Most under rated and over rated current players in NRL

[Sevshark]

Overrated: Manu; fantastic player sure but plays selfish footy imo

Underrated: Jaimin Jolliffe; think anyone who is familiar with me on the forum knows I love an honest hard-working forward. I think he's going to have a huge season now that Tino has been ruled out.
53 tackles this year for 0 misses in a horrendous titans side.
Bring him home.

 

[Western Sharkie]

Overrated: Manu; fantastic player sure but plays selfish footy imo

Underrated: Jaimin Jolliffe; think anyone who is familiar with me on the forum knows I love an honest hard-working forward. I think he's going to have a huge season now that Tino has been ruled out.
53 tackles this year for 0 misses in a horrendous titans side.
Bring him home.

Oh, and here I am thinking it was just Ellie!

 

[Sevshark]

Oh, and here I am thinking it was just Ellie!

Ellie is a goddess and none but I am worthy of her love.

 

[Wizard]

Overrated - David Fifita
Blayke Brailey

Underrated - I would’ve said Edwards but that’s old news, this year it’s Tago and Leo Thompson

 

[Sparkles]

Over - Latrell and Dylan Brown
Under - DWZ and anyone with red hair

How would you feel if Latrell dyed his hair red?

 

[Wizard]

Overrated: Manu; fantastic player sure but plays selfish footy imo

Underrated: Jaimin Jolliffe; think anyone who is familiar with me on the forum knows I love an honest hard-working forward. I think he's going to have a huge season now that Tino has been ruled out.
53 tackles this year for 0 misses in a horrendous titans side.
Bring him home.

Sev bro ..Manu is a genuine gun

 

[Sevshark]

Sev bro ..Manu is a genuine gun

Needs to learn to pass the ball Wiz

Other than that, fantastic player as I said

 

[Sharkfox]

Most underrated - Lachlan Croker

Most overrated - Blayke Brailey

 

[HaroldBishop]

How would you feel if Latrell dyed his hair red?

Why do this to me?

 

[Sevshark]

Why do this to me?

If Tino dyed his I reckon you'd buy a titans membership

 

[HaroldBishop]

If Tino dyed his I reckon you'd buy a titans membership

Not sure I could love Tino anymore

 

[Capital_Shark]

Over - Burton & his ****ing bombs that everyone seems to squeal about but the opposition catch no worries.

Under - lots, but Garrick & Croker were good shouts

 

[Flanno]

Over - Burton & his ****ing bombs that everyone seems to squeal about but the opposition catch no worries.

Under - lots, but Garrick & Croker were good shouts

Good call on Burton, was just thinking before I was surprised no one had mentioned him

 

[Sevshark]

Good call on Burton, was just thinking before I was surprised no one had mentioned him

Thought we would have seen Nanai by now as well tbh
Would have been my less controversial shout for overrated

 

[Deleted member 2543]

Thought we would have seen Nanai by now as well tbh
Would have been my less controversial shout for overrated

I think a lot of young players get over-hyped early. Nanai imo is a much better player than now than 2 years ago, but the hype has died down because the Cowboys missed the finals and he isn’t scoring tries from bombs every week.

Pretty common for a young player to come in and perform really well for a while and then have a bit of a dip. The grind and all - plus once opposition teams have a month worth of video to study it makes things tougher.

Nanai very similar to Nikora in this way imo. I think both have come out the other side of this.

 

[Sevshark]

I think a lot of young players get over-hyped early. Nanai imo is a much better player than now than 2 years ago, but the hype has died down because the Cowboys missed the finals and he isn’t scoring tries from bombs every week.

Pretty common for a young player to come in and perform really well for a while and then have a bit of a dip. The grind and all - plus once opposition teams have a month worth of video to study it makes things tougher.

Nanai very similar to Nikora in this way imo. I think both have come out the other side of this.

I'd still like to see him get through some more work, especially inside their own half but your right that hype has died down somewhat.

I admit Cowboys often play a style that doesn't help him there though.

 

[Jeff Robson]

Overrated - Josh Schuster

 

[Deleted member 2543]

I'd still like to see him get through some more work, especially inside their own half but your right that hype has died down somewhat.

I admit Cowboys often play a style that doesn't help him there though.

Also similar to Nikora there.

 

[Sevshark]

Also similar to Nikora there.

Yeah nearly put that on second line as well

 

[vicsharkfan]

Underrated- nick Meaney (storm)