3-2-1 Thread: Cronulla vs Wests Tigers, NRL Premiership, Round 1, 2012

Status
Not open for further replies.

Mark^Bastard

Great White
Joined
May 6, 2009
Messages
17,725
Reaction score
167
Location
Brisbane
Mark^Bastard's ratings for Cronulla vs Wests Tigers (NRL Premiership, Round 1, 2012)

3 Points - Todd Carney: Looked really great when he ran a bit wider like a 5/8. Can create out of no where and change the momentum of a game single handedly. Wow. (9/10)
2 Points - Bryce Gibbs: Wow, he really put in. He's our new Douglas for sure. He just doesn't leave anything in the tank and if he can keep this up we'll be in good stead. (9/10)
1 Point - Colin Best: Some really strong running too. Looked young and enthusiastic! (9/10)

- Nathan Gardner: I actually thought he was okay. Defense needs improvement. (6/10)
- John Williams: Did alright. No strong opinion. (6/10)
- Ben Pomeroy: Did he do a single thing wrong? Damn he had some strong runs and love seeing the trademark body slam. (9/10)
- Matthew Wright: Is playing out of position and of course he'll want to play in the NRL so I can't blame him really for being chosen. (5/10)
- Wade Graham: Is playing out of position. I would have given him less but he had some good moments when running it and in defense. (7/10)
- Isaac De Gois: It was so good to see him back in Sharks colours. I think he'll look better if rotated better. It was a hot day but he definitely degraded as time went on and really needed a break. (7/10)
- Ben Ross: Turned up and had a reasonable game. He was subbed off quite early, not sure why. (8/10)
- Jeremy Smith: Was quite good, typical performance. (8/10)
- Anthony Tupou: Was just okay. Good touch with that first try, nothing spectacular afterwards. (7/10)
- Paul Gallen: Was definitely off his game. Tough conditions to play in after being crook that week. (7/10)
- Andrew Fifita: I think he put in a really good effort but was targeted by the defense which stopped him having a heap of impact. Still had a lot of tackle busts and I think was good in defense. (8/10)
- Sam Tagataese: Didn't offer anything too special. I know he's capable of more and won't always have a highlight for every game. (6/10)
- John Morris: Actually looked great off the bench. Provided some impact and plenty of direction. (8/10)
- Jayson Bukuya: He was possibly our best forward. I love the way he runs and defends. I'm giving the biccies to Gibbs because of effort but Bukuya was all class. (9/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

josho

Hammerhead
Joined
Apr 21, 2008
Messages
348
Reaction score
11
josho's ratings for Cronulla vs Wests Tigers (NRL Premiership, Round 1, 2012)

3 Points - Todd Carney (9/10)
2 Points - Jeremy Smith (8/10)
1 Point - Paul Gallen (8/10)

- Nathan Gardner (5/10)
- John Williams (5/10)
- Ben Pomeroy (6/10)
- Colin Best (6/10)
- Matthew Wright (4/10)
- Wade Graham (6/10)
- Bryce Gibbs (7/10)
- Isaac De Gois (6/10)
- Ben Ross (6/10)
- Anthony Tupou (6/10)
- Andrew Fifita (6/10)
- Sam Tagataese (5/10)
- John Morris (6/10)
- Jayson Bukuya (7/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

sharkys26

Hammerhead
Joined
Feb 22, 2010
Messages
445
Reaction score
4
Location
brisbane
sharkys26's ratings for Cronulla vs Wests Tigers (NRL Premiership, Round 1, 2012)

3 Points - Todd Carney
2 Points - Colin Best
1 Point - Bryce Gibbs

- Nathan Gardner (7/10)
- John Williams (6/10)
- Ben Pomeroy (8/10)
- Matthew Wright (4/10)
- Wade Graham (7/10)
- Isaac De Gois (8/10)
- Ben Ross (7/10)
- Jeremy Smith (7/10)
- Anthony Tupou (7/10)
- Paul Gallen (7/10)
- Andrew Fifita (6/10)
- Sam Tagataese (6/10)
- John Morris (7/10)
- Jayson Bukuya (8/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

oozy

Grey Nurse
Joined
Feb 18, 2010
Messages
600
Reaction score
9
Location
Under Tom Uglys
oozy's ratings for Cronulla vs Wests Tigers (NRL Premiership, Round 1, 2012)

3 Points - Bryce Gibbs (8/10)
2 Points - Todd Carney (7/10)
1 Point - Colin Best (8/10)

- Nathan Gardner (3/10)
- John Williams (5/10)
- Ben Pomeroy (8/10)
- Matthew Wright (2/10)
- Wade Graham (6/10)
- Isaac De Gois (7/10)
- Ben Ross (7/10)
- Jeremy Smith (7/10)
- Anthony Tupou (6/10)
- Paul Gallen (7/10)
- Andrew Fifita (6/10)
- Sam Tagataese (5/10)
- John Morris (6/10)
- Jayson Bukuya (7/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

sharkarm

Hammerhead
Joined
Jun 12, 2007
Messages
464
Reaction score
4
Location
Gold Coast
sharkarm's ratings for Cronulla vs Wests Tigers (NRL Premiership, Round 1, 2012)

