Everyone Played Well so Who do we Drop?

[stormshark]

Aside from Gards in For Gordon, Who do we Drop? Think Both Gal and Lewis will play so Who's the unlucky 2?

 

[Milkshark]

I'm afraid it has to be Bukuya. He's signed to go elsewhere and although he has played well the past maybe 2 weeks he is is foo inconsistent. I'd be trying to get Peach into the run on side.

 

[Gumby]

1. Gardner
2. Feki
3. Wright
4. Pom
5. Ryan
6. Carney
7. Robson
8. Fafita
9. De Gois
10. Ross
11. Lewis
12. Graham
13. Gallen

14. Toops
15. Heighno
16. Peachey/bukuya
17. Morris/peachey

 

[JimBob]

I think it should be Taga and Bukuya.

Other than his big hit Taga was fairly quiet and Bukuya is going to the Warriors.

 

[dimi]

What about Gibbs ?

 

[Great_White_Shark]

Tags had a good game, he did more than that one hit

 

[Milkshark]

Gibbs in, Ross out. Gal to front row with Fifita. Gibbs off the bench. Peach and Graham backrow, Lewis to lock. You really could have any of those 3 playing lock but I'd have either Lewis or Peach in there.

 

[Gumby]

Can't drop Ross. From what I've read he had his best game today in years!

 

[Jigsaw]

Taga and Peach will be dropped (as **** as it is) Flanno will stick with JB

 

[Tank]

Peach stays.

 

[JimBob]

Taga and Peach will be dropped (as **** as it is) Flanno will stick with JB

In his defense Boogs was great today.

 

[Shark]

Gibbs in, Ross out. Gal to front row with Fifita. Gibbs off the bench. Peach and Graham backrow, Lewis to lock. You really could have any of those 3 playing lock but I'd have either Lewis or Peach in there.

Gee that's harsh on Rossy!

Gibbs should come off the bench anyway, he has no match fitness. Gal probably shouldn't come back until after Origin - He'd want the run for match fitness going into Origin, I don't think it's the best move from the team's point of view though.

In any case, having a full squad free of injury is a luxury most coaches rarely get to enjoy. Fitness, form & injury will dictate MOST spots in the 17.

I want Peach to stay.

 

[stormshark]

Maybe Gibbsy needs game time in the Reserves?

 

[Gumby]

Yeah I'd give Gibbs a week in reserves. I think we need gal against the rabbits. His experience, aggression will be needed against a massive forward pack. Plus he's still the captain of our beloved club. And we need our captain IMO for next weeks game.

I want peach to stay also. I'd rather have him in the team ahead of Morris with

Toops
Heighno
Peach
Taga/bukuya as our bench

 

[D.D]

Its gotta be Taga and Bukuya for mine.

Bukuya really stepped up today, but he's off at seasons end and Well Peachy showed what he can do in a short period in his debut today and deserves to have the coaches faith and confidence, we need to stick with him because he will be a special player if he does all the right things.

Ross was immense, so cant drop him. Has to be Taga unfortunately.

 

[deano the p]

Bukuya drops for the peach taga drops for Lewis Ross drops for gibbs

 

[85Sharkie]

Anyone think Ryan might go to fb? Not saying he should or shouldnt but he has played well when he has covered there.

 

[deano the p]

Would much rather gards come in

 

[hitman124]

Let's rest Gal until finals................

 

[Gil]

I can see Gards coming back, played well in the NSW cup

Not expecting Gal back, Lewis if fit................tuff one, maybe Taga drops off.