State of Origin 2012 Game 3 Discussion

[josh11223344]

I see what you two are saying but I can't see what is gained from hindy coming on and playing those 20 odd minutes. He doesn't possess any impact or danger to the other team in his hitups and with tough defenders in watmough, lewis, bird, gallen I can't see any reason to carry a defensive backrower. Those attacking stats aren't impressive from creagh but I have more faith in him making the dangerous runs and he obviously works hard in defense.

We'll agree to disagree.

 

[A.Snowden]

Im with bastard and 2010 on this. Hindy would give his all if he was selected.

 

[Mark^Bastard]

I see what you two are saying but I can't see what is gained from hindy coming on and playing those 20 odd minutes. He doesn't possess any impact or danger to the other team in his hitups and with tough defenders in watmough, lewis, bird, gallen I can't see any reason to carry a defensive backrower. Those attacking stats aren't impressive from creagh but I have more faith in him making the dangerous runs and he obviously works hard in defense.

We'll agree to disagree.

It's more that you don't lose anything. He'll defend better, attack the same (ordinary) but will have more passion and will give NSW something to aim up for. I know they have plenty of motivation already but I reckon Hindmarsh would see it as his last great game.

I'm not even a Hindmarsh fan. If we didn't have Creagh in the team I'd never suggest this. It's just if you have someone like Creagh that doesn't deserve to play for NSW and never had deserved it, you may as well give it to someone that actually deserves it.