BlackWhiteBlue
Jaws
Will chambers blew the gf not passing to cronk...doesnt make him ****
Official Edrick Lee
- Thread starter sharkyboy
- Start date
Will chambers blew the gf not passing to cronk...doesnt make him ****
dylan the villian
Jaws
does to me haha
vicsharkfan
Jaws
Welcome aboard Hightower, Looking forward to seeing you rise above and catch s few bombs a score plenty.
Never called him ****, just explained why people are bringing up his error rate
BlackWhiteBlue
Jaws
Many players have made big errors at the worst time, doesnt define them though
snowman
Total gronk
Slow? **** me the trolls are bad
slide rule
Jaws
It shouldn't but it does tend to happen.
Kimmorley and Hodgson in Origin.
It is unfair.
boozecluez
Hammerhead
Edrick Lee only played 17 games last year so hardly a fair comparison to use those 'stats' if that's the point you are trying to make. All the players mentioned to compare errors with all played close to a full season.
But if you like stat comparisons
Johnathan Wright 2015 v Edrick Lee 2016
Wright ran more metres, had more line breaks and try assists and a better scoring strike rate including less errors than Lee did last year
Let's not even compare how Lachlan Maranta 2015 compares stats wise.
Stats don't show the full picture, just saying....
And I'm undecided on Lee at this stage but happy to see him given a chance
But if you like stat comparisons
Johnathan Wright 2015 v Edrick Lee 2016
Wright ran more metres, had more line breaks and try assists and a better scoring strike rate including less errors than Lee did last year
Let's not even compare how Lachlan Maranta 2015 compares stats wise.
Stats don't show the full picture, just saying....
And I'm undecided on Lee at this stage but happy to see him given a chance
BlackWhiteBlue
Jaws
They are remembered for those moments but those moments dont indicate a lack of skill. An error is an error.
slide rule
Jaws
Agree. People ride it for eternity though.
BlackWhiteBlue
Jaws
But a bloke like mal meninga and another in kevin walters who have a little knowledge of the sport have him rated....
boozecluez
Hammerhead
What's that got to do with what I said?
I never said Lee was a bad player, I just used those comparison of players (whom are fan favourites) to show stats aren't everything.
Anyways, So Lee will replace Beale who is good enough to play for NZ.
Lee made an emerging QLD squad that also has Copley in it.
Lee may be effective and a contrast in styles to Feki (especially a target for under the high ball) so not a long wait to see how he goes.
We all want him to go well
HITMAN
Bull Shark
- Joined
- Aug 22, 2009
- Messages
- 1,955
- Reaction score
- 10
Makes him an immortal in my eyes.
snowman
Total gronk
You're telling me im not comparing games then you cherry pick 2 players from 2 different seasons. Get the **** out.
snowman
Total gronk
You're also using a guy who played centre in 2015 and saying he had more try assists. No ****ing ****.
snowman
Total gronk
2015 lee had more try assists than Wright. Your point sucks. Awful contribution.
vicsharkfan
Jaws
It's either Beale or lee... No brainer 4 me, still bitter on Beale for losing that ball v raiders semi then let's not ever talk about that chambers moment in the big one.
Once edticedrick catches a couple of overhead balls for tries he will become a fav of many especially kids.
Beale is no thrills atleast lee has some thrills in him along with some spills.
Once edticedrick catches a couple of overhead balls for tries he will become a fav of many especially kids.
Beale is no thrills atleast lee has some thrills in him along with some spills.
HaroldBishop
Megalodon
Mate so called experts used to rate Robbo as well.
Anyway, as I said before I'm ambivalent. Hope he absolutely tears it up for us.
BlackWhiteBlue
Jaws
Best origin coach in history never rated robson