3-2-1 Thread: Cronulla vs Manly, NRL Premiership, Round 19, 2010

Status
Not open for further replies.

SF

Mako Shark
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
9,857
Reaction score
1,348
Location
Monty Porter Stand
This is the 3-2-1 thread for the match:

Manly 48 - Cronulla 18
NRL Premiership, Round 19, 2010
Toyota Park, 7:30 pm, Saturday July 17, 2010


To add your 3-2-1 and/or comments, please
fill out the form on the match review page.

  • Filling in the above form allows the 3-2-1 to be automatically calculated, and your comments added to this thread.
  • Please login before voting if you want to have your votes recorded under your username.
  • Ratings are open for a period of two weeks after the match.
  • Only one vote per IP address/username is allowed.
  • Please allocate at least your 3-2-1 points. Comments and additional ratings are optional for all players. However, you can't go back and add/edit ratings after you vote.
  • The results for this match are also available on the match review page once you have voted (or skipped voting).
  • The leaderboard for this season is available here.
 

SF

Mako Shark
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
9,857
Reaction score
1,348
Location
Monty Porter Stand
Sharks Forever's ratings for Cronulla vs Manly (NRL Premiership, Round 19, 2010)

3 Points - Nathan Gardner: Made some critical errors early, but bounced back to be just about the only bright part of the match. Put his body on the line in defence, and scored another very nice try from 30m out, running straight through the middle of the Manly forward pack, and accelerating past the Manly fullback. Great effort, can hold his head high. (8/10)
2 Points - Paul Gallen: Like everyone he made a couple of bad errors and missed tackles. Also he handled the ball too much in the first half. But without him in the second half, it would have been a record flogging. (7/10)
1 Point - Josh Cordoba: Scored a solid try to bring back some respectability, and did a lot of tackling in a short time on. (7/10)

- Isaac Gordon: Returned early from injury, and it showed. (5/10)
- Dean Collis: Totally under-used. We were camped on their line for the first 5 minutes, and our attacking side (Collis + Gordon) did not get the ball once. (5/10)
- Ben Pomeroy: They scored a lot of tries down his side in the first half, but the overlap was always there. (5/10)
- Luke Covell: Again, a lot of tries down his wing in the first half, but he made a brilliant cover tackle on Anthony Watmough to stop a 4th try. (7/10)
- Tim Smith: Was criticised heavily at the game, but did not deserve it. Put in 100%. Yes he made some errors, and just has to stop kicking when it's not on, but he threw some very nice passes too. (6/10)
- John Morris: Also was 50-50 before the game, and it showed. Not a happy night. (5/10)
- Kade Snowden: Another 50-50 before the game... another one who wasn't right. (5/10)
- Paul Aiton: Did all he could behind a well-beaten forward pack. Missed a few tackles, but made a lot. (7/10)
- Luke Douglas (6/10)
- Grant Millington (5/10)
- Anthony Tupou (5/10)
- Lancen Juodo (5/10)
- Taulima Tautai (5/10)
- Siosaia Vave: Had a good second spell. Always looks a chance at scoring near the line, which is a nice change. (7/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

Great White Shark

Hammerhead
Joined
Jun 24, 2007
Messages
302
Reaction score
4
Great White Shark's ratings for Cronulla vs Manly (NRL Premiership, Round 19, 2010)

3 Points - Nathan Gardner: Often exposed at the back but not really his fault (5/10)
2 Points - Paul Gallen: His second half was great. First half he showed poor leadership. Still 149 metres and 38 tackles! (4/10)
1 Point - Paul Aiton: Most deadly attacking weapon we have. Did his best in a forward pack that gave him no go forward
(4/10)

- Isaac Gordon: 4 errors. irrespective of injury, way too much (2/10)
- Dean Collis: not sure what to make of this guy. needs a quality centre/winger around him (2/10)
- Ben Pomeroy: fills the numbers. often out of position (especially defence). Bad hands. Need to call his day. (1/10)
- Luke Covell: tried hard. Way too slow for today's style of game. (1/10)
- Tim Smith: All the potential in the world will not overcome a lack of brain usage. Not the answer to our halve problems (1/10)
- John Morris: Works hard. Not suited to halves. Another guy in the twilight of his career. Not the future (3/10)
- Kade Snowden: Post origin blues it seems. Looks a little down on confidence. BIG future though. Kept trying (3/10)
- Luke Douglas: Down on confidence. Did not dominate. Still trying. Up there in tackle count (3/10)
- Grant Millington: Always tries. Good bench player for next year. (3/10)
- Anthony Tupou: Again MIA. Where is the $400k per year player??? (2/10)
- Josh Cordoba: Tried hard. Did ok off bench. (3/10)
- Lancen Juodo: Did he play? (1/10)
- Taulima Tautai: Same as Juodo (1/10)
- Siosaia Vave: Good go forward. (2/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

Shark68

Bull Shark
Joined
Mar 27, 2008
Messages
2,052
Reaction score
18
Shark68's ratings for Cronulla vs Manly (NRL Premiership, Round 19, 2010)

3 Points - Nathan Gardner (7/10)
2 Points - Paul Gallen (7/10)
1 Point - Paul Aiton (7/10)

- Isaac Gordon (4/10)
- Dean Collis (5/10)
- Ben Pomeroy (5/10)
- Luke Covell (4/10)
- Tim Smith (4/10)
- John Morris (6/10)
- Kade Snowden (7/10)
- Luke Douglas (7/10)
- Grant Millington (7/10)
- Anthony Tupou (6/10)
- Josh Cordoba (7/10)
- Lancen Juodo (5/10)
- Taulima Tautai (4/10)
- Siosaia Vave (6/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

ROB SHARK

Great White
Joined
Apr 8, 2009
Messages
2,633
Reaction score
6
Location
Shire
ROB SHARK's ratings for Cronulla vs Manly (NRL Premiership, Round 19, 2010)

3 Points - Nathan Gardner: Made some stupid errors, but tried hard and his try was great. (8/10)
2 Points - Paul Gallen: Usual solid effort from gal, good to see him get a try as well (7/10)
1 Point - Josh Cordoba: Tried hard, scored, went froward well. (6/10)

- Isaac Gordon (5/10)
- Dean Collis (5/10)
- Ben Pomeroy (5/10)
- Luke Covell (6/10)
- Tim Smith (1/10)
- John Morris (4/10)
- Kade Snowden (5/10)
- Paul Aiton (7/10)
- Luke Douglas (5/10)
- Grant Millington (5/10)
- Anthony Tupou (5/10)
- Lancen Juodo (3/10)
- Taulima Tautai (3/10)
- Siosaia Vave (5/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

A.Snowden

Jaws
Joined
Jun 17, 2009
Messages
15,838
Reaction score
156
Location
Mac Fields Represent
A.Snowden's ratings for Cronulla vs Manly (NRL Premiership, Round 19, 2010)

3 Points - Paul Aiton (7/10)
2 Points - Paul Gallen (7/10)
1 Point - Nathan Gardner (7/10)

- Isaac Gordon (5/10)
- Dean Collis (5/10)
- Ben Pomeroy (5/10)
- Luke Covell (5/10)
- Tim Smith (5/10)
- John Morris (5/10)
- Kade Snowden (6/10)
- Luke Douglas (7/10)
- Grant Millington (6/10)
- Anthony Tupou (5/10)
- Josh Cordoba (7/10)
- Taulima Tautai (5/10)
- Siosaia Vave (6/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top