Cronulla vs St George Illawarra, NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006

[SF]

This is the ratings thread for the match:

Cronulla 30 - St George Illawarra 12
NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006
Toyota Park, 3:00 pm, Sunday May 7, 2006

To add your ratings and/or comments, please
fill out the form on the match review page.

• Filling in the above form allows the average ratings to be automatically calculated, and your comments added to this thread (you can't post in this thread directly).
• Please login before voting if you want to have your votes recorded under your username.
• Ratings are open for a period of two weeks after the match.
• Only one vote per IP address/username is allowed.
• Ratings and comments are optional for all players. You can rate as many or as few as you would like. However, you can't go back and add/edit ratings after you vote.
• The ratings results for this match are also available on the match review page once you have voted (or skipped voting).
• The ratings leaderboard for this season is available here.
• The all-time ratings results for this grade/competition are available here.

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 10
2. Darren Albert - 10
3. Nigel Vagana - 10
4. Phil Bailey - 10
5. Luke Covell - 10
6. Brett Kearney - 10
7. Adam Dykes - 10
8. James Stosic - 10
9. Kevin Kingston - 10
10. Luke Douglas - 10
11. Reece Williams - 10
12. Lance Thompson - 10
13. Paul Gallen - 10
14. Hutch Maiava - 10
15. Beau Scott - 10
16. Greg Bird - 10
17. Tevita Latu - 10

 

[Insane]

Insane's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 8
2. Darren Albert - 7
3. Nigel Vagana - 7
4. Phil Bailey - 7
5. Luke Covell - 8
6. Brett Kearney - 8
7. Adam Dykes - 9
8. James Stosic - 7
9. Kevin Kingston - 8
10. Luke Douglas - 8
11. Reece Williams - 7
12. Lance Thompson - 10
13. Paul Gallen - 7
14. Hutch Maiava - 6
15. Beau Scott - 6
16. Greg Bird - 6
17. Tevita Latu - 8

ST GEORGE ILLAWARRA:
6. Trent Barrett - 2

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 7
2. Darren Albert - 6
3. Nigel Vagana - 5
4. Phil Bailey - 7
5. Luke Covell - 6
6. Brett Kearney - 6
7. Adam Dykes - 8
8. James Stosic - 5
9. Kevin Kingston - 7
10. Luke Douglas - 7
11. Reece Williams - 7
12. Lance Thompson - 10
13. Paul Gallen - 8
14. Hutch Maiava - 5
15. Beau Scott - 5
16. Greg Bird - 8
17. Tevita Latu - 6

 

[Matts3939]

Matts3939's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 8
Good clean game
2. Darren Albert - 9
Great offensivly, awsome defencivly.
3. Nigel Vagana - 7
4. Phil Bailey - 7
5. Luke Covell - 8
Still playing great
6. Brett Kearney - 6
7. Adam Dykes - 8
Mixed bag but still played pretty well.
8. James Stosic - 6
9. Kevin Kingston - 7
10. Luke Douglas - 7
11. Reece Williams - 6
12. Lance Thompson - 10
What a work horse, buy of the season, good to see him rub salt into the wound when he kicked that goal
13. Paul Gallen - 9
Keeps getting better every game
14. Hutch Maiava - 8
Solid
15. Beau Scott - 7
16. Greg Bird - 5
17. Tevita Latu - 7

ST GEORGE ILLAWARRA:
6. Trent Barrett - 0
Someone remind him he is in the nrl, not the nfl. Iv never seen someone pulled up for so many forward passes.

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
12. Lance Thompson - 10
16. Greg Bird - 10

 

[bigjamal]

bigjamal's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 5
2. Darren Albert - 6
3. Nigel Vagana - 7
4. Phil Bailey - 6
5. Luke Covell - 4
6. Brett Kearney - 4
7. Adam Dykes - 9
8. James Stosic - 6
9. Kevin Kingston - 7
10. Luke Douglas - 8
11. Reece Williams - 7
12. Lance Thompson - 10
13. Paul Gallen - 8
14. Hutch Maiava - 4
15. Beau Scott - 3
16. Greg Bird - 5
17. Tevita Latu - 8

ST GEORGE ILLAWARRA:
2. Colin Best - 0
6. Trent Barrett - 0
16. Charlie Leaeno - 9

