If You Were The Coach, What Would You Do?

Capital_Shark

Kitty Master
Joined
May 7, 2006
Messages
17,767
Reaction score
2,435
Our problems go a bit deeper than a reshuffle. They're the dumbest footy side I've seen.

But in regards to the line up Val & Bird have to be in there at fullback & centre. Whoever has to make way for that to happen, so be it.
 

Mr Wright

Jaws
Joined
Apr 16, 2009
Messages
12,573
Reaction score
97
Location
Sunshine Coast
Val
Gagan
Bird
Beale
Feki
Barba
Robson
Gal
Ennis
A Fifita
Graham
Bukuya
Heino

Lewis
D Fifita
Houma
Tupou

Use graham and bukuya as inside line runners/decoys to free up space for Barba to use Beale and bird more effectively out wide for a start.

Val provides dynamic ability at the back to go the length at any given time. His ball playing is a step up from Flash. Also his speed off the mark would be killer when utilized in sweeping backline movements. He could burst around tired edge defenders.

Gagan and Feki would provide great metres bringing the ball out of our own end. Not to mention both are good finishers.

Bird looks incredibly likely against the titans and would excell playing outside Barba/Val when shifting wide. Defences would have to stay honest on barba/Val or risk them beating them inside. That opens up space for bird to manipulate his man 1 on 1.

Im not sold on murphy, so robson stays at 7.

Give Gal 60 minutes and limit his touches to the middle third.

Heino provides a solid ruck forward and can be used well in the softening up period to open the game, rather than Lewis.

Bring Lewis on 20-25 minutes in when fatigue is starting to creep in. His ball running and late passing through the middle could be dangerous if our support men are their to back him up.

Tupou replaces boogs. Same thing as lewis, get our support men to follow his every footstep and look for that offload opportunity.

Bring Houma on with 10 to go in the 1st. Some spirited runs from the big fella would cause headaches for a tired opposition middle third.
 

DANGA HATCH

Grey Nurse
Joined
May 20, 2009
Messages
558
Reaction score
11
I drop Gordon to start - at 31 he is not getting any better with age where as Holmes will. So Holmes to fullback.

My wingers are Feki and gagan (even though he is a little rusty) because they are the best we have.

My centres are Bird and Beale - Although Ricky has not done much wrong he is not as good as Beale.

Halves are Barba and Murphy - again Robson has done nothing wrong and is playing good football but at 31 he isn't the future. I need to know now if Murphy has more to his game then being a reverse grader.

Forward pack is pretty good but I am telling them all to do what the halves tell them to and to stay out of the ball playing - offloads are ok.

A fifita is getting a rocket and getting told to run straight and hard till he doesn't make an error then I will let him go the fend again.

And the captain gets free reign on taking the 2 or not.
Agree with these ideas.
 

egg

Jaws
Joined
Apr 11, 2010
Messages
12,851
Reaction score
1,036
From the title of this thread I would follow Gus's advice below : Flanno is just lucky he didn't say 15 of the 16 NRL teams follow this script ~ one just continues grinds it's spectators into a coma .

Victory over Canberra Raiders shows no one executes blueprint for success better than Sydney Roosters

SOURCE : Brisbane Times
Date
March 29, 2015
from Phil Gould
League Columnist


I have always had a saying when coaching rugby league teams. Basically, "It's not what you do, it's the way that you do it".

Let me make just a little addition to that thought; because if you watched the Roosters play against the Raiders this weekend, it's painfully obvious that the way that you do it depends greatly on the quality of players who are doing the doing! I'm not sure if that's an appropriate use of the Queen's English, but I'm sure you get my meaning.

This was a complete team performance.

Every team in the NRL pretty much plays the same way when in possession of the ball. When coming out of their own end of the field, teams rely on attacking the advantage line with their big men to get themselves rolling forward. We see the occasional change of direction or conservative quick shift of the ball to the faster men on the edges. However, the basic plan is to control the football and safely work to a point where they can position their kicker to fire the ball off down field.

Only when they get into the opposition half, do they start to expand the ball movement and set about scoring points. The big men take a couple of runs to position the team in a certain part of the field. From there, we see playmakers drifting across field with a series of inside and outside decoy runners looking to create space down the extremities of the field for the outside backs. If they don't score on one side, they simply come back the other way and repeat the dose towards the opposite sideline.

