2023 NRL Round 25 Cronulla-Sutherland Sharks v North QLD Cowboys, 7:50pm Thursday 17th August @ Queensland Country Bank Stadium

[Deleted member 2543]

Ok well currently, Cows are fighting for 8th with a few other teams, say it comes to that last round, 1 team wins and then its a cowboys must win to make the 8 situation and their opponent rests 15 players……how the **** is that fair to the competition

Well it’s a top 8. Most years winning 1-2 more than you lose will get you there. As Cap said, if you have to rely on other results in week 27 you didn’t do a good enough job in weeks 1 to 26.

 

[BlackWhiteBlue]

Penrith have a 30 man squad & are entitled to pick whatever 18 from that they want for game day. Any impact that might have on other teams is irrelevant to their mission.

If you wanna talk "fair" then its fair Penrith earned the freedom to pick who they want. Teams relying on other results haven't earned anything yet.

You and i both know this place would go into ****ing meltdown if we slipped out of the 8 because another team gets a gift in the last round. Dont even act like youd be ok with it

 

[Capital_Shark]

You and i both know this place would go into ****ing meltdown if we slipped out of the 8 because another team gets a gift in the last round. Dont even act like youd be ok with it

This place goes into meltdown when things are good lol

I'd cop it. I wouldn't have my expectations too high if we're hanging on for other results to get us in the 8.

 

[Sevshark]

You and i both know this place would go into ****ing meltdown if we slipped out of the 8 because another team gets a gift in the last round. Dont even act like youd be ok with it

Think my anger would be with Cronulla for putting ourselves in a position where that could happen

 

[Capital_Shark]

If we couldn't move up or down in last round should we give a **** how our team selection might affect others or just worry about what's best for us?

 

[Deleted member 2543]

If we couldn't move up or down in last round should we give a **** how our team selection might affect others or just worry about what's best for us?

We should only worry about us - unless there is any possibility of screwing over the Dragons.

 

[BlackWhiteBlue]

This place goes into meltdown when things are good lol

I'd cop it. I wouldn't have my expectations too high if we're hanging on for other results to get us in the 8.

There is no way this place would just cop it if we were knocked out by a team that gets a gift win.

I agree you control your own fate but **** theres teams like Newy (who i ****ing hate) that have turned it around who may well be the team that falls victim to the cowboys getting an easy assignment in the last round.

Fair enough if the game is a dead rubber i get it.

 

[BlackWhiteBlue]

If we couldn't move up or down in last round should we give a **** how our team selection might affect others or just worry about what's best for us?

Im not saying Penrith shouldnt be thinking about themselves, im saying the NRL need to be thinking about the integrity of their competition (which os called into question every week for various reasons already)

 

[Capital_Shark]

There is no way this place would just cop it if we were knocked out by a team that gets a gift win.

I said I'd cop it.

The collective feelings of the forum doesn't matter & is a horrible argument for or against anything.

 

[Proud Shark]

I'm absolutely fine with Penrith resting their side in the given circumstances. I think Brisbane will too and they've earned the right.

That said, it's not hard to have a week off before finals like the afl do. Would avoid this issue and make for more interest in the last round.

 

[Sevshark]

Im not saying Penrith shouldnt be thinking about themselves, im saying the NRL need to be thinking about the integrity of their competition (which os called into question every week for various reasons already)

Where's the integrity of the competition being upheld for Penrith in this scenario?

Congratulations on being the best team all year, oh by the way we're forcing you to play your best team in a game that means nothing to you, hope no gets injured, good luck.

 

[snowman]

If we are waiting on a result in round 27, i hope it goes against us

We should be sweet though

 

[snowman]

Where's the integrity of the competition towards Penrith in this scenario?

Congratulations on being the best team all year, oh by the way we're forcing you to play your best team in a game that means nothing to you, hope no gets injured, good luck.

Yeh plus you also need to look at other years

They have rested players last round every year

However, they want the MP so i think they will leave a few out of the 3 remaining games and not a huge turnover in the last round

 

[Western Sharkie]

I said I'd cop it.

The collective feelings of the forum doesn't matter & is a horrible argument for or against anything.

That hurt my feelings Cap.

I thought you cared!

 

[Deleted member 2543]

I said I'd cop it.

The collective feelings of the forum doesn't matter & is a horrible argument for or against anything.

Cap doesn't care about our feelings

 

[Western Sharkie]

I'm absolutely fine with Penrith resting their side in the given circumstances. I think Brisbane will too and they've earned the right.

That said, it's not hard to have a week off before finals like the afl do. Would avoid this issue and make for more interest in the last round.

The AFL tried it once and got caned for it

 

[bort]

Cows will beat half strength resting Penrith to go with their win over them earlier this season with a Salmon/Cogger halves pairing and everyone will be impressed how many top 8 teams they can beat

 

[MrDravid]

I'm absolutely fine with Penrith resting their side in the given circumstances. I think Brisbane will too and they've earned the right.

That said, it's not hard to have a week off before finals like the afl do. Would avoid this issue and make for more interest in the last round.

Yeah, its not Penrith's fault that their last bye was round 19 and teams like the Cows, Broncos and Bunnies get one in the last month of the season.

With the bye this week, not sure Brisbane will need to rest anyone in round 27.

 

[HaroldBishop]

The AFL tried it once and got caned for it

Once? They've been doing it for years and still do it.

 

[Proud Shark]

The AFL tried it once and got caned for it

Is it not still a thing? I thought it was a great idea.

With the bye this week, not sure Brisbane will need to rest anyone in round 27.

Fair point, I didn't consider that.

I'm sure they back themselves to beat anyone, but if I'm them I'd much rather finish second and play NZ at home than finish first and welcome Melbourne up to suncorp.