2020 NRL GF

Joined
May 17, 2010
Messages
28,418
Reaction score
784
Location
NSW
I thought the ref was okay. Couple tackles (by storm players) early I would have called 6 again (though Welch did a really bad one, although though Welch HIA smelled a bit of free interchange), couple early high contacts (both ways) that were pretty minimal I didn't mind being let go, especially as both ways.

The May kick for first penalty try and the Yeo kick try were both interesting.
Penalty try technically correct but May's leg action very much not what they were trying to stamp out with that rule, it was clean and fair, but against the rules.
The Yeo one by the letter of the law was no try, but again was not the kind of obstruction that rule enforcement is there to prevent (because nobody was particularly adversely affected) but was incorrectly awarded as a try.

Re Tamou saying ref made a pathetic decision or whatever (didn't specifically hear that myself) I guess I do think there is a difference between saying you don't agree with a decision vs implying ref is intentionally making incorrect decisions to favour one team.

It's 100% Panthers own fault they lost that game. Probably also Storms own tactic and play styles fault they nearly let Penrith back in.

One ref decision I was a bit confused by but don't remember exact names involved - Storm player offloads and hit Penrith player, second Penrith player picks it up from in front of the first one who was hit and is penalised for offside. How did it come forward off Penrith player legally but so his teammate could be offside? Offload into his foot? And Storm player offloaded into Penrith player who it came forward off and neither of them knocked on?

Brandon Smith offloaded it into the torso or thigh of a Panthers player tackling him (no knock on), Penrith player was them deemed offside due to being in front of the player it contacted. Because he picked it up on purpose its not an accidental offside its deliberate. Penalty call correct
 

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
30,268
Reaction score
6,117
Location
IN A BAR
Brandon Smith offloaded it into the torso or thigh of a Panthers player tackling him (no knock on), Penrith player was them deemed offside due to being in front of the player it contacted. Because he picked it up on purpose its not an accidental offside its deliberate. Penalty call correct

So Cheese offloads legally backwards but hits opposition, opposition has not played at ball and never made an intentional or illegal contact with ball, it is then (legally) forward off opposition despite them not having made any intentional interaction with the ball.
I'd have though Penrith player was onside as his teammate tackling never played at ball or did anything wrong. But if that's the go then so be it, no problem with it being deliberate instead of accidental, as you say he actively picked it up. Just watched it again and I think even ref felt a bit bad calling it haha

Think Kikau had something similar called a knock on by ref and Crichton was a chance of scoring.

I’m glad they finally learned that rule because they missed an obvious one for us a few weeks ago.
Seems the kind of thing that probably gets missed a bit
 

Sparkles

Jaws
Joined
May 21, 2008
Messages
12,077
Reaction score
2,816
I love Bellamy.

And by all reports hes actually a ****in legend and treats his players really well. If they **** up they know it. But he has a great bond with his players

Does twice the paperwork of other coaches, too help look after their contacts. He's a saint
 

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
30,268
Reaction score
6,117
Location
IN A BAR
Cam didn't get fined now Storm CEO has weighed in too and said ref would have sent off more Storm players if there had been longer left.
All that carry on from the Hughes sin bin too which was 100% justified
 

Addy

Jaws
Joined
Jun 21, 2010
Messages
8,829
Reaction score
989
Location
NSW/ACT
12 or 24 months after our win, they found the footage of Flanno during the last couple minutes of the game.

I hope they don't wait as long to release footage of Bellamy

'NRL on Nine' page on Facebook just put up the last 7 mins of the game with the camera on Bellamy
 

HaroldBishop

Megalodon
Joined
Mar 8, 2012
Messages
55,068
Reaction score
7,846
Location
Sydney
'NRL on Nine' page on Facebook just put up the last 7 mins of the game with the camera on Bellamy

Haha that was hilarious. Didn't even speak to the assistants after the siren, just ****ed off.
 

MMsharks

Great White
Joined
Apr 6, 2019
Messages
4,714
Reaction score
874
Location
Sutherland Shire
best highlights of that GF was the chair kicking and the spray into Ryles headset


I reckon Panthers will learn from that experience enormously, they will be a dangerous outfit in 2021 and will be hard to beat.
wouldn't be surprised if they take it out next year.
 

Jimako

Hammerhead
Joined
May 30, 2009
Messages
333
Reaction score
15
best highlights of that GF was the chair kicking and the spray into Ryles headset


I reckon Panthers will learn from that experience enormously, they will be a dangerous outfit in 2021 and will be hard to beat.
wouldn't be surprised if they take it out next year.

Thought the same about the Raiders this year but that didn't happen, not sure about the Panthers a bit hard to replicate this season with 17 straight wins, there'll be a let down.
 

Gards

Jaws
Joined
Apr 25, 2010
Messages
18,382
Reaction score
1,943
Location
At the Tucky
Yeah, sounds like they all have a good relationship with Bellamy. Takin the piss a far bit.

They wouldn't be that loose during the season or if they lost that game though.

I don't usually listen to it, but when I'm bored i'll listen to the Rushhour with MG podcasts, often when walking the dog.

Going to have to tune into listen to the butthurt.

MG's bro will be happy though

Yeah but we had Feki.......

From what I recall of JAC in our 20's system he always had the speed and that was evident but his other skills and abilities were rough around the edges which tbf you should expect at that age. you could even see this at his Tigers stint he was still pretty raw but showed heaps of promise. but he never looked as good as Holmes did who got promoted to FG in 2014 and JAC signed with the tigers the next year.

going to Melbourne transformed him though into a gun, just needed some more time and a quality development system

best highlights of that GF was the chair kicking and the spray into Ryles headset


I reckon Panthers will learn from that experience enormously, they will be a dangerous outfit in 2021 and will be hard to beat.
wouldn't be surprised if they take it out next year.

I reckon they start strong in 2021 but at some point go through a bad stretch of form dropping consecutive games and pressure starts to go back on Ivan. they really should still be top 8 and playing finals though
 

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
30,268
Reaction score
6,117
Location
IN A BAR
going to Melbourne transformed him though into a gun, just needed some more time and a quality development system

For sure Melbourne helped massively but he has also benefitted a lot from stacking on some kilos of muscle, and props to him (/Storm) for doing it in conjunction with a sprint coach to ensure he didn't lose any speed.
A lot of players (especially those growing up as outside backs) struggle to put on muscle until they are in early 20s, and he moved to Storm at 20/21

Like to see Ronnie and Kennedy put on a few extra kilos of muscle, and Nikora too (as we have all mentioned).
Think Katoa has a little bit since he debuted with us, but another couple wouldn't go astray for him either.
 

gando2230

Jaws
Joined
Jun 1, 2006
Messages
10,882
Reaction score
63
Location
Cronulla
Does anyone know where I can watch the replay of the Freddy segment at halftime During the GF?
 

Sparkles

Jaws
Joined
May 21, 2008
Messages
12,077
Reaction score
2,816
Does anyone know where I can watch the replay of the Freddy segment at halftime During the GF?

Gando... Don't do it to yourself mate.
If someone told you it was funny, they're wrong. Utterly and completely wrong
 
Top