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 7
2. Darren Albert - 7
3. Nigel Vagana - 7
4. Phil Bailey - 7
5. Luke Covell - 7
6. Brett Kearney - 8
7. Adam Dykes - 9
8. James Stosic - 7
9. Kevin Kingston - 7
10. Luke Douglas - 6
11. Reece Williams - 7
12. Lance Thompson - 9
13. Paul Gallen - 7
14. Hutch Maiava - 6
15. Beau Scott - 6
16. Greg Bird - 6
17. Tevita Latu - 7

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 8
2. Darren Albert - 7
3. Nigel Vagana - 8
4. Phil Bailey - 7
5. Luke Covell - 9
6. Brett Kearney - 8
7. Adam Dykes - 8
8. James Stosic - 7
9. Kevin Kingston - 5
10. Luke Douglas - 5
11. Reece Williams - 7
12. Lance Thompson - 8
13. Paul Gallen - 8
14. Hutch Maiava - 9
15. Beau Scott - 8
16. Greg Bird - 8
17. Tevita Latu - 8

ST GEORGE ILLAWARRA:
1. Clint Greenshields - 1
2. Colin Best - 1
3. Mark Gasnier - 1
4. Matt Cooper - 1
18. Brett Morris - 1
6. Trent Barrett - 1
7. Ben Hornby - 1
8. Justin Poore - 1
9. Aaron Gorrell - 1
10. Ashton Sims - 1
11. Ben Creagh - 1
12. Dean Young - 1
13. Shaun Timmins - 2
14. Michael Henderson - 1
15. Matt Bickerstaff - 3
16. Charlie Leaeno - 0
17. George Ndaira - 0

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 10
Damn good game for the young fullback. Keeps getting better and better. The back three of Simmons, Albert and Covell is becoming such a solid unit.
2. Darren Albert - 8
3. Nigel Vagana - 7
4. Phil Bailey - 7
5. Luke Covell - 8
6. Brett Kearney - 7
7. Adam Dykes - 10
For the sharks sake I hope he doesn't get picked for origin but I reckon he's playing good enough to pull on the 6 or the 7. In the best form of his life.
8. James Stosic - 7
9. Kevin Kingston - 8
10. Luke Douglas - 8
11. Reece Williams - 8
12. Lance Thompson - 10
Another big game. Worked feverishly. So glad for him to have a big one against his old club given the circumstances. They must have been wishing he was in the red and white cause he has been the best forward in the competition. Deserves an origin jersey.
13. Paul Gallen - 9
14. Hutch Maiava - 7
15. Beau Scott - 7
16. Greg Bird - 7
17. Tevita Latu - 7

 

[timber]

timber's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 9
2. Darren Albert - 7
3. Nigel Vagana - 7
4. Phil Bailey - 7
5. Luke Covell - 8
6. Brett Kearney - 7
7. Adam Dykes - 8
8. James Stosic - 8
9. Kevin Kingston - 7
10. Luke Douglas - 8
11. Reece Williams - 7
12. Lance Thompson - 10
13. Paul Gallen - 9
14. Hutch Maiava - 7
15. Beau Scott - 7
16. Greg Bird - 7
17. Tevita Latu - 7

 

[Sir Chadley]

Chad's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 7
He's really starting to settle into the fullback role now. Looked very safe and scored a great try
2. Darren Albert - 7
Scored another try and pulled off some great tackles. Spilt the ball for one try but the pass was quite low
3. Nigel Vagana - 7
Another quiet one for Nigel, but solid in defence against Gasnier first (except for the disallowed try - which I thought was a try) and then Creagh. Also scored his usual try for the game
4. Phil Bailey - 7
Much better game from Bailey, although caught out a few times by Cooper but scrambled well. Great offload for Albert's try
5. Luke Covell - 7
Another good game from Covell, kicked well with the wind and ran strongly
6. Brett Kearney - 7
Another solid game from Kearney - he is providing a good second option for Dykes at the moment
7. Adam Dykes - 9
Brilliant game, laid the foundation for the attack and directed the team around the park.
8. James Stosic - 7
Solid game again from Stosic - carries the ball up and always attracts several defenders
9. Kevin Kingston - 7
Sharp from dummy half early - gave Dykes and Kearney good service.
10. Luke Douglas - 8
Another strong game from this kid - he is impressing with every game.
11. Reece Williams - 7
Another solid game from Reece
12. Lance Thompson - 9
Got great revenge on his former club by having another outstanding game, scoring a try and kicking the last goal.
13. Paul Gallen - 7
Powerful game but still has problems with hands - bombed a certain try in the first half, should have scored but dropped a simple ball with the line wide open.
14. Hutch Maiava - 6
Good, strong running from Hutch - still not at his best but getting there.
15. Beau Scott - 6
Didn't get much game time today - still went well, better with his hands this time.
16. Greg Bird - 5
He still worries me with his ball control as well, looks to offload when it is not on and can be sometimes over agressive. If he can temper this aggression he can be a very good player
17. Tevita Latu - 7
Provided another spark again from dummy half and made some good runs