We occasionally witness the odd variation to this structure, but very few of the 16 NRL teams stray too far away from this simple blueprint. It must be the best way to play this modern game, because all teams choose to play this way.

Obviously some teams do it better than others. Judging by what we have seen in the opening month of the 2015 season, though, I can declare that no one does it better than the Roosters, when they put their minds to their work.

They have the slickness and precision few teams in this competition can consistently match. I watch many teams every weekend in this competition roll through the identical plays, but many fall well short in their game-day delivery.

Their attention to detail is evidence of a purposeful and dedicated coaching regime. It's easy to see that when this team prepares itself for competition, "close enough is never good enough". You don't get such clinical execution on game day if this is not the norm at practice sessions during the week.

What also helps their cause is the fact that in just about every position on the field, the Roosters team boasts players who rate amongst the top echelon of those in the game today.

Sometimes the sides with elite football talent in a number of positions tend to rely on individual brilliance to provide the difference on the scoreboard. Those sides which consist mainly of tradesmen-like performers, work hard on their attention to detail and resilience to keep themselves competitive.

The fact that these brilliantly talented individuals in the Roosters' team come together to respect each other and contribute to a totally committed team performance, speaks volumes for the culture that exists in this formidable club.

All six tries posted by the Roosters against the courageous Raiders on Sunday were scored by back-line players. In fact, every back-line player scored, except half-back Mitchell Pearce. While his name did not appear on the scorer's sheet by full-time, the experienced playmaker could be well satisfied that his passing and kicking game instigated many of the successful attacking raids for the afternoon.

While it was the speedy backline players who were scoring the points, it was the hard-nosed forwards who were setting up the victory. The Rooster big men completely dominated the battle of the advantage line and made easy metres on just about every carry of the ball. They take pride in their work and they celebrate their dominance.

This was a complete team performance.

The Raiders? Well, I actually don't mind them.

I know they were somewhat outclassed and the final numbers on the scoreboard do not paint a pretty picture. But there is something to like about this side.

They are enthusiastic and willing. They are determined and courageous. Their execution has room for improvement, but I also think this is because they try to play beyond their capabilities at times.

This is often the case when young players get behind on the scoreboard against quality opposition. If the Raiders can just come together and be comfortable in their own skin, I think they have the ability to play some very good football.

Despite the best efforts, though, they were no match for the Roosters on this sunny Sunday afternoon in Sydney.

The two teams did the same things. The Roosters did it better, and to be honest, they just had better players doing it.
 
Joined
Feb 3, 2015
Messages
8,279
Reaction score
2,572
Throw the gameplan out the window and start fresh, but pick a side (the right side) and stick with it. We are in round 5 and already entertaining the posibility of our 3rd 5/8.
We know Barba is never going to be a traditional 6 so we can't use him like one, we need to focus on his strength which has always been his running game, and that doesn't come from turning someone inside every set.
Keep wade on the left edge and use him as our second option kicker for short kicks. He has shown that he has a good touch when weighting a kick, however that is hardly going to come rushing back after 3 years as a second rower but we need to give him the ball with time.
Robbo (or Murphy) is on the right edge and is our main kicker in attack, he hasn't done poorly in their attacking zone this year so i'm happy with this.
The whole time Barba needs to play a roving role and threaten to inject himself on both sides and when he gets the ball he does so at pace and goes to the line.
Same goes with Val, if you have both Barba and Val hitting a backline play at pace they will be able to get outside their man and create, we should view it as almost playing two fullbacks in attack, unstructured, adlib and hard to read.
When clearing from our own half either ennis goes from dummy half or barba or val stand deep to kick with plenty of time and space, then lead the chase whilst the other drops to cover fullback for the first tackle or two. Again it might not be perfect week one but after some practice it can work, Val has shown he has a huge boot.

