3-2-1 Thread: Cronulla vs Penrith, NRL Premiership, Round 5, 2012

Status
Not open for further replies.

Great White Shark

Hammerhead
Joined
Jun 24, 2007
Messages
302
Reaction score
4
Great White Shark's ratings for Cronulla vs Penrith (NRL Premiership, Round 5, 2012)

3 Points - Paul Gallen: no need to say anything!! (9/10)
2 Points - Jayson Bukuya: Strongest runner in the game (outside Gal). (9/10)
1 Point - Jeremy Smith: Solid defence. Another good game. (8/10)

- Nathan Gardner: made one error. but played well. Needs to get more involved in attack running off Gallen, Smith and Bukuya (ET style) (6/10)
- Matthew Wright: was solid. Does not look dangerous in attack. (5/10)
- Ben Pomeroy: our best of the 1-5 (and I cant believe it!!!) (6/10)
- Colin Best: played better than week before but still made two errors. (5/10)
- John Williams: see matt wright. (5/10)
- Todd Carney: slowly getting there. Cant wait when he explodes (7/10)
- Jeff Robson: solid. Two bad missed tackles to let in tries. (7/10)
- Bryce Gibbs: hasnt played in a month. Did well (7/10)
- Isaac De Gois: great player. Pity he missed 30 minutes (8/10)
- Ben Ross: Solid opening to the season. Impressive for an old fella. (7/10)
- Andrew Fifita: Was quite good. Needs to shed 5 kilos. (7/10)
- Wade Graham: Great when he came on. Solid defence but let in one try running out of the line. (7/10)
- John Morris: i know isaac was injured but when he and Robson are on together we dont look good. (4/10)
- Sam Tagataese: ok. (4/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

Great_White_Shark

Great White
Joined
Aug 14, 2011
Messages
2,818
Reaction score
60
Location
Perth
Great_White_Shark's ratings for Cronulla vs Penrith (NRL Premiership, Round 5, 2012)

3 Points - Paul Gallen: i should just copy and paste his every week, he is winning us games just by inspiring the rest of the team! his stats speak for themselves (10/10)
2 Points - Wade Graham: should be our starting 13! Gallen goes better at prop and graham goes better at lock so it makes sense, a try this week as well (9/10)
1 Point - Jeremy Smith: i believe Smitty will be getting a 3-2-1 point from me every week, besides gal i think he is our hardest working player, if he was on for the 80 mins he might even be the hardest! brilliant short pass to bukuya as well (10/10)

- Nathan Gardner: we arent using him to his ability, and i still think he is a little light in defence (8/10)
- Matthew Wright: did the job, but i cant wait till mills is back (8/10)
- Ben Pomeroy: loving his defence! something i havent said in years, that hit he put on that gave us possesion 10 metres out from their line was UNREAL! inspired the rest of the team i think (9/10)
- Colin Best: Solid as always, needs to pick his lines better when gettiing carney ball (8/10)
- John Williams: quiet game from him, he didnt get the ball much except for when he came in for a hitup (8/10)
- Todd Carney: Brilliant as always, i would like to see him leave the massive kicks for robson on the 5th, i dont mind carney getting the ball on the 5th when we are 10 metres out and attacking, but Robson is definately the better kicker for 5th on our 40m line, That field goal was the TITS! and he nearly got our first 40/20 in 3 years
(10/10)
- Jeff Robson: his kicks didnt quiet find open space all the time, needs to work on his positional kicking a lil bit, what happened since his first kick in his first match for us, he kicked it from half way and found the line 2m out from their line, havent seen him do this since that game (9/10)
- Bryce Gibbs: Solid! great defence and great running ability! Great to see him back (9/10)
- Isaac De Gois: Great game from hiim, we missed him in the second half tho (9/10)
- Ben Ross: great stats! he is solid as always, runs the ball straight and hard, one thing i like about our forwards this year is they dont try and offload every tackle, i watched snowden in his game at the knights this week and he stuffed up the offload on many occasions (9/10)
- Jayson Bukuya: Great eyes for him to run that line leading to our first try! loving his game (10/10)
- Andrew Fifita: would like to see him get more minutes, he is pretty agressive in defense and i like it! (9/10)
- John Morris: solid as always, not sure if he is needed, i would prefer an extra forward, if something happens to de-gois you throw graham into Halfback and Robson to hooker for the rest of the game (8/10)
- Sam Tagataese: needs more minutes, he needs to run wide as well, i remember the lines he was running last year for us and he was carving up the centres and halfs out wide, need to play to his strengths (9/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top