 

[san29]

san29's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 7
good game but some times stops dead and does't seem to know what to do
2. Darren Albert - 7
slow at first but then played well
3. Nigel Vagana - 7
not bad but still needs to go looking for the ball
4. Phil Bailey - 7
also played well
5. Luke Covell - 8
getting better each game
6. Brett Kearney - 7
trys realy hard and can only get better
7. Adam Dykes - 9
trys so hard maybe to hard sometimes is the back bone of the sharks well done adam
8. James Stosic - 9
will only get better trys hard
9. Kevin Kingston - 8
well done
10. Luke Douglas - 7
well done
11. Reece Williams - 8
always trys
12. Lance Thompson - 10
well done lance very proud of you
13. Paul Gallen - 10
well done
14. Hutch Maiava - 9
well done
15. Beau Scott - 8
trys very hard
16. Greg Bird - 7
trys to hard
17. Tevita Latu - 10
well done

 

[Hammerhead]

Hammerhead's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 7
2. Darren Albert - 7
3. Nigel Vagana - 6
4. Phil Bailey - 6
5. Luke Covell - 6
6. Brett Kearney - 5
7. Adam Dykes - 8
8. James Stosic - 7
9. Kevin Kingston - 7
10. Luke Douglas - 7
11. Reece Williams - 7
12. Lance Thompson - 8
13. Paul Gallen - 9
14. Hutch Maiava - 7
15. Beau Scott - 6
16. Greg Bird - 6
17. Tevita Latu - 7

ST GEORGE ILLAWARRA:
2. Colin Best - 1
3. Mark Gasnier - 2
4. Matt Cooper - 2
18. Brett Morris - 2
6. Trent Barrett - 2
15. Matt Bickerstaff - 2
16. Charlie Leaeno - 4
17. George Ndaira - 2

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 7
2. Darren Albert - 8
3. Nigel Vagana - 9
4. Phil Bailey - 5
5. Luke Covell - 8
6. Brett Kearney - 7
7. Adam Dykes - 9
8. James Stosic - 8
9. Kevin Kingston - 9
10. Luke Douglas - 10
11. Reece Williams - 9
12. Lance Thompson - 10
13. Paul Gallen - 7
14. Hutch Maiava - 8
15. Beau Scott - 4
16. Greg Bird - 3
17. Tevita Latu - 9

ST GEORGE ILLAWARRA:
16. Charlie Leaeno - 7
the others had nothing...

 

[SAG]

SAG's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 8
2. Darren Albert - 7
3. Nigel Vagana - 7
4. Phil Bailey - 6
5. Luke Covell - 7
6. Brett Kearney - 5
7. Adam Dykes - 8
8. James Stosic - 6
9. Kevin Kingston - 6
10. Luke Douglas - 7
11. Reece Williams - 6
12. Lance Thompson - 9
13. Paul Gallen - 8
14. Hutch Maiava - 7
15. Beau Scott - 5
16. Greg Bird - 7
17. Tevita Latu - 8

ST GEORGE ILLAWARRA:
1. Clint Greenshields - 0
2. Colin Best - 0
3. Mark Gasnier - 0
4. Matt Cooper - 0
18. Brett Morris - 0
6. Trent Barrett - 0
-10
7. Ben Hornby - 0
8. Justin Poore - 0
9. Aaron Gorrell - 0
10. Ashton Sims - 0
11. Ben Creagh - 0
12. Dean Young - 0
13. Shaun Timmins - 0
14. Michael Henderson - 0
15. Matt Bickerstaff - 0
16. Charlie Leaeno - 1
17. George Ndaira - 0

