Halfback for 2012

[greg_bird]

vote for the player you would most like to see start the year at halfback

 

[josh11223344]

graham now

 

[deano the p]

Carney.

 

[snowman]

carney

 

[Tyger Sharky]

Townsend

 

[goodbyepenrithhellosharks]

carney

 

[sharks4ever]

Carney

 

[gando2230]

Townsend.

 

[baanya]

I'm putting it out there... Even though I don't like the idea I feel flanno will go with robson...more experience and he has coached him before... Flanno recruited him as he can lead a team around the park which is what we struggled with depiste Townsends great efforts.. ...even with no carney I reckon robson would have been no7 next to Kelly in the 6.. Graham to the forwards

 

[CrazyMatt]

I think Robson will start there, but Carney will find his way there eventually.

 

[shark 101]

i want carney attacking not organising therefore he should be at six.
definately not graham at 7: has no kicking game which cost us games this year.
degois doesn't kick much and i haven't seen gards kick therefore we need a good kicking half. I dont want carney being used as a organiser and having to worry about sides kicking game.

id prefer townsend or robson.

 

[bluey]

Graham, Carney, Degois have to be in the side, that leaves
IMO in this order
Halves Kelly Robson Townsend
Hookers Morris Robson

All will come down to trial form

 

[Tank]

Carney 7 Kelly 6

 

[Great_White_Shark]

Anyone notice how carney has the most votes for halfback and 5/8th!

Would be awesome if we had 2 carneys!

I'm gonna say Carney 6 Townsend 7

 

[Mr Wright]

Carney

 

[The Shire]

i just think kelly has to be in the side. dont forget how good he was in the first 7 rounds at the start of the year.

 

[Mr Wright]

6. Kelly 7. Carney.

Flanno said he sees Kelly purely as a 6. While Carney can play both.

 

[egg]

Bloody oath, Kelly IS the goods , stayed true to the SHARKS (especiallywhen we neaded some GREAT news) and will get better, him and Carney, LETHAL WEAPONS .

 

[hitman124]

Did Kelly play a great game at 7 against penrith in round 2 or 3?

Id like Carney 6
Kelly 7

But Id be more than happy either way.

 

[Born&bred]

My worry with Kelly is whether he can hack the punishment in the halves.

I'm not convinced he won't be injury prone.

I'm not death riding him, far from it - I would love it if he stayed fit and killed it.

I just have a question mark over whether he's physically up to it (yet).