NRL Halfbacks...

[Rise_Against]

Who are your top 10 Halfbacks of the NRL at the moment?

Mine are...

1. Jonathan Thurston
2. Scott Prince
3. Cooper Cronk
4. Brett Finch
5. Mitchell Pearce
6. Todd Carney
7. Peter Wallace
8. Matt Orford
9. Brett Kimmorley
10. Jarrod Sammut

 

[Sharks#1]

im sure you got that wrong shuldunt kimmorley be no 1

 

[Rise_Against]

No no i don't.

 

[brad]

maybe if it was for defensive 1/2backs

 

[peachey]

1. Thurston
2. Prince
3. Cronk
4. Finch
5. Pearce
6. Carney
7. Wallace
8. gidley ( swaps between fullback and halfback)
9. head
10. Mullen

9 and 10 were a struggle because there arn't that many decent halves these days

 

[Rise_Against]

yeah, and grant rovelli isn't too bad!

 

[zakspiders]

1.prince
2 thurston

 

[Rise_Against]

mmm, they are quite even zak!

 

[scott17]

1.prince
2.thurston
3.cronk
4. pearce
5.carney
6.wallace
7.finch
8. kimmorley
9.orford
10. head

 

[jedman1]

i know its hard to put him in front of any of those guys, but i reckon Buster could hold his own against half of them at least. And then if you factor in the cash we could sign him for NOW, I still think he is a priority contract to get done sooner rather than later.

 

[Bungy]

as i've said before noddy should have been a hooker at least 2-3 years ago and then maybe we would be saying how good he is like Monahan for manly

 

[Bungy]

and I agree kimmorley is near the bottom of the list

 

[teflon77]

and I agree kimmorley is near the bottom of the list

That just confirms that you dont know **** mate. What I love about Noddy bashers is the fact that they disregard every other teammate that plays alongside him and put the blame for losses squarely on Noddy's shoulders. Noddy isnt the best half in the comp but he is far from the worst. There is no way that Finch is better than Kimmorley.

 

[Bungy]

That just confirms that you dont know **** mate. What I love about Noddy bashers is the fact that they disregard every other teammate that plays alongside him and put the blame for losses squarely on Noddy's shoulders. Noddy isnt the best half in the comp but he is far from the worst. There is no way that Finch is better than Kimmorley.

That just confirms that "YOU" dont know **** mate. Read it properly, I DIDN'T SAY he's resposible for all our losses. I'm saying he should have became a good hooker years ago.

 

[bort]

and I agree kimmorley is near the bottom of the list

That just confirms that "YOU" dont know **** mate. Read it properly, I DIDN'T SAY he's resposible for all our losses. I'm saying he should have became a good hooker years ago.

i dont believe thats what you were saying at all, in fact you didnt even say one of those words!

 

[Bungy]

as i've said before noddy should have been a hooker at least 2-3 years ago and then maybe we would be saying how good he is like Monahan for manly

HEY BORT READ THE POST ONE UP FROM THE 2ND ONE

 

[bort]

HEY BORT READ THE POST ONE UP FROM THE 2ND ONE

TEF WASNT RESPONDING TO THAT ONE THOUGH WAS HE!
he didnt say anything about hooker, he just disagreed that noddy was one of the worst halfbacks
(why are we shouting?)

 

[teflon77]

Lol, thanks Bort. Bungy, you may or may not be anti Kimmorley but to say Noddy is at the bottom of that list is wrong IMO. In saying that you are entitled to your opinion. In fact the only person here not entitled to their opinion is Peach because he is always wrong. I may have over reacted but I do that sometimes when I get caught up in Peachy's anti-Kimmorley rants. (See any of Peach's listed posts for the last 3 years.) My humble appologies if I offended you mate. Noddy will always be a divisive figure amongst Sharks fans which is no fault of his just the way it is. I've noticed that there is not much middle ground when it comes to him its either like or hate.

 

[Bungy]

I think noddy is a very good defender, kicker, kick chaser, and he's tough, I think his organization skills and creative plays are a bit predictable but he could have been a very valuable dummy half runner, an important position in any team.

Bungy Bounces Back

 

[teflon77]

I think noddy is a very good defender, kicker, kick chaser, and he's tough, I think his organization skills and creative plays are a bit predictable but he could have been a very valuable dummy half runner, an important position in any team.

Bungy Bounces Back

No argument mate, fair observations. I officially retract my stance that you dont know ****. I was heavily influenced by Peach fever.