snowman
Total gronk
the only way he comes back is if noyce goes
noyce is backed by keogh, todd is backed by gallen
hopefully, todd and gallen are in bali next year
(Archived) THE RUMOUR MILL - Player Movement
- Thread starter snowman
- Start date
- Status
the only way he comes back is if noyce goes
noyce is backed by keogh, todd is backed by gallen
hopefully, todd and gallen are in bali next year
Nulla Boy
Bull Shark
- Joined
- Mar 21, 2006
- Messages
- 2,417
- Reaction score
- 50
Me too
HaroldBishop
Megalodon
I really can't see Souths letting Reynolds go, especially if his combo with Keary keeps working which I suspect it will. That's not to say we shouldn't be throwing in an offer though.
JimBob
Jaws
Captain courages is doing all he can to make this happen.
Credit to the board, they ain't budging.
Riverside MF
Tiger Shark
- Joined
- Jul 5, 2010
- Messages
- 1,419
- Reaction score
- 253
If he comes back he can play 7. Brown at 6 and Ennis doing the organising like Farah does at Wests.
Robbo can hit up centre link
Robbo can hit up centre link
Gards
Jaws
Even if Carney was to come back who is to say his form will make it worth while? Real hot and cold player and his mind and body won't all of a sudden be fixed and in perfect harmony. Has had more bad games than good this season for us
It's early days with Brown but he is showing signs of being a more solid consistent sort of player than Carney while still maintaining that elusiveness and X factor, he is at the early stages of his life yes but he looks a happy guy and heaps of passion
Playing Carney at 7 is the only bit that would appeal to me, but would not be a fan of bring him back to replace Brown at 6 who is our real future and already doing good things on the field
Robson cops **** but Carney also runs out of ideas at times and just resorts to drifting across field and throwing short flat bullet passes at the line which the runner usually drops
If Brown gets stuck he can always fall back onto his killer running game and has the young legs to really play to that strength of his for many seasons to come, has also shown a deft grubber in behind the line. He can also drift across field similar to Carney and draw in players
It's early days with Brown but he is showing signs of being a more solid consistent sort of player than Carney while still maintaining that elusiveness and X factor, he is at the early stages of his life yes but he looks a happy guy and heaps of passion
Playing Carney at 7 is the only bit that would appeal to me, but would not be a fan of bring him back to replace Brown at 6 who is our real future and already doing good things on the field
Robson cops **** but Carney also runs out of ideas at times and just resorts to drifting across field and throwing short flat bullet passes at the line which the runner usually drops
If Brown gets stuck he can always fall back onto his killer running game and has the young legs to really play to that strength of his for many seasons to come, has also shown a deft grubber in behind the line. He can also drift across field similar to Carney and draw in players
The starting side needs to start reflecting the guys who are good enough and importantly largely injury free. Guys like Lewis and Tupou and I'd add Carney if he comes back, need to have roles that don't leave a gaping hole everytime they're injured. And you can add Gal to that list which is why prop would be a good position for him now. It's an easier role to replace when he is injured/on rep duty without damaging the structure of the side. Lewis and Tupou should play off the bench. Carney I have no idea, but you could consider playing him off the bench like the cowboys did with Darren Smith at the end of his career.
I just don't think Carney will be injury free again in his career.
I just don't think Carney will be injury free again in his career.
sharks2010
Dribbler
halfback
squiddy
Tiger Shark
- Joined
- Jul 24, 2010
- Messages
- 1,446
- Reaction score
- 38
I don't - he wont be back get over it , ET is a bigger chance of making a comeback
Carney will want his calming influence no doubt.
endevour shark
Bull Shark
E=sharkyboy;804887]I'm more than happy with Brown atm. Partner him with a strong halfback with a mean kicking game and we don't need a Barba imo[/QUOTE]
Spot on Sharkyboy, however the Broncos have about 3 or 4 really good fullbacks maybe we should start shopping around Brisvagas
Spot on Sharkyboy, however the Broncos have about 3 or 4 really good fullbacks maybe we should start shopping around Brisvagas
Capital_Shark
Kitty Master
- Joined
- May 7, 2006
- Messages
- 17,788
- Reaction score
- 2,471
Did I miss a memo? Have we marked Holmes a **** **** already?
snowman
Total gronk
the guy who posted that doesnt know if he is coming or going mate, grain of salt
Gards
Jaws
Kasiano is a beast with skill and unlike Fifs runs straight
Would be great for us coming from the bench when Fifs gets a breather
We need genuine forwards and hope we are still considering him, I remember the rumours earlier in the year when fifs had signed with the dogs
Would be great for us coming from the bench when Fifs gets a breather
We need genuine forwards and hope we are still considering him, I remember the rumours earlier in the year when fifs had signed with the dogs
endevour shark
Bull Shark
Yes:Yes::Yes::Yes:
endevour shark
Bull Shark
Sutty
Jaws
- Joined
- Mar 17, 2014
- Messages
- 5,438
- Reaction score
- 370
You wouldn't pay $650k a season for a "normal" prop. We've signed Fifita for all his crabbing/fending/offloading glory, so he can continue to do that as far as I'm concerned. Gallen has openly said that he wants Fifita to just run straight so that his own job playing lock is easier. Captain courageous just cares about his own stats, probably why Fifita plays better without him there.
- Status