1. Holmes
2. Feki
3. Beale
4. Bird
5. Gagan
6. Barba
7. Robson (Murphy)
8. Prior
9. Ennis
10. D. Fifita
11. Graham
12. Bukuya
13. Gallen

14. A Fifita (starts when he can hold the ball)
15. Toupo
16. Heighington
17. Lewis
 

HaroldBishop

Megalodon
Joined
Mar 8, 2012
Messages
55,089
Reaction score
7,888
Location
Sydney
Throw the gameplan out the window and start fresh, but pick a side (the right side) and stick with it. We are in round 5 and already entertaining the posibility of our 3rd 5/8.
We know Barba is never going to be a traditional 6 so we can't use him like one, we need to focus on his strength which has always been his running game, and that doesn't come from turning someone inside every set.
Keep wade on the left edge and use him as our second option kicker for short kicks. He has shown that he has a good touch when weighting a kick, however that is hardly going to come rushing back after 3 years as a second rower but we need to give him the ball with time.
Robbo (or Murphy) is on the right edge and is our main kicker in attack, he hasn't done poorly in their attacking zone this year so i'm happy with this.
The whole time Barba needs to play a roving role and threaten to inject himself on both sides and when he gets the ball he does so at pace and goes to the line.
Same goes with Val, if you have both Barba and Val hitting a backline play at pace they will be able to get outside their man and create, we should view it as almost playing two fullbacks in attack, unstructured, adlib and hard to read.
When clearing from our own half either ennis goes from dummy half or barba or val stand deep to kick with plenty of time and space, then lead the chase whilst the other drops to cover fullback for the first tackle or two. Again it might not be perfect week one but after some practice it can work, Val has shown he has a huge boot.

1. Holmes
2. Feki
3. Beale
4. Bird
5. Gagan
6. Barba
7. Robson (Murphy)
8. Prior
9. Ennis
10. D. Fifita
11. Graham
12. Bukuya
13. Gallen

14. A Fifita (starts when he can hold the ball)
15. Toupo
16. Heighington
17. Lewis

Good post mate. Any chance we can keep you and get rid of sharkyboy?
 

sharkyboy

Jaws
Joined
Nov 28, 2006
Messages
15,273
Reaction score
105
Location
N.S.W
Throw the gameplan out the window and start fresh, but pick a side (the right side) and stick with it. We are in round 5 and already entertaining the posibility of our 3rd 5/8.
We know Barba is never going to be a traditional 6 so we can't use him like one, we need to focus on his strength which has always been his running game, and that doesn't come from turning someone inside every set.
Keep wade on the left edge and use him as our second option kicker for short kicks. He has shown that he has a good touch when weighting a kick, however that is hardly going to come rushing back after 3 years as a second rower but we need to give him the ball with time.
Robbo (or Murphy) is on the right edge and is our main kicker in attack, he hasn't done poorly in their attacking zone this year so i'm happy with this.
The whole time Barba needs to play a roving role and threaten to inject himself on both sides and when he gets the ball he does so at pace and goes to the line.
Same goes with Val, if you have both Barba and Val hitting a backline play at pace they will be able to get outside their man and create, we should view it as almost playing two fullbacks in attack, unstructured, adlib and hard to read.
When clearing from our own half either ennis goes from dummy half or barba or val stand deep to kick with plenty of time and space, then lead the chase whilst the other drops to cover fullback for the first tackle or two. Again it might not be perfect week one but after some practice it can work, Val has shown he has a huge boot.

1. Holmes
2. Feki
3. Beale
4. Bird
5. Gagan
6. Barba
7. Robson (Murphy)
8. Prior
9. Ennis
10. D. Fifita
11. Graham
12. Bukuya
13. Gallen

14. A Fifita (starts when he can hold the ball)
15. Toupo
16. Heighington
17. Lewis

And thats exactly it, teams are so used to defending structure, that when you throw something different at them they **** themselves.

The ****ing eels beat south sydney because they were tough, energetic and played some really entertaining and ad-libbed football.

Thats how you win. If we tried to play our bland grind style against souths we will get done by 30. If we throw the ball around and don't even know what we are doing ourselves then how can you defend it? You cant.

But keep grinding Flanno. Its clearly working.
 

sharkyboy

Jaws
Joined
Nov 28, 2006
Messages
15,273
Reaction score
105
Location
N.S.W
I'll never get it.

I told you. You have to meet me. Its your own fault, I've only missed one game al year.

Come down from your Ivory tower!

I think thats more your domain, btw I didn't think you were allowed online unsupervised? Mrs wont be happy.

haha very good. You gonna make a game this year or come up with a few more excuses?
 
Top