Official Andrew Fifita

Joined
Jul 29, 2006
Messages
13,426
Reaction score
989
Location
victoria
Bit early to tell yet, but my dgaf attitude towards origin that I have harboured last couple of years. Doesn't seem as burning inside me since 11pm 2nd October 2016.
 

HaroldBishop

Megalodon
Joined
Mar 8, 2012
Messages
55,107
Reaction score
7,912
Location
Sydney
Being a full time Origin coach wouldn't you expect that? His job is to talk about Origin. It's not a club coach, it's not a commentator, it's the guy who's sole purpose is Origin... Get him to only focus on it for 10 weeks so that way we can whine that Origin is dead.

Count me out of that, I'd be more than happy to see it die.
 

HaroldBishop

Megalodon
Joined
Mar 8, 2012
Messages
55,107
Reaction score
7,912
Location
Sydney
So they couldn't get him for consorting with a criminal even though they busted their arse in attempting to, so have gone for the on field support of a criminal.

I'd like to know if Mal's support for his brother years ago would be OK now, or would it depend on the player's standing in the game?

Bull****, amateurish hour continues at the NRL.
 
Joined
May 17, 2010
Messages
28,423
Reaction score
787
Location
NSW
So they couldn't get him for consorting with a criminal even though they busted their arse in attempting to, so have gone for the on field support of a criminal.

I'd like to know if Mal's support for his brother years ago would be OK now, or would it depend on the player's standing in the game?

Bull****, amateurish hour continues at the NRL.

It was only 1 or 2 years ago his brother was back behind bars and Mal publicly declared his support for him......then dropped Fifita from selection availability for HIS country
 

egg

Jaws
Joined
Apr 11, 2010
Messages
12,852
Reaction score
1,037
Excerpt from an old Herald Article

The Sydney Morning Herald
RUGBY LEAGUE
If Andrew Fifita had written a letter in support of a killer – like Mal Meninga did – he may be playing for Australia


But let's get one thing straight – it is a legal impossibility, that Fifita has been issued a "consorting" notice under the enacted laws of NSW, for merely visiting someone in prison. It's not impossible that there's more at play, but the fact is, that visiting one person in jail – however heinous their crime – is not a crime itself.

Inane it may well be, to write "FKL" on one's wrist with the intention of supporting a convicted killer, but one can only wonder how things might have been so different, had Fifita taken an alternate path. Would all and sundry seek to spear Fifita, had he instead penned an articulate, thoughtful letter to the editor of this newspaper, declaring his unwavering support for Loveridge, in spite of Loveridge's popularity being on a par with untreated sewerage?


Maybe that would have been a better approach, compared to cracking out the coloured textas. One will now never know.

For mine, there's enormous double-standards at play here. Blake Ferguson has been selected to represent Australia, despite his past misdeeds involving shoving his lecherous hand up a girl's dress in a nightclub, uninvited. Though Ferguson's criminal conviction for indecent assault was overturned on appeal in 2014, the same court found the criminal conduct proven, and placed him on a good behaviour bond.

For every reader that has a mother, a sister or a daughter: explain to me, how Ferguson's conduct isn't a thousand times worse, than anything Fifita has been accused of doing.

Moreover, almost a quarter of a century ago Bevan Meninga, the brother of Australia's coach Mal Meninga – the coach of the very team Fifita has been purposely not selected in – was jailed for life. Imprisoned after being convicted of the murder, in 1991, of 19-year-old Cheree Richardson. Bevan Meninga bashed Richardson to death, with a tree branch. Her battered, barely recognisable body was later discovered in a park.

As is so often the case, "life" doesn't mean LIFE. In 2012, Bevan Meninga became eligible for parole (he was released in 2014, but returned to custody earlier this year). In support of his brother's application, Mal Meninga wrote a letter to the Queensland Parole Board, part of which reads as follows:

To Whom It May Concern

I am writing in support of my brother Bevan Errol Meninga.

I have supported Bevan by phone, letters and visits over the term of his incarceration and have kept a keen interest in his welfare during that period. I believe family support is so invaluable regardless of his wrongdoing or how long it is between phone calls or visits, the family love, respect and support is paramount to his re-integration.

Whilst as a family we don't condone his actions of the past, I will make certain that Bevan will have the necessary family support during his re-integration back into the community ....

Does a single, reasonable person countenance the proposition that Mal Meninga was in any way wrong, in penning this letter, or for visiting his incarcerated brother during the two decades prior? Bloody hell, of course not.

Did Mal Meninga bring the Queensland Rugby League (he was, in 2012, the State of Origin coach) or the sport as a whole, into disrepute or censure by acting with human compassion towards his brother, despite Bevan Meninga's wicked crimes?

So riddle me this – why exactly, is Fifita's interactions with Loveridge viewed through such a different prism?

Put simply, there are some people who are unbelievably fortunate to be involved in the sport of rugby league; people who've done things mightily worse than the high-water mark of what Fifita is accused of doing. Deeds for which there shouldn't be any second chances in the sport.

Yet second chances, there are aplenty. Which is a reality, that sits very awkwardly with Fifita's intentional non-selection.

Article by Darren Kane
 
Joined
May 17, 2010
Messages
28,423
Reaction score
787
Location
NSW
some **** should put big mal on the spot and ask him if he thinks there is any difference.......
 
Top