This Year's Opinions?

[mjef3966]

I strongly feel that the Storms are so dirty, not only that they get away with so much.
they are constantly slowing the play the ball working players on the ground and holding for too long. and they still get away with it.

Dirtiest team of the year

1. Storms (The dirtiest team since the Oakland Raiders)

Surprise team of the year:

1. Warriors

Overrated Player of the year

1. Benji Marshal

 

[chunk67]

Dirtiest: Cowboys (last night confirmed my view)
Suprise: Souths
Overrated: Nate Myles

 

[Capital_Shark]

Dirtiest: I can't think of an entire club, but some of Gallen's performances this year could be worthy, unfortunately.

Surprise: Parramatta. I had 'em pegged for the spoon on the back of the Finch/Smith halves combo and Michael Hagen without Joey. D'oh!

Over-rated: Another tough one, depends who you listen to. Certainly not SBW this year. Might go with chunk and say Myles.

 

[Jigsaw]

Dirtiest - Us with Gallen

Surprise - Surprised to see Brisbane have such a **** yeah hahahah and im loving it!

Over-Rated - Jamie Lyon/Craig Gower

 

[zakspiders]

dirtiest-dogs
surprise-raiders
over-rated-lyons/tate/a.ryan

 

[GO GO GALLEN!!]

dirtiest - team: dogs, player: mark riddell

surprise - the roosters (back end of the season charge)

over rated - reni matiua

underrated - luke douglas, reece williams and christian inu

 

[Dutchie1983]

Dirtiest Team - Storm (by a mile)
Dirtiest Player - Riddel or Jeremy Smith
Suprise Team - Sharks with our run of Injuries
Suprise Player - Kristen Inu
Over rated team - Parra
Over rated player - Anasta
Under rated team - Raiders and Sharks
Under rated player - Dougie for sure

 

[Great White Shark]

Dirtiest - the Dogs...as usual. Have to account for their fans as well;
Surprise - Titans. Never thought they would be close to the 8 in their first year;
Overrated - Nobby Kimmorley by the countriest of country miles!!!

 

[Lettuce_Sharks]

for overrated, id go the entier dragons team

 

[scott17]

i agree with evrything dutchie said, krisnan inu is a freak

 

[peachey]

Dirtiest Team - storm
Dirtiest Player - Matt King or Gallen (yes thats right - done some very stupid things of late)
Suprise Team -Sharks - havent been smashed yet this year, has this happened before?
Suprise Player -krisian inu/de gois
Over rated team -Manly
Over rated player -Jamie Lyon/Kimmorley (non bias involved)
Under rated team -Warriors/Raiders
Under rated player - Douglas/Sonny Bill

 

[scott17]

kimmorley isnt overated

you just hate him lol

 

[Capital_Shark]

No, without trying to bag Noddy in any way, he is over-rated. If you listen to the CH9 mob and some FOX commentators they are living in the past. He hasn't performed consistently to their standards for years, and certainly not in a Sharks jersey.

 

[scott17]

yeah true, id still have him in my team

or maybe seymour halfback

 

[Lettuce_Sharks]

Dirtiest Team - storm
Dirtiest Player - Matt King or Gallen (yes thats right - done some very stupid things of late)
Suprise Team -Sharks - havent been smashed yet this year, has this happened before?
Suprise Player -krisian inu/de gois
Over rated team -Manly
Over rated player -Jamie Lyon/Kimmorley (non bias involved)
Under rated team -Warriors/Raiders
Under rated player - Douglas/Sonny Bill

not that i like the team, but how can manly be overrated when they are sitting 2nd on the ladder?

 

[scott17]

yeah true but what i think hes saying is there not as good as every1 makes out they are

 

[peachey]

exactly scott...if they were so good they would of smashed us...same again for the storm

 

[teflon77]

Dirtiest Team - storm
Dirtiest Player - Matt King or Gallen (yes thats right - done some very stupid things of late)
Suprise Team -Sharks - havent been smashed yet this year, has this happened before?
Suprise Player -krisian inu/de gois
Over rated team -Manly
Over rated player -Jamie Lyon/Kimmorley (non bias involved)
Under rated team -Warriors/Raiders
Under rated player - Douglas/Sonny Bill

Peach, tell me how sonny bill is under rated mate????

 

[peachey]

i just dont think he is given as much praise for his talent as he deserves, alot of people dont really give him much credit and they focus to much on the bad things he has done, he is a game changer and can win games by himself..

 

[scott17]

i hate sonny bill williams