Joined
Mar 2, 2019
Messages
1,023
Reaction score
401
Bit of a passenger tonight, besides his tip off for the try.

Looked worse when Hynes went off, but expected when you're now the main playmaker and you're pretty average.

Hope Trindall gets a chance with Hynes some point this year.
Yep, his attacking kicks were dreadful
Hynes deserves a better halves partner.
Better teams will put pressure on Hynes and Moylan isnt the man to take it off his shoulders and lead the team around the field
 
Top