Benji? Yes or no?

[stevie013]

i dont think he would come back to the nrl.

 

[A.Snowden]

No idea how much he would ask for. I wouldn't throw huge coin at him, up if we could get him on a decent contract I'd give it a shot

 

[puma1355]

beggers cant be choosers..sign benji for no more than 500k...keep holmes and brown...sign the souths hooker, koriebete, sign a centre...develop a few shark junior forwards and we are set

 

[sharkyboy]

i voted yes



i think benji could become a very crafty part of a plan

those who dont think brown is ready, or know his current position yet, he could learn from marshall/carney/robson, whilst also training at hooker

i would also be happy to chuck robson on the bench as our utility and hope we retain lichaa or sign the rabbits hooker

next year will be robsons last year, so brown plays a year of nsw cup, fills in for injuries, then takes the bench spot

big yes to benji

it would just depend how we recruit around him

Are we genuine chance of keeping licheea though?

 

[Sharky14]

Stop throwing out numbers, its isnt even likely that it will happen. Not even 0.01%
Benji's misses is a celebrity in New Zealand, they only connected benji to the sharks because beau is here.
If Benji returns to league it will be with the Warriors this year, or Tigers next year.
But his misses doesnt want to leave NZ.

 

[hamsy44]

Are we genuine chance of keeping licheea though?

His deal with dogs as of early this week according to a few different people was not done and not signed.

So unless he really doesn't want to stay I would say we can still list it as a maybe.

 

[HaroldBishop]

Stop throwing out numbers, its isnt even likely that it will happen. Not even 0.01%
Benji's misses is a celebrity in New Zealand, they only connected benji to the sharks because beau is here.
If Benji returns to league it will be with the Warriors this year, or Tigers next year.
But his misses doesnt want to leave NZ.

Good.

 

[deano the p]

I can't see us keeping Lichaa.

 

[slide rule]

Stop throwing out numbers, its isnt even likely that it will happen. Not even 0.01%
Benji's misses is a celebrity in New Zealand, they only connected benji to the sharks because beau is here.
If Benji returns to league it will be with the Warriors this year, or Tigers next year.
But his misses doesnt want to leave NZ.

Now who's throwing numbers...:glasses-cool:

 

[sharks2010]

Hahahahaha

 

[egg]

1 , 54. 895 , 82 , 1096, 5387 , 350 , maybe more
SORRY S14, couldn't help not being a smart a-se

 

[sharkyboy]

His deal with dogs as of early this week according to a few different people was not done and not signed.

So unless he really doesn't want to stay I would say we can still list it as a maybe.

Well apparently he didn't really wanna stay either haha

 

[Sharky14]

Now who's throwing numbers...:glasses-cool:

Just thought id slide it in.

 

[CrazyMatt]

I can't believe how split we are on this, according to the poll.

 

[Sharky14]

Theres been two people commenting yes- and giving reason.
Yet almost everyone thats said no has given reason.

 

[snowman]

to be fair, no one really needs to comment, there is an answer in the pole for you

 

[Great_White_Shark]

I'm up for adding a player like Benji into our side,

What Benji would add is not just another attacking option but it would also stop the opposing team smothering carney on the 5th

We really only have one option on the 5th: give the ball to carney and hope to god he pulls out a miracle and opposing teams know this

I'm all for adding a player like Benji, he is better than the majority of our current squad, who wouldn't want to improve that?

 

[Sharky14]

Noone needs to comment, but my reason for that earlier statement is people may be saying yes purely because his name is benji marshall.

 

[hamsy44]

Well apparently he didn't really wanna stay either haha

haha that is true.

 

[Great_White_Shark]

Noone needs to comment, but my reason for that earlier statement is people may be saying yes purely because his name is benji marshall.

I'm not saying yes because of his name,

Read my above post I think it's a couple of very good reasons