Who Should We Look At For 2015?

[deano the p]

Would love to sign Walsh. I was calling for us to sign him a couple of seasons back. He would make a HUGE difference to our side IMO.

 

[JimBob]

Would love to sign Walsh. I was calling for us to sign him a couple of seasons back. He would make a HUGE difference to our side IMO.

Not a fan of Walsh.

The guy goes missing too much, especially when you need him most, and his defence is horrid.

He's got a good kicking game though.

 

[deano the p]

Not a fan of Walsh.

The guy goes missing too much, especially when you need him most, and his defence is horrid.

He's got a good kicking game though.

I know you're not that's why we should sign him

 

[Sir Chadley]

Not a fan of Walsh.

The guy goes missing too much, especially when you need him most, and his defence is horrid.

He's got a good kicking game though.

Because he's a good player?

 

[Gumby]

Not a fan of Walsh.

The guy goes missing too much, especially when you need him most, and his defence is horrid.

He's got a good kicking game though.

Wouldn't be in the team for his defence. Has one of the best kicking game's in the comp. And great passing game, speed and good vision.

Or would you rather a bloke who defends alright, can't kick, has no speed, can't pass and has no direction whatsoever??

 

[deano the p]

Wouldn't be in the team for his defence. Has one of the best kicking game's in the comp. And great passing game, speed and good vision.

Or would you rather a bloke who defends alright, can't kick, has no speed, can't pass and has no direction whatsoever??

Yes he would. I've had that argument with him before.

 

[JimBob]

Wouldn't be in the team for his defence. Has one of the best kicking game's in the comp. And great passing game, speed and good vision.

Or would you rather a bloke who defends alright, can't kick, has no speed, can't pass and has no direction whatsoever??

The guy can have the best passing and kicking game in the comp, but what use is it if he doesn't get involved?

That's what irked Penrith fans the most about him. One week he would have the ball on a string and lead the Panthers to victory, then the next 6 weeks it would seem he wasn't even on the field.

 

[slide rule]

He's not fantastic but he's better than what we have now. I wouldn't pay a fortune for him though.

 

[Gumby]

The guy can have the best passing and kicking game in the comp, but what use is it if he doesn't get involved?

That's what irked Penrith fans the most about him. One week he would have the ball on a string and lead the Panthers to victory, then the next 6 weeks it would seem he wasn't even on the field.

And the bloke we have now wins us how many games a year ? lol

 

[sharkyboy]

The guy can have the best passing and kicking game in the comp, but what use is it if he doesn't get involved?

That's what irked Penrith fans the most about him. One week he would have the ball on a string and lead the Panthers to victory, then the next 6 weeks it would seem he wasn't even on the field.

Just…. ehh its not worth it today.

 

[bluey]

Not a fan of Walsh.

The guy goes missing too much, especially when you need him most, and his defence is horrid.

He's got a good kicking game though.

Penny supporters were happy to see him go because of this

 

[Opeth]

Not a fan of Walsh.

The guy goes missing too much, especially when you need him most, and his defence is horrid.

He's got a good kicking game though.

at least he can go missing in games. Robson doesn't even turn up.

 

[snowman]

i would rather luke walsh "going missing" and still have a threatening kicking game, and lead the nrl in assists off kicks, than have jeff robson...

 

[bluey]

It is crap how all the 7s have dried up , Is it because of the way the game is played now???
Left and right side compared to an open side and a blind side???

 

[sharks2010]

i would rather luke walsh "going missing" and still have a threatening kicking game, and lead the nrl in assists off kicks, than have jeff robson...

this, if we are going to have a half back to play for a few years until brown is ready Walsh would fill the void fine

 

[evertonshark]

The guy can have the best passing and kicking game in the comp, but what use is it if he doesn't get involved?

That's what irked Penrith fans the most about him. One week he would have the ball on a string and lead the Panthers to victory, then the next 6 weeks it would seem he wasn't even on the field.

Who are all these penrith fans you always speak of ? It's like you're their official spokesman

 

[sharkyboy]

Who are all these penrith fans you always speak of ? It's like you're their official spokesman

He's probably over there doing the same thing for all of us Cronulla supporters.

"oh yeah I'm a big dog on the sharks forum. We all think Simmons shouldn't have been let go and Robson is one of the greats".

 

[JimBob]

Who are all these penrith fans you always speak of ? It's like you're their official spokesman

I use to post on Panther Pride and I visit Penrith's LU section at least 5 times a day.

 

[JimBob]

He's probably over there doing the same thing for all of us Cronulla supporters.

"oh yeah I'm a big dog on the sharks forum. We all think Simmons shouldn't have been let go and Robson is one of the greats".

Actually no, when I was posting on PP I spoke about how the Sharks fans weren't happy with Robson and how I hoped we would sign Austin.

 

[SJH]

I still think Sam Williams is worth the risk 2 year deal