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 7
2. Darren Albert - 10
3. Nigel Vagana - 10
5. Luke Covell - 10
6. Brett Kearney - 8
7. Adam Dykes - 10
ur heaps better then brett kimroly !!!!!!!!!! don't leyt brett kimorly take ur place
8. James Stosic - 7
9. Kevin Kingston - 0
10. Luke Douglas - 10
15. Beau Scott - 10
16. Greg Bird - 10
17. Tevita Latu - 10

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 7
Had his best game of the years so far, with some very goood moments in attack and defence. Slowly learning the role of the fullback
2. Darren Albert - 7
Another good game, great cover defence again
3. Nigel Vagana - 5
A quiet game from Nigel, again. Needs to get more involved around the ruck. Solid in defence.
4. Phil Bailey - 7
Getting better but really he needed to. Strong in defence
5. Luke Covell - 6
Thought he had a good game. Is it just me or does he seem to be gettin a bit faster. Good try
6. Brett Kearney - 6
Consistently solid. That's all he needs to be too
7. Adam Dykes - 7
Some good work early on, but a few silly decisions in attack at times
8. James Stosic - 6
Thought it was his best game in 1st grade. Was really running hard at the line
9. Kevin Kingston - 6
Nothing special, was looking for him to make some smart darts from dummy half as he usually does in the early minutes, but they were missing
10. Luke Douglas - 7
Another impressive performance. Is playing well above his age
11. Reece Williams - 6
A better performance from recent times. Looked a little stronger in attack but he can still improve in this area
12. Lance Thompson - 8
Great game. Plays with passion and gave it to his old team mates in attack and defence. Great try, great goal
13. Paul Gallen - 7
Another strong game and deserves his City spot. Dropped a sitter with the line wide open. 1st you have to catch the ball Paul
14. Hutch Maiava - 6
Nothing special but ok.
15. Beau Scott - 5
Didn't really get many opportunities. Is a better player than his score. Needs more game time
16. Greg Bird - 6
Solid but not outstanding
17. Tevita Latu - 6
Quieter than usual but think he was a marked man this week

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 8
2. Darren Albert - 7
3. Nigel Vagana - 6
4. Phil Bailey - 5
5. Luke Covell - 6
6. Brett Kearney - 4
7. Adam Dykes - 8
8. James Stosic - 5
9. Kevin Kingston - 6
10. Luke Douglas - 6
11. Reece Williams - 7
12. Lance Thompson - 9
13. Paul Gallen - 9
14. Hutch Maiava - 6
15. Beau Scott - 4
16. Greg Bird - 4
17. Tevita Latu - 5

ST GEORGE ILLAWARRA:
1. Clint Greenshields - 5
2. Colin Best - 4
3. Mark Gasnier - 4
4. Matt Cooper - 6
18. Brett Morris - 3
6. Trent Barrett - 2
7. Ben Hornby - 5
8. Justin Poore - 4
9. Aaron Gorrell - 3
10. Ashton Sims - 4
11. Ben Creagh - 5
12. Dean Young - 5
13. Shaun Timmins - 5
14. Michael Henderson - 4
15. Matt Bickerstaff - 6
16. Charlie Leaeno - 6
17. George Ndaira - 3

 

[Macca]

McSharkie's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 9, 2006)

CRONULLA:
1. David Simmons - 7
2. Darren Albert - 7
3. Nigel Vagana - 7
4. Phil Bailey - 7
5. Luke Covell - 8
6. Brett Kearney - 7
7. Adam Dykes - 9
8. James Stosic - 7
9. Kevin Kingston - 8
10. Luke Douglas - 8
11. Reece Williams - 7
12. Lance Thompson - 9
13. Paul Gallen - 8
14. Hutch Maiava - 7
15. Beau Scott - 6
16. Greg Bird - 6
17. Tevita Latu - 7

ST GEORGE ILLAWARRA:
1. Clint Greenshields - 0
2. Colin Best - 5
3. Mark Gasnier - 0
18. Brett Morris - 0
6. Trent Barrett - 0
7. Ben Hornby - 0
8. Justin Poore - 0
9. Aaron Gorrell - 0
10. Ashton Sims - 0
11. Ben Creagh - 0
12. Dean Young - 0
13. Shaun Timmins - 0
14. Michael Henderson - 0
15. Matt Bickerstaff - 5
16. Charlie Leaeno - 0
17. George Ndaira - 0