(Archived) THE RUMOUR MILL - Player Movement

[BlackWhiteBlue]

If Bennett goes from brissy we need to offer TPJ a gold plated deal. Best forward on the market aside maybe Tapau.

IMO would be a better by than Tapau

 

[Capital_Shark]

Moses is a joke. Has a skill set for sure but he throws as many tantrums as he does try assists.

 

[Proud Shark]

If you gave each player a 1-10 rating on each game I reckon they come out even. The difference being Chad would consistently fall in the 4-8 range where as Moses can deliver a 0-10. Also Moses being desperate to leave the tigs only to bw moved on a year later is a massive red flag for mine. No thanks.

 

[Riverside MF]

At least Chad has a crack at making a tackle.

 

[HaroldBishop]

So if we could get him for 400k people would say no?

 

[Proud Shark]

So if we could get him for 400k people would say no?

If he was happy to potentiality run 3rd string and force his way in sure. But his ego and history suggest that would be unlikely.

 

[HaroldBishop]

If he was happy to potentiality run 3rd string and force his way in sure. But his ego and history suggest that would be unlikely.

He's better than third string.

I'd 100% take him if we're losing Val. No brainer.

 

[BurgoShark]

He's better than third string.

I'd 100% take him if we're losing Val. No brainer.

I think the point there HB was that he would need to earn his way in and show that his attitude is fixed. I don't think anyone is doubting his talent but one bad egg ....

 

[Capital_Shark]

So if we could get him for 400k people would say no?

I don't see it as a dollars thing. Getting a bargain is great (any FG half @ $400k is really) but I don't just buy **** because its cheap. I dunno, maybe we could put the harder edge in him I feel he lacks. If Flanno picked him up cheap for a couple years I wouldn't whinge about it but thats all to do with my trust in Flanno, his staff and our culture not so much Moses.

Skill wise he's above Chad, but skill ain't everything in FG, consistency in performances means a lot. As Proud Sharks pointed out while Moses' best is better his worst is worse and he doesn't find middle ground often (granted neither have many of his teammates throughout his career). Much rather know I'm gonna get a minimum 5 most weeks from my halfback and if he pulls out an 8.5 he's had a blinder, than swing from 2's to 9's ...then cracking the ****s at everyone else.

 

[HaroldBishop]

I think we're all getting a bit carried away with Chad's last month or so of footy. Chad's worst stinks it up, let's not forget that.

Cap, I agree that I think our club has that hard edge that brings out the best in players, anything less isn't tolerated. Look at Maloney, awesome in 2016, stunk it up last year. Flanno didn't tolerate it, see ya Jimbo.

 

[BurgoShark]

So if we could get him for 400k people would say no?

$400k in means $400k must go out. Are you dumping one high paid bloke or eight low paid ones to bring him in?

 

[HaroldBishop]

$400k in means $400k must go out. Are you dumping one high paid bloke or eight low paid ones to bring him in?

We're losing plenty of players from this season's list.

Plus I said only if Val is leaving. Plenty of cap space.

 

[Super Impose]

I think we're all getting a bit carried away with Chad's last month or so of footy. Chad's worst stinks it up, let's not forget that.

Cap, I agree that I think our club has that hard edge that brings out the best in players, anything less isn't tolerated. Look at Maloney, awesome in 2016, stunk it up last year. Flanno didn't tolerate it, see ya Jimbo.

Chad can stink it up, no doubt .

Moses turns it up every second week , toys flying out of the cot stuff.

And has done it at consecutive clubs.

Pass.

 

[HaroldBishop]

Chad can stink it up, no doubt .

Moses turns it up every second week , toys flying out of the cot stuff.

And has done it at consecutive clubs.

Pass.

We get more out of players than Wests or Parra.

 

[Capital_Shark]

I think we're all getting a bit carried away with Chad's last month or so of footy. Chad's worst stinks it up, let's not forget that.

Cap, I agree that I think our club has that hard edge that brings out the best in players, anything less isn't tolerated. Look at Maloney, awesome in 2016, stunk it up last year. Flanno didn't tolerate it, see ya Jimbo.

Nah I know Chad can stink it up but he doesn't hit the lows Moses can and never blames those around him for his ****. He's probably got a better structure too to fall back on so doesn't go rogue overplaying his hand and coming up with more errors. It's all attitude and Chad has that over Moses. Fix Moses' attitude and he leaves Chad behind.

 

[Capital_Shark]

We get more out of players than Wests or Parra.

Undeniable.

 

[19ninety9]

Nah I know Chad can stink it up but he doesn't hit the lows Moses can and never blames those around him for his ****. He's probably got a better structure too to fall back on so doesn't go rogue overplaying his hand and coming up with more errors. It's all attitude and Chad has that over Moses. Fix Moses' attitude and he leaves Chad behind.

Is there lower than chads game against the broncos? Moses would not have to take the field to be worse.

 

[Sharkyle]

If Bennett leaves broncos I’m sure there is a clause in birds contract that he can fly the coup.

Bring back Big Mac bird!

 

[19ninety9]

If Bennett leaves broncos I’m sure there is a clause in birds contract that he can fly the coup.

Bring back Big Mac bird!

I know there’s a chance this may happen, **** I hope not though.

 

[BlackWhiteBlue]

Honestly, would not be opposed to Bird coming back.