3 Points - Todd Carney: SUPERB!!!!! (9/10)
2 Points - John Morris: Had immediate impact off the bench. (8/10)
1 Point - Jayson Bukuya: Got us rolling forward with some powerful charges. (8/10)

- Nathan Gardner (7/10)
- John Williams (6/10)
- Ben Pomeroy: Marked Lawrence particularly well, strong performance. (7/10)
- Colin Best (7/10)
- Matthew Wright (6/10)
- Wade Graham (6/10)
- Bryce Gibbs (7/10)
- Isaac De Gois (6/10)
- Ben Ross (7/10)
- Jeremy Smith (6/10)
- Anthony Tupou (7/10)
- Paul Gallen (6/10)
- Andrew Fifita (6/10)
- Sam Tagataese (6/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

LeaguePlayer

Hammerhead
Joined
Dec 5, 2007
Messages
361
Reaction score
3
Location
Lalor Park
LeaguePlayer's ratings for Cronulla vs Wests Tigers (NRL Premiership, Round 1, 2012)

3 Points - Todd Carney (9/10)
2 Points - Isaac De Gois (9/10)
1 Point - Jayson Bukuya (8/10)

- Nathan Gardner (6/10)
- John Williams (6/10)
- Ben Pomeroy (8/10)
- Colin Best (8/10)
- Matthew Wright (5/10)
- Wade Graham (5/10)
- Bryce Gibbs (8/10)
- Ben Ross (7/10)
- Jeremy Smith (7/10)
- Anthony Tupou (7/10)
- Paul Gallen (8/10)
- Andrew Fifita (8/10)
- Sam Tagataese (7/10)
- John Morris (6/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 
D

Deleted member 3365

Guest
mr.sharkiee's ratings for Cronulla vs Wests Tigers (NRL Premiership, Round 1, 2012)

3 Points - Isaac De Gois (8/10)
2 Points - Todd Carney (8/10)
1 Point - Ben Pomeroy (7/10)

- Nathan Gardner (6/10)
- John Williams (6/10)
- Colin Best (7/10)
- Matthew Wright (5/10)
- Wade Graham (6/10)
- Bryce Gibbs (7/10)
- Ben Ross (6/10)
- Jeremy Smith (7/10)
- Anthony Tupou (6/10)
- Paul Gallen (6/10)
- Andrew Fifita (6/10)
- Sam Tagataese (4/10)
- John Morris (5/10)
- Jayson Bukuya (7/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

chikenhawk

Hammerhead
Joined
Sep 30, 2006
Messages
475
Reaction score
3
Location
ipswich qld
chikenhawk's ratings for Cronulla vs Wests Tigers (NRL Premiership, Round 1, 2012)

3 Points - Todd Carney: Don't want to overrate him, but his class was hard to ignore. Queit first half but I was expecting that. Needs to work on his goal kicking - it looked rusty. (8/10)
2 Points - Paul Gallen: usual performance. (8/10)
1 Point - Bryce Gibbs: great game. excellent competitor. welcome to the black white and blue. (8/10)

- Nathan Gardner: solid game without being outstanding - but it is the first game of the year. really looking forward to him having a great impact in 2012. (6/10)
- John Williams: a quiet game. am a fan of J.Williams but with carney goal kicker I think he will be under more pressure on the wing. needs to be better than his round 1 effort. (5/10)
- Ben Pomeroy: really suprised me...looks to be fitter and stronger than ever (7/10)
- Colin Best: good stuff from best - looked dangerous. a good partnership with carney is going to be a key for us this season - we saw glimpses. (7/10)
- Matthew Wright: too many errors. i am a fan of his, but he cant put too many of those performances together. (4/10)
- Wade Graham: hot and cold - looks dangerous running the ball but his passing game was terrible - and for a five-eight that is inexcusable. not a good kicking game. needs to step up with Robson, Townsend and Kelly biting at his heels. (4/10)
- Isaac De Gois: i thought he was solid, without being spectacular. big year coming up for him i feel. (6/10)
- Ben Ross: good game but i thought he struggled to make a real impact. (6/10)
- Jeremy Smith: a great performance. (7/10)
- Anthony Tupou: solid, without being spectacular. (6/10)
- Andrew Fifita: looked the goods when running the ball and good in defence. this kid is going to be huge! (7/10)
- Sam Tagataese: not as big of impact i was hoping for, but still did a job. (5/10)
- John Morris: best game i have seen for him in the sharks colours. if this is the impact he is going to be giving us from the bench this year then it really will be something. thought he sparked us in attack. (8/10)
- Jayson Bukuya: solid hit out, i would have him in the run on team for tupou within the next few weeks. (7/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top