Where Do We Go From Here?

[vicsharkfan]

Think some of you listen to James hooper to much, gal always has and always will have the sharks back...any lesser a man would have bailed years ago. Gal 4 lyf

 

[HITMAN]

Gal has earned every right to whinge about this rabble of a club.

 

[Fozzym]

im gunna say it, knowing i will get a spray. gal is the worst captain we've had.
he is a leader on the field yes, but **** me on tv pr in interviews he has a long way to go.

asked about todd carneys previous incidents........i dont know what they were, that was between noyce and todd.

no, you do know. instead of the typical cronulla ' i dont know ' how bout you say, im not going to comment on that. he publicly shamed the whole team last week, maybe they needed it, but he is just not fit to be a spot light captain IMO. too much sulking. Ennis is called a grub, but every single incident has been left on the field, he isnt on the footy show carrying on, post game pressers, radio etc.

Or maybe he genuinely didn't know what they were, and they were between Noyce and Todd. Just quietly, what difference does it make whether he says "no comment" or "that's between Noyce and Todd"? Are you seriously getting up him for that? Fmd that's a tad uncalled for.

To me Gal hasn't been sulking at all. He was asked a question and he gave an honest answer. Spoke his mind. I understand how his comments could be seen as unnecessary but it's a far cry from the "dug deep", "credit to the boys" cliches we usually get from players. It was refreshing for a change.

 

[Fozzym]

Paul Gallen can play football yes - but everything he does is for Paul Gallen. I would not be upset if he decided to hang the boots up after origin 3 or went somewhere else.

So I agree with you.

So when he had the choice to leave for Manly for more money and potentially multiple premierships and chose to stay, he was only thinking of Paul Gallen right?

 

[slide rule]

So when he had the choice to leave for Manly for more money and potentially multiple premierships and chose to stay, he was only thinking of Paul Gallen right?

Were we even in a bad position when he got the offer? And were Manly even good then? I can't remember ancient history.

Remember how Manly were absolutely **** for a while before they bought BK? Then they rebuilt, just like Cronulla will do.

It's cyclical, all cyclical.

 

[Fozzym]

Were we even in a bad position when he got the offer? And were Manly even good then? I can't remember ancient history.

Remember how Manly were absolutely **** for a while before they bought BK? Then they rebuilt, just like Cronulla will do.

It's cyclical, all cyclical.

Are we ever not in a bad position?

He said he got bigger offers for Manly at the end of both 2007 and 2010. Both right before they won premierships. Not exactly ancient history.

 

[Opeth]

Are we ever not in a bad position?

He said he got bigger offers for Manly at the end of both 2007 and 2010. Both right before they won premierships. Not exactly ancient history.

haha probably kicking himself now

 

[slide rule]

Are we ever not in a bad position?

He said he got bigger offers for Manly at the end of both 2007 and 2010. Both right before they won premierships. Not exactly ancient history.

Before 09 we were fine.

 

[Fozzym]

Before 09 we were fine.

Ricky Stuart. We weren't fine.

 

[BlackWhiteBlue]

Or maybe he genuinely didn't know what they were, and they were between Noyce and Todd. Just quietly, what difference does it make whether he says "no comment" or "that's between Noyce and Todd"? Are you seriously getting up him for that? Fmd that's a tad uncalled for.

To me Gal hasn't been sulking at all. He was asked a question and he gave an honest answer. Spoke his mind. I understand how his comments could be seen as unnecessary but it's a far cry from the "dug deep", "credit to the boys" cliches we usually get from players. It was refreshing for a change.

If a captain doesnt know he aint much of a captain.

Im not denying his ability or heart or anything. Im talking about his role as captain

 

[slide rule]

Ricky Stuart. We weren't fine.

None of this doubt or self-fulfilling doom existed prior to the first couple of scandals in 2009.

 

[slide rule]

If a captain doesnt know he aint much of a captain.

Im not denying his ability or heart or anything. Im talking about his role as captain

But if he isn't told, then that's not really his fault. He's not the employer, he can't really demand to know.

 

[BlackWhiteBlue]

But if he isn't told, then that's not really his fault. He's not the employer, he can't really demand to know.

U act like gal isnt at northies every spare minute with todd

 

[Fozzym]

If a captain doesnt know he aint much of a captain.

Im not denying his ability or heart or anything. Im talking about his role as captain

Why would him being captain make him more privy to information about off field discipline? It's not his job to know.

 

[slide rule]

U act like gal isnt at northies every spare minute with todd

I don't think he is, to be honest.

 

[FNQ Shark]

Gal has earned every right to whinge about this rabble of a club.

Couldn't agree more! If ya start turning on Gal you'd turn on anyone. Quite simply the man spits blood for this club. The worktate and never give up attitude he shows week in week out on the field despite what goes on around him is second to none. If the sharks had 17 players that even put in what Gal puts in talent aside they'd have silverware in the cupboard make no mistake about that.

 

[BlackWhiteBlue]

So most of australia hears whispers that todd has been up to his old tricks, yet one of the closest to him hasno idea? Bull****.

Im all for him protecting or not saying. Im sick of this 'i dont know' ****

 

[Fozzym]

I don't think he is, to be honest.

Agree. Ridiculous claim

 

[BlackWhiteBlue]

Couldn't agree more! If ya start turning on Gal you'd turn on anyone. Quite simply the man spits blood for this club. The worktate and never give up attitude he shows week in week out on the field despite what goes on around him is second to none. If the sharks had 17 players that even put in what Gal puts in talent aside they'd have silverware in the cupboard make no mistake about that.

Again im not turning on him, i just dont think he is a good captain in the club spokesperson area.

 

[Fozzym]

So most of australia hears whispers that todd has been up to his old tricks, yet one of the closest to him hasno idea? Bull****.

Im all for him protecting or not saying. Im sick of this 'i dont know' ****

Dude it's a non-issue. Giving him a "worst captain ever" tag over this is ridiculous. Read what you are typing.