3-2-1 Thread: Cronulla vs Manly, NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2012

Status
Not open for further replies.
sharksforever.com

sharksforever.com

Information
Joined
Mar 8, 2011
Messages
3,086
Reaction score
4
This is the 3-2-1 thread for the match:

Cronulla 17 - Manly 14
NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2012
Toyota Stadium, 7:00 pm, Monday March 19, 2012

To add your 3-2-1 and/or comments, please
fill out the form on the match review page.
  • Filling in the above form allows the 3-2-1 to be automatically calculated, and your comments added to this thread.
  • Please login before voting if you want to have your votes recorded under your username.
  • Ratings are open for a period of two weeks after the match.
  • Only one vote per IP address/username is allowed.
  • Please allocate at least your 3-2-1 points. Comments and additional ratings are optional for all players. However, you can't go back and add/edit ratings after you vote.
  • The results for this match are also available on the match review page once you have voted (or skipped voting).
  • The leaderboard for this season is available here.
 
SF

SF

Mako Shark
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
9,962
Reaction score
1,527
Location
Monty Porter Stand
SF's ratings for Cronulla vs Manly (NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2012)

3 Points - Jayson Bukuya: Scored the crucial first try through 4 or 5 defenders. Awesome running all night, and pretty good defence on T-Rex (9/10)
2 Points - Paul Gallen: One or two small errors, but back to his best with line-bending hitups and defence. (9/10)
1 Point - Jeff Robson: Great kicking game and organisation, made the difference from previous weeks. Well done. (8/10)

- Nathan Gardner: Generally excellent under the high ball, despite horrible conditions for a fullback. Support play and kick returns were great too. (8/10)
- Stewart Mills: Best game he's had so far. Two late tries were scored down his wing, but his kick returns were good, often beating a couple of tackles. (8/10)
- Ben Pomeroy: Highlight was earning a repeat set with a great kick chase and tackle. Good offloads all game too. (8/10)
- Colin Best: Excellent defence (8/10)
- John Williams: Outplayed his star brother (8/10)
- Todd Carney: Good ball control and kicking, considering how slippery it was. (8/10)
- Ben Ross (8/10)
- Isaac De Gois: Always looks dangerous. Nice flick pass for our second try. (8/10)
- Jeremy Smith (8/10)
- Wade Graham: Did definitely look better at 13. (8/10)
- Andrew Fifita: Not his best game, was one of only two players to get back to stop the quick 20m tap by a flying Brett Stewart. That's attitude! (8/10)
- John Morris: Really strong game from the bench. (8/10)
- Anthony Tupou: Great defence and drew in a lot of defenders in attack. (8/10)
- Sam Tagataese (8/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 
Tiger Shark

Tiger Shark

Jaws
Joined
Apr 27, 2010
Messages
8,922
Reaction score
832
Location
Sydney
Tiger Shark's ratings for Cronulla vs Manly (NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2012)

3 Points - Paul Gallen (9/10)
2 Points - Jayson Bukuya (8/10)
1 Point - Todd Carney (8/10)

- Nathan Gardner (7/10)
- Stewart Mills (7/10)
- Ben Pomeroy (7/10)
- Colin Best (8/10)
- John Williams (6/10)
- Jeff Robson (7/10)
- Ben Ross (7/10)
- Isaac De Gois (8/10)
- Jeremy Smith (8/10)
- Wade Graham (8/10)
- Andrew Fifita (5/10)
- John Morris (6/10)
- Anthony Tupou (7/10)
- Sam Tagataese (7/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 
G

Great White Shark

Hammerhead
Joined
Jun 24, 2007
Messages
302
Reaction score
4
Great White Shark's ratings for Cronulla vs Manly (NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2012)

3 Points - Paul Gallen: 36 tackles, 30 hitups. 260 metres. Enough said.....(just hold onto that ball, some of the hair went gray at the 79th minute:))
2 Points - Jayson Bukuya: Strong runner. Has really come along over the past few years. That first try was sensational!!
1 Point - Jeff Robson: Gave him a point. Not a flashy player but we looked organised and it gave carney plenty of time and space. Our shape in attack looks a lot more balanced

