Your dream team... or not so dream team.

[josh11223344]

Most overrated:

1- will zillman (just for the fact he got a 5 year contract and provides nothing as a fullback)
2- nathan merritt (playing outside gi and having the media push you for origin as you're aboriginal get's you a blues jumper it seems)
3- jack reed
4- dane nielsen
5- akuila uate (not bad, just hasn't progressed)
6- james maloney
7- adam reynolds (it will do me if he's picked for origin because of fan and media pressure. Pearce ****s on him)
8- james graham
9- I honestly can't think of any overrated dummy halves
10- david shillington
11- chris mcqueen
12- simon mannering
13- shaun fensom

 

[deano the p]

That 1-7 would be amazing to watch!

I love my attacking backs and my hard hitting forwards.

Speaking of which I can't believe I left Joel Edwards out, he comes in for Hinchcliffe.

 

[josh11223344]

favourites:

1- jarryd hayne
2- akuila uate
3- michael jennings
4- ricky leutele
5- tuivasa-sheck
6- todd carney
7- shaun johnson
8- andrew fifita
9- jake friend
10- JWH
11- jason taumololo
12- tony williams
13- wade graham

 

[deano the p]

Overrated:
1) Moylan
2) Vatuvei
3) Nielson
4) Beale
5) D. Williams
6) J. Reynolds
7) Pearce
8) Hunt
9) Gidley
10) Mannah
11) McQueen
12) Papali
13) Peachey

14) T. Sims
15) M. Minichiello
16) T. Williams
17) Buhrer

 

[Sir Chadley]

Gee Sharky 14, took a long time for this thread to get going but once it did, wow!

I'll be putting up some teams of my own later tonight.

 

[deano the p]

Favourite Sharks:
1) Peachey
2) Rogers
3) ET
4) Mellor
5) Best
6) Campbell
7) Carney
8) Nutley
9) Treister
10) Lang
11) Gallen
12) Bird
13) N. Graham

14) Beattie
15) Dykes
16) Taga
17) W. Graham

 

[snowman]

sharks favourites

1) Peachey
2) Rogers
3) Vagana
4) E.T
5) Young Colin Best
6) Carney
7) Kimmorley
8) Fifita
9) Morris
10) Snowden
11) Sean Ryan
12) Wade Graham
13) Nick Graham

14) Preston Campbell
15) Danny Nutley
16) Greg Bird
17) Luke Douglas

 

[deano the p]

Dougie!!! I forgot Dougie, he has to come in for Taga.

 

[snowman]

you have no idea the stress i came under not being able to find a spot for tawera nikau

 

[BurgoShark]

Best Sharks players never to have represented City/County, State of Origin or ANY Country

1. Chris Quinn
2. Craig Dimond
3. Chris Gardner
4. Paul Mellor
5. Glenn Coleman
6. Michael Speechley
7. Barry Russell

13. David Hatch
12. Andrew Pierce
11. David Boughton
10. Michael Porter
9. Kevin Kingston
8. Andrew Hick

14. Matt Hilder
15. Dean Treister
16. Craig Stapleton
17. ???

 

[northofthebordershark]

Anthony Watts hasn't made any of the misfit/grub teams yet

 

[batsun]

Supercoach Dream Team
1 Inglis
2 Mansour
3 Lyon
4 Jennings
5 Gordon
6 Hayne
7 Thurston
8 Fifita
9 Smith
10 Gallen
11 SBW
12 Parker
13 Fensom

14 Milford
15 Watmough
16 Burgess
17 Merrin

 

[Sharky14]

Nrls most underrated
1. Josh Hoffman- yes he has played rep football but i would take him at fullback any day of the week. They moved him for barba who was average at best at the end of last season.
2. Saia Feki- based off the end of last year and the first few games this year kid deserves a wrap.
3. Jarrod Croker- one of my personal favourites, very good footballer
4. Dean whare- i have to say, he is very Jennings like
5. Kevin gordon- safe under the high ball and great finisher
6. Thomas Leiluai- cant push townsend out when he was the dominant half toward the end of last season
7. Ben Hunt- pushed out by Karmichael Hunt... if broncs officials even contemplate it they have **** for brains.
8. Luke Douglas- mr.underrated himself
9. John Morris- im sorry but jmoz is one of the best hookers in the game. Matt Ballin deserves a mention too.
10. Martin Tapau- release this kid, keep kasiano... okay bulldogs.
11. Anthony Tupou- another shark thats underated
12. Jeremy Smith- yes he has played for NZ but I still dont think he gets what he deserves.
13. Sean Fensom- check the numbers...

