Official Craig Fitzgibbon

Shortfin Mako

Shortfin Mako

Bull Shark
Joined
Aug 16, 2020
Messages
2,206
Reaction score
1,199
slide rule said:
Let’s just hope peak Fifita returns next season and we won’t need a long kicker. A 40m run every set would do the job... :cool:
Click to expand...
If you could get only one which one would you choose: A peak and fit Fifita or a peak and fit Moylan?
 
bort

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
37,423
Reaction score
13,153
Location
IN A BAR
slide rule said:
I can see why Fitz would be saying Moylan/ Nicho.

They are the two biggest names. A former rep player and the big name recruit.

It’s kind of their position to lose, rightly or wrongly. Even from a man management position it’s the easiest default.

If their shortcomings don’t satisfy the requirements of the team then the dropping becomes obvious.
Click to expand...
The one playing worse?
 
Blix

Blix

Great White
Joined
Jun 29, 2009
Messages
3,655
Reaction score
302
CrazyMatt said:
Blind faith gets us nowhere. This is a forum, you are allowed to use your own brain.

Snowman is right, if Fitz thinks a Moylan/Hynes combo is whats best for the team then he is a dud.
Click to expand...
CrazyMatt said:
have been
Click to expand...
CrazyMatt said:
Blind faith gets us nowhere. This is a forum, you are allowed to use your own brain.

Snowman is right, if Fitz thinks a Moylan/Hynes combo is whats best for the team then he is a dud.
Click to expand...

I have been seriously excited ever since hearing about Fitz.

However the second I read that report about Moylan I just hoped that Fitz hasn’t watched all of the sharkies game over the last 3 years….

Given time he reviews the Moylan situation and comes to realisation that Moylan is firstly no where near the player from 5 years ago and is now continuously injured even when he is supposedly fit to play.

And secondly he has never been able to kick….and def can’t now.

Seriously the thought of Moylan / Hynes is sickening….. Moylan should become a salesman
 
bort

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
37,423
Reaction score
13,153
Location
IN A BAR
slide rule said:
No, because by round 2 Moylan will be injured and not playing at all...😉

I wonder if our new football staff will be able to get a few more games out of him.
Click to expand...
It's certainly possible... that he will be injured

Moylan played 15/24 which is not great by any stretch but is not awful.
Played more than SJ, Katoa, Dugan, Graham
Same as Talakai
Same as Wilton although was mostly selection for him

1 less than Chad played across two clubs, 1 less than Ronnie, 2 less than Ramien

Definitely an improvement on his last two seasons.

Blix said:
Given time he reviews the Moylan situation and comes to realisation that Moylan is firstly no where near the player from 5 years ago and is now continuously injured even when he is supposedly fit to play.
Click to expand...

In regards to quality of play as viewed by Sharks Forever
We gave Moylan 0.7 votes per game he played, good for equal second with SJ (WK 1.6 per game, clear leader).
If you don't count games he started on the bench he got .875 votes per game.
Trindall for comparison got only .44 per game although did much better as a starter where he was 0.8 per game.

So our voting on here, where Moyza is pretty unpopular, he consistently polled well when playing.

2018 13.5 votes in 24 games (0.56 per game) 4th overall
2019 8 votes in 11 games (0.73 per game) 7th overall
2020 0 votes in 8 games (0 per game)
2021 10.5 in 15 games (0.7 per game) 5th overall

Collectively Sharks Forever has voted that Moylan has been pretty good for us

This is not necessarily intended to indicate he should partner Hynes as it is definitely a questionable pairing in terms of styles and contribution, Trindall and Hynes is a much more obvious halves pairing, just pointing out he hasn't been overly bad for us, that seems to be an impression people have because they are frustrated with him.
 
stormshark

stormshark

Jaws
Joined
Jan 8, 2009
Messages
6,542
Reaction score
1,144
Location
Phillip Island
That voting patterns quite interesting. As Thresher i think said when he's on, he's our main or close to it,one of our 3 top Attacking threats. Other teams know it, coaches know it, like it or not.... or we just buy 2 additional trickier, similarly experienced players, which may cost a Bomb.
 
Blix

Blix

Great White
Joined
Jun 29, 2009
Messages
3,655
Reaction score
302
In relation to the voting. The games trindall didn’t start he played on average under 20 minutes quite hard to accumulate points (where Moylan played more then 40)

I am surprised that Trindall as a rookie when starting in the team scored on average higher per game in scoring then Moylan has over the last 3 years
 
bort

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
37,423
Reaction score
13,153
Location
IN A BAR
Blix said:
In relation to the voting. The games trindall didn’t start he played on average under 20 minutes quite hard to accumulate points (where Moylan played more then 40)

I am surprised that Trindall as a rookie when starting in the team scored on average higher per game in scoring then Moylan has over the last 3 years
Click to expand...
Not bad is it, I'm certainly not making an argument against Trindall I am just making sure Moylan's contribution is fairly acknowledged.
In saying that Moylan has a 17-13 record as a starter and Trindall has 6-9 in that space of time.

Last season as most recent point of comparison Moylan (largely unpopular) did poll better than Trindall (largely popular).

Personally as I've said at this stage I probably would have preferred we just let Moyza go and spend the money elsewhere. Trindall looked competent to do the job and Metcalf looks solid to back up, maybe buy in another youngin to compete with Metcalf and keep spine numbers up.

We have signed Moylan though so I am not just going to pretend like he doesn't exist or hasn't played a good game for a few years.
I'll trust Fitz to watch everyone through preseason and trials and make the right decision for now.

I do think Trindall will have to earn the jersey over Moyza through that period though, and Fitz won't just pick him because he is younger and may keep improving.

Back on those numbers (which mean nothing to Fitz) maybe .8 per game starting and kicking is more valuable than .875 and no kicking, it probably is actually. But then as recent as round 24 when playing together Moylan got our 3 votes and Trindall our 2, maybe Fitz will be happy enough with Hynes' kicking the better player in other areas wins out?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top