Gallen: "I don't want to captain australian diving team"

Shiredad

Great White
Joined
Aug 16, 2006
Messages
3,117
Reaction score
77
Location
not in the shire anymore :(
Shark denies taking a dive
By Dean Ritchie
June 12, 2007 SHARKS back rower Paul Gallen vehemently denies taking a dive during the spiteful and ferocious derby against St George-Illawarra at OKI Jubilee Stadium last night.

Sharks coach Ricky Stuart and Dragons rival Nathan Brown agreed that diving had become an issue in rugby league, saying the NRL had to change the rule whereby a player can stay down and receive a penalty through the video referee.

The match, won 20-16 by the Sharks, was one of the most fierce and torrid southern Sydney derbies in history.

St George-Illawarra hammered the Sharks tryline late in the match, but the Sharks - for so long the Dragons' "little brother" - held on to record a memorable victory that cemented their position in the top eight.

The Dragons were brave in defeat, playing the final 32 minutes with 12 men after prop Adam Peek was sent off for a late elbow to the head of Sharks halfback Adam Dykes.

Peek walked into the Sharks dressing room at full-time to apologise to Dykes - the pair long-time friends.

A concerned Stuart meanwhile spoke to NRL chief executive David Gallop about diving.

Gallen was one of several players accused of taking a dive when clipped high by Dragons five-eighth Richie Williams in the second half. Gallen rose to his feet and winked.

Both teams said they disliked the rule but would continue to exploit it while penalties were on offer.

"I was hit in the head and it hurt," Gallen said.

"It didn't miss my jaw.

"The referee saw it and we got the penalty."

Brown, who claimed that Dykes lay down after being hit in the head by Peek, said diving had become a "sad" part of rugby league.

"It is supposed to be the toughest sport in the world," Brown said.

"My dad always told me if you lie down then you don't go back on again.

"You can't lift an elbow to someone's head (as Peek did).

"Even though Dykesy would have got an Oscar, I can't condone what (Peek) did."

Stuart said that players should not be criticised for laying down, and the NRL should take it out of the players' hands by changing the rules.

Asked about the possibility that Dykes lay down, Stuart said: "Look at his (bloodied) ear. He didn't lay down.

"It is something that is creeping into the game. I don't agree with it and it's disappointing but eradicating it is difficult.

"If there's 30 seconds to go and you're down by one point in the grand final, what would you do?"

Dykes said that players were only acting within the rules when laying down.

"You do what you have to do to win," Dykes said.

Stuart described Peek's send-off as a "brain explosion".

"He'd be thinking 'what have I done' and 'why did I do that'," Stuart said.

Gallen was also placed on report for a high tackle on Dragons forward Ben Creagh, who came from the field but later returned.

Source:http://www.foxsports.com.au/story/0,8659,21890467-23214,00.html

My suspicion ... which is probably wrong ... is that Ricky is quietly asking some of the senior players to take notice of how the ref is handling high-ish tackles. If he's awarding penalties for border-line high tackles, and we need some points or field position, then lay down.

I think he's doing it, not simply to get points and win games, but I suspect he might be pressuring David Gallop/NRL to have the rules adjusted, by pointing out the problems with the rules.

Just a thought.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Capmar

Grey Nurse
Joined
Aug 7, 2006
Messages
569
Reaction score
10
Location
Maroubra NSW
Big deal

All of a sudden the Sharkies are a tougher unit under Ricky who play to win and the so called power clubs like St George start to whinge.

The Sharks did nothing wrong but win

The others just better get used to it
 

wang shark

Bronze Whaler
Joined
May 29, 2007
Messages
145
Reaction score
1
whats wrong with taking a dive to earn a penalty all teams do it and it worked for the italians in the soccer last year.
 

Shiredad

Great White
Joined
Aug 16, 2006
Messages
3,117
Reaction score
77
Location
not in the shire anymore :(
If st george illawarra did it and won the game, we'd be pissed off.

I think diving suggests that the player who takes the dive is somewhat ... soft and womanly?

Unless it's one of our guys and we win. Then he's a bloody legend!
 