- Nathan Gardner: Showed a lot of maturity. Could have scored a double. I think he is a real star in the making. Needs to work on defence
- Stewart Mills: Good in attack. Had some good runs. Awful defence and positional play. All THREE tries he cuold have stopped. Needs to read play better, position himself better, trust his centre. Needs a LOT of work. But a young guy....
- Ben Pomeroy: Best game in years. Didnt drop the ball. 5 OFFLOADS!!!
- Colin Best: Solid. Had some good runs when the forwards needed him to take a load. Is showing real leadership on the field
- John Williams: Played well. Good running. No idea why he is not kicking for goal?!?!
- Todd Carney: Good game. Needs to improve his kicking game close to the line. When he gets outside his man he is unstoppable
- Ben Ross: Great game Benny. took the ball up strongly. Without Gibbs showed a lot of leadership
- Isaac De Gois: Solid. a Bit quiter than normal. Can not figure out why Flanagan keeps on taking him off?!?
- Jeremy Smith: Solid in defence. Some great hits. Would like to see him a little more involved in attack
- Wade Graham: Best game for years. He is more suited as a ball playing backrower then in the halves. Real talent in the making
- Andrew Fifita: Solid off the bench. Needs to touch up parts of his game. But young enough to do it.
- John Morris: ok off the bench. Made a good break but I would prefer to see isaac o for 80 minutes.
- Anthony Tupou: did well in defence. But to be honest, he is well past his best days. No real impact in attack (and stats show we ein 90% of our games when he runs 75 metres+) .....but he doesnt do it anymore.
- Sam Tagataese: Good off the bench. I think (despite last week's effort), he will challenge Toups and Morris on the bench




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 
Great_White_Shark

Great_White_Shark

Great White
Joined
Aug 14, 2011
Messages
2,818
Reaction score
60
Location
Perth
Great_White_Shark's ratings for Cronulla vs Manly (NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2012)

3 Points - Paul Gallen: 80 minute forward! (10/10)
2 Points - Jeff Robson: Best kicking game, good to see some grubbers (9/10)
1 Point - Todd Carney: Good to see him take the line on! and good to see him mix up his 5th tackle options (8/10)





Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 
ACT SHARK

ACT SHARK

Bronze Whaler
Joined
Mar 16, 2012
Messages
135
Reaction score
3
Location
ACT
ACT SHARK's ratings for Cronulla vs Manly (NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2012)

3 Points - Paul Gallen: Dead set freak. Nothin more to add. (10/10)
2 Points - Jayson Bukuya: Boogie played amazing. Definitely cemented his spot with his ball running. Another freak who will only continue to get better. (10/10)
1 Point - Jeremy Smith: Was outstanding all night. D was amazing. Tackle on T-Rex was crazy. Great commitment and leadership. (10/10)

- Nathan Gardner: Played a lot better than last week. Would like to see him play like that consistently (8/10)
- Stewart Mills: Made some mistakes in d, although was fairly solid running the ball back. Needs to stay in the side. (7/10)
- Ben Pomeroy: Played really well. Extremely impressed with his form at the moment (8/10)
- Colin Best: Definitely standing up at the moment. Had Jamie Lyon covered all night. (8/10)
- John Williams: Played decently. (7/10)
- Todd Carney: Toddy was good for most of the night. Thought he looked a lot more comfortable out wider. (8/10)
- Jeff Robson: Good addition to the side. Seemed to have the team more organised/structured (7/10)
- Ben Ross: Performed alright. (7/10)
- Isaac De Gois: Isaac looked dangerous again. (7/10)
- Wade Graham: Looked the goods as a ball playing back rower. Seemed to be far more comfortable just focusing on his running game. Would love for him to stay there. (7/10)
- Andrew Fifita: Seemed to play ok. To be honest, didn't pay much attention to him. (6/10)
- John Morris: Played well off the bench. Thought he had a bit of impact. Happy for him to keep coming on as a bit of impact (6/10)
- Anthony Tupou: Had limited impact from the bench. Think he was fairly solid in d. (7/10)
- Sam Tagataese: Again fairly solid although didn't pay much attention again (7/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 
S

Shark68

Bull Shark
Joined
Mar 27, 2008
Messages
2,052
Reaction score
18
Shark68's ratings for Cronulla vs Manly (NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2012)

3 Points - Jayson Bukuya (9/10)
2 Points - Paul Gallen (8/10)
1 Point - Todd Carney (8/10)

- Nathan Gardner (8/10)
- Stewart Mills (6/10)
- Ben Pomeroy (7/10)
- Colin Best (8/10)
- John Williams (7/10)
- Jeff Robson (8/10)
- Ben Ross (7/10)
- Isaac De Gois (7/10)
- Jeremy Smith (8/10)
- Wade Graham (8/10)
- Andrew Fifita (7/10)
- John Morris (7/10)
- Anthony Tupou (7/10)
- Sam Tagataese (6/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top