To see what players people select and why... like what they look for in a player, its interesting...

 

[sharkyman]

Most overrated:

1- will zillman (just for the fact he got a 5 year contract and provides nothing as a fullback)
2- nathan merritt (playing outside gi and having the media push you for origin as you're aboriginal get's you a blues jumper it seems)
3- jack reed
4- dane nielsen
5- akuila uate (not bad, just hasn't progressed)
6- james maloney
7- adam reynolds (it will do me if he's picked for origin because of fan and media pressure. Pearce ****s on him)
8- james graham
9- I honestly can't think of any overrated dummy halves
10- david shillington
11- chris mcqueen
12- simon mannering
13- shaun fensom

I was going to add
9- Isaac DeGois... but then realised noone rates him.

 

[SkullCrusher]

Favourite Sharks
1-David Peachy/Brett Kearney
2-Luke Covell
3-Colin Best
4-Phil Bailey
5-Matthew Rieck
6-Todd Carney
7-Brett Kimmorley
8-Jason Stevens
9-Dean Bosnich
10-Martin Lang
11-Danny Nutley
12-Frazer Anderson
13-Lance Thompson

14-Kevin Kingston
15-Hutch Maiava
16-Luke Douglas
17-Nathan Long

Liked the inclusion of Fraser Anderson, actually named my son Fraser after him, couple of months prior to his switch to Japanese Rugby. Whatever happened to him? Also, thought he was better at centre, but yeah, your list.

Also, good thread. Some good lists on here.

 

[Sir Chadley]

My all time favourite Sharks players

David Peachey
Dean Carney
Steve Rogers/ET - can't split them
Mark McGaw
Mat Rogers
Barry "Panda" Andrews
Tommy Bishop
Cliff Watson
John McMartin
Danny Lee
Gavin Miller
Steve Kneen
Greg Pierce

Paul Gallen
Kurt Sorenson
Martin Lang
Les Davidson

 

[Sharky14]

My all time favourite Sharks players

David Peachey
Dean Carney
Steve Rogers/ET - can't split them
Mark McGaw
Mat Rogers
Barry "Panda" Andrews
Tommy Bishop
Cliff Watson
John McMartin
Danny Lee
Gavin Miller
Steve Kneen
Greg Pierce

Paul Gallen
Kurt Sorenson
Martin Lang
Les Davidson

My favourite "My favourite Sharks team" Sharks team.

 

[sharkyboy]

Has Chris Mckenna got a mention in here yet?

Him, Dean Treister, matty Rieck and Rogers were my heroes growing up.

 

[Jigsaw]

Current fav players

1 - William Zillman
2 - Kevin Gordon
3 - Brad Tighe
4 – Maurice Blair
5 - David Mead
6 - Aidan Sezer
7 - Albert Kelly
8 - Luke Douglas
9 - Beau Falloon
10 - Nate Myles
11 - Greg Bird
12 – David Taylor
13 - Ashley Harrison
INTERCHANGE (from)
14 - Matthew White
15 - Luke Bailey
16 - Mark Minichiello
17 - Ryan James

 

[dylan the villian]

Misfits (I've gone for a combination of 'bad boys', players who play a limited amount of games a year, players with a stigma & players who suck at fullback)

1-Albert Kelly
2-Sandor Earl
3-Blake Ferguson
4-Dane Gagai/Steve Matai
5-John Hopoate
6-Matthew Johns
7-Andrew Johns
8-Kade Snowden
9-
10-Jarad Waerea-Hargreaves
11-Darcy Lusskick
12-Tony Williams
13-Paul Gallen

After game party is at Paul Gallen's house, Beau Ryan is the host & The Johns are bringing all the party supplies.

surely birdy makes the cut?