Megashark

Jaws
Joined
Aug 23, 2006
Messages
5,826
Reaction score
63
Location
Auckland NZ
If the referees do their job properly then none of this is an issue. It is the referees job to penalise a high shot, regardless of whether the tackled player stays down or gets straight to his feet.
 

wang shark

Bronze Whaler
Joined
May 29, 2007
Messages
145
Reaction score
1
who was ref i know that s.clark is pro manly anyone remember the manly v penrith game penaltys were 2 to 1 and they still didn't win i hate biased refs who are influenced by home crowds.it is most noticable at parra stadium they can be offside all day and one boo from the parraplegics and whadda ya know penalty!
 

the_prawn

Hammerhead
Joined
Jul 28, 2006
Messages
380
Reaction score
3
Location
down by woolooware bay
gal only did it to get one back on creagh. thats who he winked at.

he knows creagh fell into his bicep, there was no swinging arm, and coz they were under the pump he layed down to get off their own 10m line. gal was standing there telling him to get up, which made it funnier when he winked at him once he got it back.

he better not get any suspension. i don't think he will but what do you guys reckon?
the judiciary is not exactly known for its consistency.
 

Catfish

Bronze Whaler
Joined
Jun 12, 2007
Messages
158
Reaction score
18
I agree with the prawn 100%, Gallen was proving a point with that penalty. He got hit high, was it really bad? No. Did it cause him injury? No. Same can be said for Creagh for the exact same sort of tackle. Creagh milked it and if anyone deserves an oscar for their performance it was him. Poor rendition of a person concussed that one. Gallen took opportunity to get the same for his team and they knew exactly why he winked.....its a little thing called karma! If you cant take it then don't dish it out. I dont approve of milking for penalties and it's frustrating when the opposition does it to you but every team does it, because it is the Sharks it gets noticed and a huge hoopla is made of it.
 

sharks195

Jaws
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
6,540
Reaction score
46
Location
Ellas
My suspicion ... which is probably wrong ... is that Ricky is quietly asking some of the senior players to take notice of how the ref is handling high-ish tackles. If he's awarding penalties for border-line high tackles, and we need some points or field position, then lay down.

I think he's doing it, not simply to get points and win games, but I suspect he might be pressuring David Gallop/NRL to have the rules adjusted, by pointing out the problems with the rules.

Just a thought.

i agree shireboy, he did it in the warriors game
 

Lettuce_Sharks

Grey Nurse
Joined
Jun 17, 2006
Messages
637
Reaction score
4
Dykes didnt take a dive...did u see his ear fter the game?

If the referees do their job properly then none of this is an issue. It is the referees job to penalise a high shot, regardless of whether the tackled player stays down or gets straight to his feet.

exactly right mate
 
Last edited by a moderator:

sharkarm

Hammerhead
Joined
Jun 12, 2007
Messages
464
Reaction score
4
Location
Gold Coast
To win a premiership not only do you need to be tough and fit but smart as well Ricky and his coaching staff dymock etc... were all thinkers as players it won them comps ! now they have brought it to the shire keep up the good work boys.
 

sharks195

Jaws
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
6,540
Reaction score
46
Location
Ellas
it is absolutely fair, they did it and we did it back, i bet ricky told him to do it at half time
 

Nulla Boy

Bull Shark
Joined
Mar 21, 2006
Messages
2,417
Reaction score
50
gallen did wat he had to do to get the penalty.the refs shouldnt have put him in a posistion to do it in the first place,wat were they looking at when williams tackled him.it was an obvious high tackle and the refs were gonna let it go.
 
Joined
Mar 4, 2007
Messages
5,963
Reaction score
64
Location
Brisbane
Have a think guys Brownie is a wanker hasn't changed never will I can remember when he laid down when he was smashed by Lang years ago, so really he should be keeping his mouth shut how much of a fool must he felt after seeing Dyke's ear and the blood all over his Jersey, hows it go Cant Play Cant Coach Cant Win :D , I am sure he will end up being a commentator in the next few years.

I would have done the same in gallens shoes and I can bet any player would have including Tallis.

We really need to send a petition in on Tallis out of all the commentators he is a complete joke, the other guys on the panel had no idea what he was taking about at times it was piss funny.
 

scott17

Great Scott
Joined
Apr 16, 2007
Messages
3,770
Reaction score
45
Location
Camden
yer you cant say dykes dived when everybody saw his left ear during the interview at the end off the match
 

fancyman

Bull Shark
Joined
Jun 26, 2006
Messages
2,349
Reaction score
20
Location
tha shire
i can remember 2 season ago, in the semis we played at wollongong and stg bet us off 2 forward passes. we we winge, no, when is stg going to realise that they are bottom feeders.
 
Top